Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Finishes - Marcs Shootout

Featured Replies

http://www.thewoodwhisperer.com/videos/wiping-varnish-shootout/

If you have not seen it yet, here it is.

Did this change anyone's mind on finishes? I did find it interesting that ARS seemed better on darker woods and Waterlox seemed a little better on lighter woods. With some exceptions. 

I found it a good learning session and helped me find a clearer way to finish  on certain things that I never thought of before.

Marc is right though .. all finishes on their own without seeing the others side by side look pretty good. Only seeing them all side by side could you really see the differences.

 

... Also, anyone use that bloxygen stuff that he uses?

I've never used Waterlox products but after watching the video...I'll be sticking with ARS for my go-to wiping varnish.  It's the clear winner in that shootout...plus it's the cheapest (hard to believe).

I wish he would have done all the tests with satin sheen.  I have no interest in anything gloss.

28 minutes ago, Eric. said:

I've never used Waterlox products but after watching the video...I'll be sticking with ARS for my go-to wiping varnish.  It's the clear winner in that shootout...plus it's the cheapest (hard to believe).

That was the big surprise to me. I knew Minwax had been creeping up their prices, but never realized they'd surpassed GF. Of course, if the two products are that close in performance, it's hard to fault them.

Quote

I wish he would have done all the tests with satin sheen.  I have no interest in anything gloss.

I agree with you, I don't like gloss. On the other hand I think the visual comparison is a lot easier when looking at glossy finishes. The pore-filling and clarity information for instance would be very hard to show with a satin finish.

Marc did a great job on this.  Since I live in a state that people like to move to from somewhere else, get into politics and make up all sorts of silly rules, I cannot buy Waterlox or ARS.  I mix my own and also prefer a non-gloss finish.  I do use a gloss varnish in the blend but, rub it back.

Minwax is the only contender that is locally available.  I can get ARS by going to the big city.

I'm ok with Minwax, but one of my refinishing projects did come out a bit on the glossy side - maybe "plastic" looking.  I'll probably pick up some ARS on my next trip to WoodCraft.  I've seen that WoodCraft has ARS on sale from time to time.

[edit:  Thanks to BW for posting!  I would likely have missed the shootout article, and no, I'd never heard of Bloxygen.]

More than anything else I was impressed that ARS is cheaper than the minwax wipe-on. I guess I'd always just assumed specialty meant expensive, but evidently not!

14 minutes ago, Denette said:

More than anything else I was impressed that ARS is cheaper than the minwax wipe-on. I guess I'd always just assumed specialty meant expensive, but evidently not!

The prices listed are for ARS (quart) versus Minwax (pint), which is probably the most readily available sizes.  They're about the same $/oz if you get them in the same sizes (pints or quarts), but ARS seems easier to find in quart sizes.  ARS, tho, is available in gallons at a very low price/ounce.

As for changing my mind - hmm...maybe its dimmed my thoughts about trying Waterlox (as I've never used it) but the shoot-out mostly reinforced my existing thoughts about Minwax versus ARS.  I like both - a lot- and have used a lot of Minwax with great results - using semi gloss or satin...I don't use gloss so maybe I just avoid the "plastic" look that seems to be a common complaint with the minwax gloss.  My preferred finishing tho is still ARS (semi or satin).

Not really, but mostly because I have used/tested most of these finishes.  

Are more interesting 2.0 study would be testing across types of finish.  Danish Oil vs Poly Varnish vs Phenolic Varnish vs Shellac vs Nitro Lacquer va CAB acrylic vs Pre Cat vs Water.   A representative brand from each category would be fine, because the formulations from brand to brand don't differ much.   They really are  no trade secrets, as much as the coatings i dustry would like to make you think otherwise.  They all buy their ingredients (oils, resins, dryers, solvents) from the same suppliers, and those suppliers do most of the real R&D   

 

 

Great point, Mike. I would love more info on the last three you just mentioned. 

 

I find waterlox is very easy and forgiving to apply by hand. I only used ARS once or twice, but i much prefer waterlox to minwax products. Also, i dont want to hurt business for bloxygen, but if you crush the can then the finish wont cure. My waterlox cans look like they were run over several times. 

Not really, but mostly because I have used/tested most of these finishes.  

Are more interesting 2.0 study would be testing across types of finish.  Danish Oil vs Poly Varnish vs Phenolic Varnish vs Shellac vs Nitro Lacquer va CAB acrylic vs Pre Cat vs Water.   A representative brand from each category would be fine, because the formulations from brand to brand don't differ much.   They really are  no trade secrets, as much as the coatings i dustry would like to make you think otherwise.  They all buy their ingredients (oils, resins, dryers, solvents) from the same suppliers, and those suppliers do most of the real R&D   

 

 

Quick, shine the Maple Leaf light on the moon! We need to summon Matthias Wandel!

1 minute ago, Denette said:

Quick, shine the Maple Leaf light on the moon! We need to summon Matthias Wandel!

Bah.  He'd probably try to make his own finishes with household chemicals.  It would take ten times as long and look twenty times worse, but it would only cost you tree fitty a gallon.  No thanks.

Bah.  He'd probably try to make his own finishes with household chemicals.  It would take ten times as long and look twenty times worse, but it would only cost you tree fitty a gallon.  No thanks.

Hahaha, probably! I do appreciate how thorough some of his tests have been, though. Doing extensive testing of joint strength, glue strength, shop lighting, and similar things are where he shines. I agree that most of what he makes is pretty unappealing.

  • Popular Post
15 minutes ago, Denette said:

Hahaha, probably! I do appreciate how thorough some of his tests have been, though. Doing extensive non scientific, for (mild) entertainment purposes only testing, with a distinct odor of condescension and smugness, of joint strength, glue strength, shop lighting, and similar things are where he shines. 

FTFY :)

 

mattias is a punk.  I thought Calliou was my least favorite Canadian, and then he came on the scene.  

  • Author
5 hours ago, Pwk5017 said:

Also, i dont want to hurt business for bloxygen, but if you crush the can then the finish wont cure. My waterlox cans look like they were run over several times. 

Crush them? Like make it to where the finish is at the top by the lid and then you are good?

32 minutes ago, bushwacked said:

Crush them? Like make it to where the finish is at the top by the lid and then you are good?

I think that's what he means.   If you can remove as much as the atmosphere from the container, it will reduce the amount of curing that occur.   So like a collapsible bladder would be the ideal container, if you could find one that won't react with whatever you are storing in it.

Marc has covered bloxygen on the show a few times, and they usually recommend a cheaper alternative.  If you have access to argon or nitrogen in a gas bottle, a couple spritz of that would work.  In the long run, getting a small bottle of inert gas is far cheaper than using bloxygen over the same time period, but the initial outlay is MUCH higher.  CO2 is supposed to work well also I've read, so if you can get those paintball gun cartridges to fire into the finish can, you'll be good to go.  I've been using those canned air duster's, and have yet to have any finish go bad, but I don't think I've been doing this long enough to tell yet :).  I also pour my finish into a smaller container (like an old plastic sour cream jar or a generic ketchup squeeze bottle, and I'll get 4-5 uses from that before I have to open up the mother can again.

As to Matthias... what else do you expect from a Canadian engineer on a budget?

Its not Mattias' cheap projects that bother me.  It is his sanctimonious attitude.  And he took a potshot at @thewoodwhisperer, so he is persona non grata in my book.  

Bah.  He'd probably try to make his own finishes with household chemicals.  It would take ten times as long and look twenty times worse, but it would only cost you tree fitty a gallon.  No thanks.

I've never seen him use anything but Varathane, when the label shows at all. His gig is more of engineering interest, than 'fine' furniture building.

  • Popular Post
3 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said:

I've never seen him use anything but Varathane, when the label shows at all. His gig is more of engineering interest, than 'fine' furniture building.

Yeah, I know.  I get it.  But

 

mtmpu.jpg

Its not Mattias' cheap projects that bother me.  It is his sanctimonious attitude.  And he took a potshot at @thewoodwhisperer, so he is persona non grata in my book.  

Good point. He is just the first person who came to mind on the topic of super analytical tests related to woodworking.

On 2017-6-2 at 10:19 AM, Eric. said:

I've never used Waterlox products but after watching the video...I'll be sticking with ARS for my go-to wiping varnish.  It's the clear winner in that shootout...plus it's the cheapest (hard to believe).

I wish he would have done all the tests with satin sheen.  I have no interest in anything gloss.

After Eric's praise, I bought a few cans of ars a while ago. I have used minwax wipe on for ages, with excellent results.

I found that I liked the minwax more, and used up the ars before it expired. I find that the minwax dries to a nicer satin sheen, and I also find it less oduress. Maybe I'll go back and give ars a third try, as there must be something I am missing with all the praise it gets from woodworkers I respect.

8 minutes ago, Pug said:

After Eric's praise, I bought a few cans of ars a while ago. I have used minwax wipe on for ages, with excellent results.

I found that I liked the minwax more, and used up the ars before it expired. I find that the minwax dries to a nicer satin sheen, and I also find it less oduress. Maybe I'll go back and give ars a third try, as there must be something I am missing with all the praise it gets from woodworkers I respect.

its like coke and pepsi.  both variations of sugar and water.  neither one is inherently better.  just a little different. 

The more you get into other finishes (lacquers, waterbase, shellac) the more you realize all oil polys are basically the same with subtle differences. 

5 minutes ago, Mike. said:

The more you get into other finishes (lacquers, waterbase, shellac) the more you realize all oil polys are basically the same with subtle differences. 

Both of my "go to" finishes are poly - minwax wipe on satin (oil), and general finished high performance poly (water).

I have used many others (lacquer, true oils, shellac, etc) but find the ones I mentioned above have an excellent balance of ease of application, availability, and durability.

I am not sure GF high performance is really a poly.   They call it that for marketing purposes but I think the resin is mostly acrylic.  It contains very little urethane.   It is still a great product, and I like it, but calling it poly is like calling corn syrup "sugar".  GF makes great products but they basically lie about what is inside.   

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.