bleedinblue Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 I made this frame as a pair a couple years ago. Walnut and curly maple. I noticed a few months ago one of the frames' miters had failed. It is a perfect example of why miters need extra reinforcement, and if done by splines, the splines need to be properly sized. I think the failure is interesting and a good learning point. I can't explain why I made these splines this way, I honestly don't remember. Quote
..Kev Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 Makes you wonder if the joint was glue starved as well.. Thanks for sharing! Quote
Andy Wright Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 13 minutes ago, bleedinblue said: I made this frame as a pair a couple years ago. Walnut and curly maple. I noticed a few months ago one of the frames' miters had failed. It is a perfect example of why miters need extra reinforcement, and if done by splines, the splines need to be properly sized. I think the failure is interesting and a good learning point. I can't explain why I made these splines this way, I honestly don't remember. You never really said why you think it failed? Quote
wdwerker Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 If the wood dried out nothing you could do would stop it . The outside point stayed tight so you did your part right. Mother Nature will not be ignored ! 2 Quote
Brendon_t Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 That's a very pretty frame. It does raise some questions though. Are all mitered joints inherently weak? Do all miters require reinforcement? If so, why did yours fail with a spline? If a spline isn't enough, what is enough? I don't believe that all mitre joints are destined for failure. Especially on a light use item like a photo frame. I wonder if there's either more to the story or something you don't know or did inadvertently, maybe wood not totally dry? Thanks for posting. Please let us know how you plan to proceed from there. 1 Quote
bleedinblue Posted May 25, 2016 Author Report Posted May 25, 2016 I figure if I would have done a much deeper spline it would have held together. With the joint holding at the spline, and separating further in, I thought that was a clear sign of that. I took this example as a sign that any spline should go all the way, or most of the way, to the inside of the miter. Maybe my assumption is wrong, and it was purely glue starved? A little more info though, that curly maple was only about a quarter inch thick and is veneered onto pine. Maybe that caused it instead? Of course now I'd drop a domino into each joint and the splines would be purely decorative. Maybe some day I'll fix this frame, probably by doing just that. Quote
wdwerker Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 Deeper spline couldn't hurt but moisture content will not be ignored. Not saying that is absolutely the cause of your gap but highly probable. Quote
treeslayer Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 one of my first frames many years ago failed, it was red oak and when it fell apart it looked like i never used glue at all, glue starved joint, that red oak just sucked all the glue into the end grain. put some hand soap on the end of a 3/4 piece of red oak about 4 inches long and blow in the end, instant bubble machine. now i coat all my miters with a wash of glue and let it dry before the final glue up, no problems since 1 Quote
gee-dub Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 8 hours ago, bleedinblue said: I figure if I would have done a much deeper spline it would have held together. With the joint holding at the spline, and separating further in, I thought that was a clear sign of that. Quite possible but, I too think I am looking at a starved joint. For miters (or other end grain joints that have to have a bit of strength) I spread a thin layer of glue and let it soak in for a minute or two, apply the main layer of glue and assemble. We all dread squeeze out but, in the case of miters it is a good indicator that we have an adequate amount of glue for the job. All that being said, it is a very nice frame. I do agree that mother nature will not be denied; we just have to make her happy. Quote
shaneymack Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 I spread a thin layer of glue and let it soak in for a minute or two, apply the main layer of glue and assemble. . This is exactly what I do as well, never had an issue. I have also used dominos on miters and that works great ! Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk Quote
Chestnut Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 3 minutes ago, shaneymack said: This is exactly what I do as well, never had an issue. I have also used dominos on miters and that works great ! Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk I have some picture frames to make soon is there a quick way to make a spline jig? Also for splines how deep is too deep? i want a domino so bad but i had an incident yesterday where one of my well loved tools needed to be sent off for repair and the bill is going to be half of a DF500. Guess that's getting pushed back further. Quote
shaneymack Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 I have some picture frames to make soon is there a quick way to make a spline jig? Also for splines how deep is too deep? i want a domino so bad but i had an incident yesterday where one of my well loved tools needed to be sent off for repair and the bill is going to be half of a DF500. Guess that's getting pushed back further. Do you want to do regular straight splines or dovetail splines? Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk Quote
Chestnut Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 Just now, shaneymack said: Do you want to do regular straight splines or dovetail splines? Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk Regular for now. Those dovetail splines that you did recently were awesome ... some day when i have more time. 1 Quote
shaneymack Posted May 25, 2016 Report Posted May 25, 2016 Regular for now. Those dovetail splines that you did recently were awesome ... some day when i have more time. There are probably a million ways to make a spline jig. I do not like spending time making fancy jigs. I normally try to come up with a way to pound out the jig asap so i can get back to woodworking. The simplest way would be to cut kerfs with a handsaw and make splines to fit in that. That way you could put two or three in the thickness of the frame, even more for a box. As for a spline jig for the ts you could make an open box of ply to saddle your fence and on the blade side make the plywood high. Screw two 45 deg pieces to that. Voila, spline jig. As for depth, go deep enough that you dont come through the other side ! Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk This is what the front would look like facing the blade. 1 Quote
Ronn W Posted May 26, 2016 Report Posted May 26, 2016 What if.........The pine had high moisture content and shrank. With the outside corners fixed in place by the spline, the inside edge of the pine on each side of the joint would tend to pull apart. Could it over power the maple - I'm not sure but I think it did. It's not a joint problem per se. Quote
bleedinblue Posted May 26, 2016 Author Report Posted May 26, 2016 It's possible! Realistically it was probably a combination of all factors. I no doubt glue starved the joint (I've got a nasty habit of doing this, even on long grain), the pine was sub-par for sure and very well could have had different moisture content, and if I would have made the splines larger the splines might have helped the joint withstand it. I thought my splines were completely inadequate, that was obvious and that was the only error. Perhaps I should change the thread title to "...and why I think they failed." Quote
BeingFrank Posted May 26, 2016 Report Posted May 26, 2016 Just to throw one more thing out, did you orientate the grain of the splines so it ran across the miter rather than in the direction of the miter? If the splines were put in with their grain running the same direction as the line in the miter joint, expansion of the splines might pull apart a weak glue joint. Quote
SawDustB Posted May 26, 2016 Report Posted May 26, 2016 If it was pine from somewhere other than a good hardwood dealer, my experience has been that it's never that dry, and always shrinks a little later. I have a charging station with miters that I made where they all tried to open up after about 2 months. I wouldn't think it'd be a stable substrate for the veneer. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted May 26, 2016 Report Posted May 26, 2016 Now that the joint horse is thoroughly beaten, mind sharing how you colored that pine? Quote
bleedinblue Posted May 26, 2016 Author Report Posted May 26, 2016 I covered it with 1/4 inch thick curly maple, lol. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.