Recommended Posts

Posted

For those of you who don't know, I work in the paper industry.  I just got the following:

U.S. forests grew by 2,740 NFL football fields each day!
Between 2005 and 2015, U.S. forests grew by the equivalent of 2,740 NFL football fields each day. That’s a total of almost 1.3 million acres a year! 
In the U.S., we grow many more trees than we harvest. Yet, our nation consumes more paper products than many parts of the world. How can this be?
 

Source: twosidesna.org

The same is true for the woods we use in our projects when purchased from sustainable sources.  Even the wood we purchase from small, independent loggers is offset in some way and the small, independents tend to use methods and practices that are more economically and environmentally friendly because they understand that if they deplete their sources they effect their livelihoods in the long run.

  • Like 1
Posted

Isn't there a shortage currently in the paper industry for the higher quality papers that are used in book making? I was reading about that because a book i per-ordered was delayed because of said shortage.

The truth of the matter is most trees aren't removed to be used they are cut down for development or to make way for farming. Most of the trees removed are in rain forests to make way for farming. Those areas aren't the best for farming either and the trees take a long time to recover. I also think it's interesting that we grow more than we can harvest but still import a lot of wood from Canada.

Some ad showed up for me for sugarcane or bamboo toilet paper and paper towels. The ad talked about how many trees were harvested a day just to make these products, it was obviously being conveyed like it was a terrible thing. I think it'd be interesting to include the number of trees that are removed for development, people wouldn't worry about harvesting for paper products anymore. In some areas around MN there are incentives for developers to minimize the amount of trees that are removed for development, not always sure that's for the best. There is some research that concluded that this practice made the fires in CA more damaging and endangered more lives.

Posted

And not all trees are equal.  Was that old growth Longleaf Pine replaced with a Loblolly sapling?  Or a walnut tree with a poplar.  I'm guessing the article was specfic to the paper industry and not talking about furniture lumber.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Thanks!  That was very interesting.  You'll be glad to know (well actually you probably won't care) that I refuse all forms of non-paper billing.  If a creditor wants to get paid they have to mail a paper bill.  In return I mail a paper check.  

And if someone wants me to give up turning wood, plan B is acrylics, which I'm not sure is an improvement. 

But still I will say when you pick up a nice piece of wood you gotta show it some respect.

  • Like 2
Posted
54 minutes ago, Mark J said:

Thanks!  That was very interesting.  You'll be glad to know (well actually you probably won't care) that I refuse all forms of non-paper billing.  If a creditor wants to get paid they have to mail a paper bill.  In return I mail a paper check.  

But still I will say when you pick up a nice piece of wood you gotta show it some respect.

Amen bud! 

  • Like 2
Posted
2 hours ago, Byrdie said:

Bills paid online require fewer persons to process them and, as a result, lower need for benefits and the other associated costs of having an employee.  Simply put, paying your bills online, no matter how convenient it may seem, costs jobs.

Costs a job in one place and creates a job in another not 1:1 but unemployment can't really go much lower. I have a few friends that work for a software company that a specifically tailored to creating software to do this. Losing a low skill job and gaining a higher paid skill job is a trade I'll make every day. I'm a millineal (yeah i can't even be bothered to look up the proper spelling) so I envision the US as a different place than those of the generations that were before me. I'd rather see better jobs than just more crappy jobs that people hate working. Folding bills and stuffing envelopes is a crappy job I've done it.

Also yes it is in their best profit interest but also there is a non zero environmental benefit to paperless billing that is being downplayed. The energy it takes to produce the printer/toner, ect. Also the fuel for the delivery vehicle. Though i fully 100% agree they do it to increase profit. I appreciate paperless billing, i don't want a paper bill.... I'd rather have more paper for books and better things than a stupid bill.

The big thing it sounds like companies are afraid to do right now is raise their prices. It's so interesting cause the economists are wondering why inflation hasn't been increasing. Part of me thinks this is still ripples from the recession of 2008.

Also it is worth noting that all the people responsible for the two sides website are/were big wigs at paper production companies.... Their info is well cited and is detailed and from a brief overview accurate but there is a perspective from the people that run the organization. I don't think they are trying to mislead us nor does the site have a nefarious intent but it's worth noting that they do have a perspective on the topic.

  • Like 2
Posted

@Chestnut, those tablets do cost a fair amount, but a kid just needs 1 to hold a library full of books, and those books can be updated every day, if necessary. Over the lang term, I can see the justification.

But I share your opinion. Reading from paper and writing on same should be a requirement.

  • Like 2
Posted
19 hours ago, Byrdie said:

I guess where I was bugged is I posted a message that I thought would be received in a positive way here.  We all depend on wood, there are those who would like us to stop using wood, and the truth is wood is a renewable, sustainable and growing resource.  Instead what i got was responses that were critical of the message and the source of the message.

I have been meaning to reply to your original post, but haven't had the time to sit down and type it out until now. I really appreciate the info that you provided and am reassured by it. With a 2 year old, I recently was feeling like we were single handedly destroying the forests with all the paper towels and other paper products we use to clean up this or clean up that, plus all the cardboard boxes from ordering things online since it can be a huge hassle to take a 2yo shopping. And like most, I constantly see articles or messages regarding "Going Green" and reducing paper usage because of all the trees being cut. So thank you for reminding me that there is always another side of the story. I now have bookmarked some additional articles and resources to further inform myself.

I should have been more informed, especially since I have some connections to the paper industries. My father's business, which I have worked for in the past and may work for again in the future, includes a brand of artists papers. My step mother used to work for a company that owns a lot of timber land and does a lot of recycling operations with various paper and wood products. And one of the companies I currently work for leases a large amount of warehouse space to a couple well-known paper and cardboard product companies, and while they are not critical to our ongoing stability, we would hate for them to have to shut down their operations in our area.

My (small) company is largely paperless, but not for environmental reasons. We all live and work in different areas and need access to all of the documents. It certainly doesn't make sense to drive 5-10 hours to pull some documents from a filing cabinet. While it would help support other workers along the way, it also would not make sense to constantly mail the documents back and forth.

As someone mentioned, not all trees are equal, and this is a good thing. I don't think it would be good for us woodworkers if walnut, cherry, maple, oak, etc were preferred for making paper products! Each wood products industry, as well as other groups or agencies, have an interest in keeping the various species renewable and managed properly. Yes, development clears a lot of area that was previously or could be forest land, but the portion of land that is developed in the US is still quite small. I'd imagine that pests and diseases are a bigger threat to the trees than anything else.

 

tldr; Thank you for your original post and subsequent replies with additional info, I appreciate it and have benefited from it.

  • Thanks 1
Posted
On 1/31/2019 at 9:55 PM, Byrdie said:

So I get the point of convenience of paperless billing.  Let me also point out where you're correct about the job loss not being 1:1 - 

There's the mail house that sorts the files, prints the bills, meters and sorts the mail and delivers it to the post office.  There's the paper mill that made the paper that your invoice was printed on.  There's the lumber worker that harvested the wood that went into the pulp to make the paper.  There's the logistic company (trucker) that moved the lumber to them mill.  There's the logistics company that moved the paper to the merchant that sold the paper to the printer (very few printers have the capacity to purchase directly from a mill so there's a middle industry to facilitate those purchases).  There's the mailman who delivers the invoice to your house and the postal employee who picks up and/or sorts your return mail.  I'm sure I left some out but you get the point.

After all that, there's the employee who might lose their job to the software developer that would be making software for processing the invoice whether or not a body was involved.

Yup.  Not exactly 1:1

Just in case you think I'm a little passionate about this, I've been laid off twice.  The second time for 9 months.  I was in the position where I worried about losing my place to live, my place to keep the few tools I'd worked so hard to get, the ability to pay for my own food.  As much as some feel I was entitled to it, taking unemployment left a bad taste in my mouth and I was deeply humbled by having to go to a food bank and accept charity.

So when I hear some fat cat CEO say, "We have to protect our shareholders." or lie to the general public about why they want you to go paperless.  When I hear any excuse to cut jobs, it kinda strikes a nerve.

Shareholders are gamblers.  They put their money into an investment hoping it'll have a return.  But every prospectus tells them there are no guarantees.  Employees, on the other hand, are not gamblers.  They put their faith in a company that if they continue to do their job well, they get to come back and do it again and be rewarded for it with income.

I’ve been laid off before too, it does stink, however this line of argument leads to all sorts of weird conclusions. We shouldn’t have backhoes, because they replace the work of a dozen guys with shovels. Better yet, drop the shovels and we can employ 1000 people using spoons. 

  • Like 1
Posted
52 minutes ago, Isaac said:

I’ve been laid of before too, it does stink, however this line of arguement leads to all sorts of weird conclusions. We shouldn’t have backhoes, because they replace the work of a dozen guys with shovels. Better yet, drop the shovels and we can employ 1000 people using spoons. 

This is truly the silliest tool to pick while making your point. The employees in manufacture, service, and repair equal the shovel pushers. You do have a point. I just think you picked a poor example:)

Posted
2 hours ago, Tpt life said:

This is truly the silliest tool to pick while making your point. The employees in manufacture, service, and repair equal the shovel pushers. You do have a point. I just think you picked a poor example:)

I don't agree, even about the shovels, but it is pretty difficult for either of us to really verify. Do you at least agree that the spoon users would far exceed the shovel or backhoe users and related workers?

But yes, of course we could make it about woodworker tools if you prefer. Get rid of all of our power tools and make every chair, desk, cabinet and bed, purely with hand tools. Think about how long it takes to plane a single board using a power planer vs. doing it purely by hand.  

Posted
4 hours ago, JohnG said:

the portion of land that is developed in the US is still quite small. I'd imagine that pests and diseases are a bigger threat to the trees than anything else.

I guess what do you consider developed? I personally feel that most of the land in the US has seen some sort of development. With agriculture being a development of sorts. There are some data sources that claim that ag generates more CO2 than it removes.

13 hours ago, wtnhighlander said:

@Chestnut, those tablets do cost a fair amount, but a kid just needs 1 to hold a library full of books, and those books can be updated every day, if necessary. Over the lang term, I can see the justification.

But I share your opinion. Reading from paper and writing on same should be a requirement.

I don't know how the book licensing works honestly a lot of the digital version requires x number of licenses or services. So yeah you can access a lot of data from one device but the people that print the textbooks and generate the information still want their royalty money. Yeah you don't have to carry around the books but with all the news reports of children being overweight ect maybe they need to lug around some old school textbooks....

I don't know what the costs of all this are and i doubt the schools will share it with us. I don't even think the teachers know, I've asked.

We for sure should give them shoves and make them dig a hole so they appreciate the technological advance that a shovel has over a spoon :P.

23 hours ago, Byrdie said:

I guess where I was bugged is I posted a message that I thought would be received in a positive way here.  We all depend on wood, there are those who would like us to stop using wood, and the truth is wood is a renewable, sustainable and growing resource.  Instead what i got was responses that were critical of the message and the source of the message.

I hope my comments weren't taken as critical. I just wanted to point out the perspective of the source so when reading the information you can know where the writer comes from. Honestly most of the information is from gov sources and the writer did an excellent job of citing their sources and provided accurate information. It's a top notch site and should be praised for not trying to pull the wool over any one's eyes that travel there.

I think the sustainability of paper products is HIGHLY important. I always use paper bags from the grocery store. If they cost more I'll pay it because they can be composted or recycled where as plastic bags are just plain damaging to the environment. They should write about paper bags vs plastic it'd be helpful to try and change that perspective.

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm well aware of, and freely admit that the TwoSidesNA organization is a paper lobby, their intent to promote the paper industry.  However the information they were promoting and that I was passing is based on fact.  There is more forest land now than there was a decade ago. 

As to another part of your discussion, if you explore their website, you'll find they support another one of your arguments.  There have been many studies done that support the idea the persons who use paper based sources for learning and or reading retain better and are better able to find the information after the fact.

  • Like 1
Posted

As an educator, we are finding some workarounds. Paging vs. scrolling and retention of page structure makes some of the retention offset more equal. Scrolling is a Huge enemy to all but screening images. Backlit screens need breaks every fifteen minutes or attention spans max out. We are now training students to take notes as they read digital text, as drawing the eye off of the screen every few minutes resets that 15 minute max. If you truly are interested, look up K Smekens. She does a good job compiling the varied study responses. 

After all that, I still prefer my paper books. Social stuff is all I read on a screen. 

  • Like 2
Posted

Interesting thread. I had a chemical engineer tell me that paper can only be recycled three times. After that it turns to mush. We have a large paper mill in  Calhoun, TN. Its original product was newsprint. With the drop in newspaper sales, they have revamped the plant for a product that is in high demand...toilet paper!

  • Haha 1
Posted
3 hours ago, Bankstick said:

Interesting thread. I had a chemical engineer tell me that paper can only be recycled three times. After that it turns to mush. We have a large paper mill in  Calhoun, TN. Its original product was newsprint. With the drop in newspaper sales, they have revamped the plant for a product that is in high demand...toilet paper!

So how many times can that be recycled? :D

Posted
On 2/1/2019 at 12:28 PM, Byrdie said:

I guess where I was bugged is I posted a message that I thought would be received in a positive way here.  We all depend on wood, there are those who would like us to stop using wood, and the truth is wood is a renewable, sustainable and growing resource.  Instead what i got was responses that were critical of the message and the source of the message.

I've been out of town and just got a chance to see this thread. I can't agree with you more, there are groups out there that would love to see us stop harvesting wood. Your data is something we all should rejoice. I've long thought that the cry of deforestation is a false one in North America. Now I will agree that with tropical rain forests there are issues, but not here in North America. 

We should realize that there should be no guilt in using wood as a resource, a renewable and growing resource. Perhaps access to some species and access to old growth is limited, but we still are in a better position with the resource now than we were decades ago. I also applaud all those woodworkers out there salvaging urban trees and converting them to lumber, but I still think the opportunity exists to make use of trees that fall victim to development.

In doing some superficial research myself I found a number of facts about US forests that should make us all smile;

We have more trees today than we had in 1970, on the first Earth Day  even more than we had 70 years ago.  In the middle of the last century, for example, Vermont, Massachusetts and Connecticut were about 35% forested; today they are 59%.

Forest growth has exceeded harvests since the 1940s.

Even if we could recycle 100% of our used paper, we would still need "virgin" fiber to replace worn out recycled fiber and meet the increasing demand for paper products.  Recycling extends the use of virgin fiber, but it will not replace it.  Even so, today well over half of all fiber used in paper products comes from recycled paper and from wood waste from sawmills.  Recycled wood is another promising source of fiber.

These are just a few facts, a visit to this site highlights a number of myths; https://www.bugwood.org/intensive/myths_and_facts_about_u_s__for.html

 

  • Like 1
Posted
11 hours ago, Bankstick said:

Interesting thread. I had a chemical engineer tell me that paper can only be recycled three times. After that it turns to mush. We have a large paper mill in  Calhoun, TN. Its original product was newsprint. With the drop in newspaper sales, they have revamped the plant for a product that is in high demand...toilet paper!

This is nearly true.  The number I've been given is closer to 7 and it depends on how much virgin pulp is in the mixture.  

Paper has a grain, just like our wood does.  When the pulp comes out of the headbox, it's about 90% water and 10% fiber.  As it goes through the mill it gets squeezed and formed and dried until the percentages are nearly reversed.  As the pulp is deposited on the chain (long conveyor belt) it's shook so that the fibers in the pulp are aligned. It's the length of the fibers and how they overlap that gives paper its strength.  The direction of their orientation is also what gives the paper its grain.

The more times a piece of paper gets recycled, the shorter the pieces of fiber become until they are no longer long enough to overlap properly or give the paper any strength.  By combining virgin and PCW (post consumer waste) the life cycle can be elongated.

Another factor is the types of woods being used.  Papers in the Southern US have a higher percentage of soft woods in them.  This makes the paper softer and more flexible than papers from the Northern US which have a higher percentage of hard woods in them.  The trade of is that the soft woods have a shorter recycling life cycle.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 64 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined