Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Purposely making rustic.

Featured Replies

Hello all,

Lately my wife has been into a rustic phase and keeps begging me to make my projects for around the house "more beat up". I may be alone on this but I have a hell of a time hammering edges or skimming off a shaving or two with my plane on my neatly and perfectly planned out  projects. Since all us married guys know the wife is always right. Right? I was looking for a how to or some sort of guidence on roughing up projects to give it a rustic aged look. Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated! 

David C.

Woodland Renovations

You could run your handplane against the grain here and there to make some tearout, and leave other tool marks for a more authentic look than the stick with nails in it or belt sander.  My wife likes some things where the "distressing" I did is just leaving all the tool marks from the planes, chisels, and saws that I'd otherwise use a scraper to remove.  Also using a scrub or jack you can leave scallops on the surface rather than smoothing it flat.

  • Popular Post

Since all us married guys know the wife is always right. Right?

No, she's wrong.    Ask her if she wants you to give her car the rustic look...maybe put a few dings in it...scratch off some paint....nice scrap marks along the side....crack in the windshield....etc.    If she argues that's different, just call bullshit.   It's exactly the same.    Crap is crap is crap.  If she wouldn't want to be seen in a cheap-looking beat-up car, then why would she want to display cheap-looking beat-up furniture?

     If you wanna get some now and then......Go buy some barnwood and build her what she wants!  Or take up preachin!

     If you wanna get some now and then......Go buy some barnwood and build her what she wants!  Or take up preachin!

I do think this is the right approach.   If you want it to look that way, start with materials like that.    Or just use cheaper material...buy some 1 common or even 2 common lumber and use that...there will be more defects and whatnot in the wood....you could still build a nice piece and just let the lower-quality characteristics of the materials provide the rustic-ness.

Agreed - obtain some lumber that has some character/history in it already. I think the rustic idea is that people want pieces that look as if they have been around for a while, with some battle scars to prove it. The part that I don't understand is that there should be plenty of sources of lumber that can be re-purposed without mangling brand-new stock to do so. It kills me to think of intentionally marring up freshly milled hardwoods - each nick and scratch should be earned with the history of the piece, but that is just my opinion.

The other alternative as well is perhaps find a style that is "less refined" in nature. Not every style is sanded to 1000 grit and coated in high-gloss. In my perception, woods with larger grains and knots, such as ceder and pine, tend to have a more "rustic" feel to them. Or use woods with natural defects that are interesting, such as Ambrosia Maple.

Using satin vs. high-gloss finish to minimize sheen? Matte-finish paints? If the goal is to have something a little more "homely" then producing mirror-finished pieces won't produce that effect.

I would never beat my own piece that I put time and money into with a chain or hammer to fake the history of the piece, just as Vyrolan said you wouldn't intentionally want to scratch up your car.

Edited by Al Capwn
More betterer grammar.

I don't like dents and dings. If you want edge wear or contact point stress, this can be ok. The dents and dings methods I have seen almost always put damage in the wrong places. 

I know nothing about rustic furniture, but I do have a wife... so, we'll see if we can move this downfield a bit... :)

 

If this were my problem, I wouldn't start my journey with finished pieces... That's a sure formula for failure... There is a fine line between rustic and junk and you don't want to cross that line after expending stock/time/effort on a project... I'd find some videos on YouTube covering rustificaiton (if that's a word)... Then get some reasonably-sized stock from the scrap pile and try some techniques for wife-approval... The wife-approval is the key -- she'll identify the rustic/junk boundary... The scrap will unfortunately have to be large to evaluate the rustification (now, it's a word) techniques. Another choice would be to get some of those side tables for $39.95 from the 'unfinished furniture' stores and give that a whack (so to speak)...

Good luck... you'll need it... :)

If she likes that 'Shabby Chic' stuff, give her the credit card and a pottery barn catalog. If she just wants furniture to looked aged, I agree with Carus. Think carefully about where the natural wear points would occur during normal use. I've aged pieces, but always start with a fully-finished "new" piece. Usually, I avoid dents and scratches that just look like abuse. I prefer to simulate wear by careful application of fine (800 grit) sandpaper, usually wet. Most of this wear is to the finish. To get a very old look, wear through to the bare wood, refinish it, and wear some more. But really pay attention to the spots more likely to be worn. Corners and edges, flat surfaces around knobs and pulls, ets. A touch of dark shoe polish, wax type, rubbed into nooks and crannies adds the appearance of built-up grime. Just remember to do it all in moderation.

My wife also just sent me a picture of a beautiful Asian super high sheen coffee table, then asked me if I could make it from barn wood.. I told her sure but I might as well do it from Popsicle sticks since it'll look like chit either way... 

She doesn't approve of this answer.

i doesn't care and aren't going to try something so rediculous.

Edited by Brendon_t

Yeah I blocked my wife computer from pintrist..  saves  me from hey would this look nice  in that room.   i made a joke about how there is a few  women wood workers . so i told her to design and make something .. so far so good

I have a lot of rustic furniture; barn wood and multi-layer milk painted stuff, plus some "mission" furniture which looks like part of the finishing process was to rub dirt on it.
 I work for some folks who used reclaimed wood to do a remodel on their home.

The thing that I think many people who like this style don't consider is that when you make furniture, cabinets, doors, trim, and molding, etc. out of old wood then you have a product that is old already. It has all of the problems(and attributes?) of old stuff the minute it is installed.

Old means splinters.

Old means grimy.

Old means that the surface collects dust that can't be wiped away.

Old means you get gaps, wood movement, and checking right from the get go.

Don't get me wrong...if you like rustic then go for it.

But go into it knowing that you're setting yourself up for scheduling some repairs and such. Worse yet, you may end up trying to fix the problems yourself...

I just made my first table.  I had some cheap wood from home depot so I didn't feel so bad tearing it up. I did the following, and again this is probably a bunch of 'newb' moves but it was my first time and like you said....gotta do what the wife wants.  Once I was done I did a good enough job that I get to buy some new tools :)

  • finally got to buy a blow torch.  That made the biggest different and then heated up some big hex screws and burned them in
  • hammer
  • old saw blades
  • chains
  • gouges with chisel
  • grab anything that is random and hit it as hard as you can

 

I found it rather therapeutic.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.