Recommended Posts

Posted
1 hour ago, Dhankx said:

The powermatic has some really bad sounding 1 stars on amazon...

I have trouble believing them.  Look at the reviews on the 54hh, it's the same machine with a different cutter.  I know a few here have the 54hh and love it.  I can't explain the poor reviews, but they don't make sense to me. 

  • Like 2
Posted

My PM has mediocre reviews too and it's the top tits model. If you look closely most of the complaints are about delivery or minor issues that are more about uninformed users rather than legitimate problems.

 

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

 

 

Posted

One more check on this as I'm about 1-2 weeks away from pulling the trigger.  I'm sold on the Rigid 4512 table saw, Powermatic 54a jointer and Dewalt 735 Planer as referenced . Is there something significantly better if I'm willing to pay more for it?  Am I sane to believe that I can manage with rolling the table saw and planer outside and just use a shop vac for the jointer so that I can avoid investing in an expensive DC system?  I'm not in a neighborhood, rather private wooded 3 acre lot so noise or the ability to blow dust around outside won't be a problem :) . 

Posted
4 minutes ago, Dhankx said:

One more check on this as I'm about 1-2 weeks away from pulling the trigger.  I'm sold on the Rigid 4512 table saw, Powermatic 54a jointer and Dewalt 735 Planer as referenced . Is there something significantly better if I'm willing to pay more for it?  Am I sane to believe that I can manage with rolling the table saw and planer outside and just use a shop vac for the jointer so that I can avoid investing in an expensive DC system?  I'm not in a neighborhood, rather private wooded 3 acre lot so noise or the ability to blow dust around outside won't be a problem :) . 

I think they're solid purchases.  I wouldn't wanna woodwork without a cabinet saw but plenty of people get by with less.

Posted
2 hours ago, Dhankx said:

One more check on this as I'm about 1-2 weeks away from pulling the trigger.  I'm sold on the Rigid 4512 table saw, Powermatic 54a jointer and Dewalt 735 Planer as referenced . Is there something significantly better if I'm willing to pay more for it?  Am I sane to believe that I can manage with rolling the table saw and planer outside and just use a shop vac for the jointer so that I can avoid investing in an expensive DC system?  I'm not in a neighborhood, rather private wooded 3 acre lot so noise or the ability to blow dust around outside won't be a problem :) . 

 

I think those are all solid choices too! I am little hesitant on the 4512 but for your first table saw I think it will do just fine, especially because you are wanting to buy a planer and a jointer at the same time. There are significantly better saws but if you are going through Amazon, your choices are limited. Not sure if anyone has already asked but do you have 220?

I would spend the extra money getting the mobile base for the planer. Like someone mentioned before DC can be had for pretty cheap. Even if you plan on rolling the table saw and planer outside, some DC would still be worthwhile. 

Posted
38 minutes ago, jmaichel said:

I think those are all solid choices too! I am little hesitant on the 4512 but for your first table saw I think it will do just fine, especially because you are wanting to buy a planer and a jointer at the same time. There are significantly better saws but if you are going through Amazon, your choices are limited. Not sure if anyone has already asked but do you have 220?

I would spend the extra money getting the mobile base for the planer. Like someone mentioned before DC can be had for pretty cheap. Even if you plan on rolling the table saw and planer outside, some DC would still be worthwhile. 

What's 220? Yep I plan on getting the mobile base for the planer

 

i only do 1 project every month or 3 as it's truly a "as I have time" hobby, I have found slowing myself down leads me to obsessively plan a lot of details. It's all stuff for me so I'm in no rush (which means I don't mind cleaning up my mess also)

Posted

I was in the same position as you. I went with the DeWalt TS. I really wanted the Ridgid but all I could find was issues with the fence and the blade going out of parallel. 

As much as I wanted it I simply didn't want to chance it. For every 1 positive review were 10 negative and always over the fence. 

The dewalt on the other hand had nothing but positive reviews. Can except dados and has ZCI available. I've yet to use either but overall I've been super happy with it. It's in its stand currently and will get its own table soon. 

The 735 is awesome as well. It's onh it's own cabinet. It is a beast. 

IMG_5562.JPG

IMG_5629.JPG

IMG_5620.JPG

  • Like 1
Posted

I used to have a Dewalt TS.  It was a great little machine for what it is made for...taking to jobsites to do flooring and what not.  I liked the rack and pinion fence and the dust shroud.  I'd never want to use it if it was my primary tablesaw now though.  Ever.  I upgraded from the Dewalt to a very used Ridgid that I bought off craigslist for $250.  It was a huge improvement.  I've since upgraded again, but it was mostly due to dust control...the old Ridgid never let me down, and I KNOW the new machines are better than what I had.

  • Like 1
Posted
On 7/16/2017 at 10:11 PM, Dhankx said:

Is this thing really required to go along with it like the site suggests? Saw some comments about needing it

Required? No.  Useful?  somewhat.  I have one on my 735, and I like it.  This one was a gift.....but if I was budget constrained I wouldn't necessarily get one.

Posted
10 hours ago, jmaichel said:

I think those are all solid choices too! I am little hesitant on the 4512 but for your first table saw I think it will do just fine, especially because you are wanting to buy a planer and a jointer at the same time. There are significantly better saws but if you are going through Amazon, your choices are limited. Not sure if anyone has already asked but do you have 220?

I would spend the extra money getting the mobile base for the planer. Like someone mentioned before DC can be had for pretty cheap. Even if you plan on rolling the table saw and planer outside, some DC would still be worthwhile. 

The Emerson motor in the Ridgid can be wired either way. It's a simple process.

 

fwiw, I'd like to replace my (4511) granite top with a cast iron top and let someone who prefers the granite buy it. It's massive.

Posted

As @BillyDoubleU I was in the same position as you are four years ago, and the Bosch was also in consideration, mostly because I own some "Blue Bosch" tools and was always satisfied even with 15 years old ones. BUT, I choosed the Dewalt DW745, for the price, and for the rack and pinion fence (which is the idea of the century IMHO). I made a cabinet for it which I still use :

DW745_37.jpg

For those who can be interested, here's the free plans for my DeWalt DW745 station. The only thing I changed was I replaced the wheels by adjustable feet and moved the power button to a side. At the start, I took some time to square the blade to the track and the fence, then it never moved. So you can consider the DW745 do the job and last. During more than four years this was (and still is) my main table saw, and it worked with no issue at all. I used it a lot, mostly for furniture but also for aluminum and plastics.

Am I totally pleased with this saw ? In a way I am, because this is a saw under 500€ and it does a very accurate job for the price and I love the fence system. The power is pretty enough to pass 75mm (3") of pine or 35mm (1.3") of dry hardwood in a single pass. I would say 90% of the time you don't worry about power.

In another hand, this is a job site saw, and you have to deal with unpleasant things. First, this saw is incredibly noisy (112db!), when I turn it on, the future also turn for all the neighborhood. Really. Second, there's absolutely no way to collect dust efficiently. Every cut is a mess. There's a 65mm dust port, I dunno if it's a standard in the US, but in EC that matches with nothing. Imagine you find a way to connect any dust collection unit, you won't be helped that much. You will be able to catch the dust sitting in the bottom of the blade's carter, but don't event think to catch more. The upper size of the  blade compartment is widely open except a piece of fabric on the left side meant to help in a hypothetic way. So you need to count on the blade guard to catch a maximum of dust. Unfortunately even with a second vacuum unit on the guard port, you only catch about 50% of the dust coming upside, which represents only a few of the overall dust produced. 80% of the dust goes under the top. It blows out of the saw and maybe 40% lays under anyways. Finally, only 30% of the dust can be collected by vacuum. The underside is not sealed, and I did not find any way to seal it up because of the tubular geometry of the saw, the complex shape of the underneath, the tilting mechanism, and so on. As I'm not a duck tape fan, only a custom latex thing could do the job if you could find a way to hold it. So, my sweep and dusting skills greatly improved during the last four years. I'm a dusty wood dummy at the end of each cutting session. A link to sealed glasses with whippers would be greatly appreciated.

I'm kidding but this is the real thing. I wish this saw would breakdown, be dangerous or do awry cuts to change it. But the worst thing is : this baby cuts properly. I should not have been so cheap. I will probably use this saw during years. I miscalculate the noise generation and the dust collection is just a nightmare. On the other hand, this is a pretty good saw on a budget, and I should probably pay at least 3 times the price to get a proper workshop saw. If you can, save money and buy a proper workshop saw.

Posted
1 hour ago, wdwerker said:

Granite don't rust !

True.

But a 400 lb table saw is fun to roll, even on good wheels.

Also ... for anyone looking at using their built-in wheel solution (Ridgid calls it Hercu-lift), I found it too much of a center system so that the granite becomes top-heavy. That's not a good balance. One time I rolled it just a bit too quickly and hit a piece of something. Had me worried for a second. Were I in a hurryit would have toppled. Nobody would have been hurt, but the granite would certainly have broken. IOW, get another base.

Posted

I had a Dewalt DWE7480...   It was a good little saw.   The fence was really easy to use and accurate.   Using thin-kerf blades it's pretty powerful as well.

It's great for ripping.  What it's not great for is crosscuts... there isn't much table to support your piece before you hit the blade.   Even with a crosscut sled, it's a challenge.

Then there's the shakiness... I had the scissors stand and had to put bags of sand or salt on the bottom to keep it in place and still it wobbled around.

A lot of people build tables around it, like what Jean posted above.   You really pretty much have to do that otherwise it's unstable and moves around too much.   I considered this... but by the time you do this, it's now takes up a lot of space and you've spent a couple hundred dollars more on plywood, casters and such.   Also, while most of these tables have support on sides and rear, I think you need support in the front as well.

I was going to buy the Delta table saw sold at Lowes... it's similar price to the Ridgid but has a biesemeyer style fence(not a great one, it's a two piece rail with aluminum fence, but).   I ended up waiting a year and buying a Sawstop PCS instead, but I realize not everyone can afford that.

 

  • Like 2
Posted
15 hours ago, Dhankx said:

What's 220? Yep I plan on getting the mobile base for the planer

 

i only do 1 project every month or 3 as it's truly a "as I have time" hobby, I have found slowing myself down leads me to obsessively plan a lot of details. It's all stuff for me so I'm in no rush (which means I don't mind cleaning up my mess also)

220, is 220V(bigger power tools run off 220) but for now we won't even worry about that. I am like you, I don't do a lot of projects in a year.  I would definitely say skip any of the smaller bench top saws. They are Just not worth it! Are you going through HD for the Ridgid 4512? 

 

Posted
2 hours ago, jmaichel said:

220, is 220V(bigger power tools run off 220) but for now we won't even worry about that. I am like you, I don't do a lot of projects in a year.  I would definitely say skip any of the smaller bench top saws. They are Just not worth it! Are you going through HD for the Ridgid 4512? 

 

Yep that's the plan, I'll order from a store that has it in stock and do an in store pickup and use paypal 6 months no interest . Will feel better with at least 1 piece not shipped to me!

Posted
8 hours ago, Jfitz said:

Required? No.  Useful?  somewhat.  I have one on my 735, and I like it.  This one was a gift.....but if I was budget constrained I wouldn't necessarily get one.

So is the jist of it this? You get a digital readout of the exact width so if you have to get back to that width later on you aren't guessing? 

Posted

I used a cardboard box to catch jointer shavings for years.  Find a box that comes up to the top of the outlet chute.  Cut a rectangle cutout on the end that goes against the outlet.  It'll catch most of it, if you remember to empty it when it gets close to being full.

I've never used that Rigid saw.  I have used the little Delta that belongs to a friend of mine.  I have no use for a saw that small.  I do like fine adjustments on a table saw fence, but it doesn't compare to the one that used to come on Powermatic saws with round rails.  Even years later, after putting a Biesmeyer on the Unisaw, I still find myself reaching for the fine adjustment knob that's not there.

Posted

If you're ordering the Ridgid saw online do a chat first and ask Home Depot if they'll give you a discount. They've been able to do 10% the few times I've asked for it.

I have the Craftsman version and like it. I got it used with an aftermarket fence so I can't comment on the fence, but I like the rest of it.

Initially I was going to buy a jobsite saw, but the blade is so close to the front of the saw it scares me too much.

  • Like 1
Posted
17 hours ago, Dhankx said:

So is the jist of it this? You get a digital readout of the exact width so if you have to get back to that width later on you aren't guessing? 

Pretty much.  Yet I also still use my dial caliper to make sure I'm where I want to be.

I find that I use it more when progressing through the milling....to know how much I'm taking off from pass to pass.  Of course I can also just count on knowing how much each turn of the handle lowers the cutter head - but it's just another way of knowing.  And once it's dialed it, it is pretty accurate so the dial calipers wouldn't be needed I guess.....just a belt and suspenders approach.

Posted

My two cents...

grizzly 490 jointer.  8" jointers are handy.  If you feel a 6" jointer will be sufficient look for a used one.  I suspect the quantity of used 6" jointers comes from a later discovered need for 8" or more.   I've used my 490x for 4 years now and I'm glad that I didn't spend more.  But...not everyone has the same experience with Grizzly.  

Not sure you can use this without a dust collector   Consider harbor freights 2hp unit  for  $169.  Even though you're working outside, keeping the chips out of your jointer and planer is important for accuracy.

I'd also recommend you consider the Grizzly hybrid saw but I don't have experience with it or the other TS mentioned.  I suspect their hybrid saw would keep you satisfied longer than a contractors saw...but that's just speculation.   

Add the Dewalt 735 planet and I think that you would still be under $3k   

 

 

   

 

Posted
1 hour ago, Patrick said:

Add the Dewalt 735 planet and I think that you would still be under $3k  

 

Extra-terrestrial real estate must be going cheap these days.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 33 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined