Recommended Posts

Posted

I currently have a 2011 Mustang that I love.  It's 460' ish (crank) horsepower of badassery that last year, I finally upgraded to everything I wanted it to be.

Then we had a baby.

I had said we'd be able to keep the Mustang, but I was in denial.  No one can sit in the passenger seat if the baby is on the back.  Its poor in the rain, out of question in the snow, and is lowered so much that it will need to be towed if I get a flat on the side of the road.  I was OK with the risk of flats when it was just the wife and I, but add in a baby to the side of the road scenario?  No thanks.

I drove the Mustang a few days ago for the first time in about three weeks.  There were literally cobwebs around the gas pedal.

So, I'm considering trading it in.  

Without a truck now, getting lumber is a chore.  I usually get crappy big box store ply so they can cut it up to fit in my wife's SUV.

If I'm ditching the Mustang, it's replacement should be a truck.  Preferably crew cab and on the smaller side.  Fitting in the standard garage would be a huge plus.

So, all of that to ask, does anyone have a Colorado?  

Posted

Yeah, I would take a F150 if the price were right, my biggest concern is the size.  I figure I might be able to fit a truck up to about 220 inches into the garage.  A Colorado "might" squeeze in, an F150 won't.

I could just forfeit my half of the garage, but that becomes a slight inconvenience.  I have my work SUV in the driveway, and my wife will probably get a work car again at some point, so that would get pretty crowded.

I like the Ridgelines too, but I would undoubtedly have to go used due to price.  That would be OK, depending on mileage.  I just wouldn't be able to take advantage of 0% financing offers.

Posted
22 minutes ago, bleedinblue said:

I like the Ridgelines too, but I would undoubtedly have to go used due to price.  That would be OK, depending on mileage.  I just wouldn't be able to take advantage of 0% financing offers.

I have one, and love it. They hold their value surprisingly well too. I looked at all of the other trucks around the same time, and it was a clear choice for my needs. 

Posted

Everyone is going to be a bit different.  Everyone has positive and negative opinions about particular manufacturers.  Even tho I'm a Dodge guy, for me the size of the bed would be more important than the manufacturer.  The problem with the "smaller" versions is that they either won't haul what I need to haul or I have to tinker with something to open up the space I need.  

I have a standard 2 car garage and fit my full size Dodge in there as well as the wife's X-Terra.  Yes, it's tight but, they do fit.

Posted

Yeah, aside from sports cars, I'm not brand loyal really at all.  All of these trucks are on the table.   I'm attracted to the Colorado right now, mainly because of a 10% off offer.  At least one dealership nearby has a new 16 crew cab, 4wd, for $27.9.  That's about the same price as a 12-15 30-50 thousand mile used truck in any of the mentioned makes.  I'm trying to nudge my wife that direction, but she's being stubborn.

Bed size is concerning, but anything would be better than what I have now, the SUV or a fold-up Harbor Freight trailer.  I figure I can build a rack for sheet goods, if needed.  

Going cheap, like 10-15k, is also tempting since the truck won't be driven much at all.  But then we're talking really high miles.  

 

Posted

As you are a sports car guy, I wouldn't go big truck. Go small truck and trailer. You can get into peppier and more economical models and still be able to occasionally haul a few hundred board feet or several sheets of ply. 

Posted

Lemme boil this down for ya, it's what I'm best at.

Kids...you realize right quick how little space you have, both in the house and the vehicles.  And if you and wifey decide to have number two...multiply that quotient by thrice.

We're gettin' older.  Who cares about bells and whistles?  Nix the leather and sunroof and fake burl dashboard.  Crew cab 4x4 half ton, a few years used, best price you can find that looks taken care of.

Park in the driveway.  We have three vehicles out in ours.  Meh.

Posted

I'm with ya Eric.  I really don't care about the fancy options.  I want seating, reliability, at least a little bit of bed for hauling the occasional things I don't want in the SUV, and 4x4. Beyond that I really don't care.  My car enthusiast status is at least on hold for a few years.

I'm actually OK with parking in the driveway, it's the wife who is picky about it.  She says it will be too hard for her to get in the garage if she has to back in around multiple cars in the driveway.  I don't understand that because she will have the full garage...plenty of room.  What was Rex saying about men and women not thinking the same way?

Posted

davewyo is right on, i own a 2015 colorado, crew cab, 4wd, Z71, nicely equipped but not top of the heap by any means. i put a fiberglass composite lid on the bed, hinged at the cab end and lifts up on hydraulics, keeps the bed dry and snow free in the winter. i really like the truck and have gotten 26 MPG on the highway, and 20 in town is not unheard of. the only reason i wouldn't buy another one is if i hauled a lot of sheet goods, the bed is not 4' between the wheel wells but there is detents to use 2X4's to keep 4' wide stuff up and flat 

  • Like 1
Posted

I drive a Chevy Avalanche. Works for me, because it seats 6, but can also seat 3 while carrying a stack of 4x8 plywood, dry and with the tail gate closed. It is as short as a 2 door pickup, so less garage space is used. 18 mpg with my typical driving, about 20 on the highway. Unfortunately, Chevy stopped production, so used is you're only choice. An option is a Suburban, just can't carry tall stuff in it.


Posted

Friend of mine has a frontier and I've driven it a few times. I don't care for the plastic steering wheel wasn't' comfortable on MY hands. There are two very important parts to a car , the drivers seat and the steering wheel, if either are uncomfortable the buy is pointless imo. He also told me the apple biased media connections drive him up the wall. Otherwise good pickup.

Posted
I have one, and love it. They hold their value surprisingly well too. I looked at all of the other trucks around the same time, and it was a clear choice for my needs. 

I use to like the Ridgelines as well as a weekend warrior type truck but man they really failed with the new model. I saw one the other day for the first time in person and the model you have is way nicer. The new model looks super wimpy.

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted
3 hours ago, Chestnut said:

Friend of mine has a frontier and I've driven it a few times. I don't care for the plastic steering wheel wasn't' comfortable on MY hands. There are two very important parts to a car , the drivers seat and the steering wheel, if either are uncomfortable the buy is pointless imo. He also told me the apple biased media connections drive him up the wall. Otherwise good pickup.

Apple based?  Ugh.  I'm an Android guy.  iTunes confuses me.

Gonna go look at that Colorado tomorrow.  

Posted

Bleedinblue I have a 2015 GMC Canyon crew cab which is the GMC version of the Colorado. I have had it for about 18 months and have put about 15K miles on it about 8K of those on long trips (2 to MI and 1 to CO) and I leave Thursday for Maine. Here is my take; overall I love the truck and it meets my needs very well. I have no desire to drive a full size pickup so my options were limited. Pros: Extremely quiet and comfortable very respectable mileage 22.5 on avg and I have gotten as high as 26.5 all freeway 75 mph on the way to CO worst i have seen is 17.5 towing two Seadoos. Nice to have a box again and back seat works well for my two huskies as well as adult passengers. The only dislike I have is that the NAV sucks absolutely sucks did I mention it sucks :) Having said that all the 2016 and newer Canyons have Apple car play which would solve that issue for me. The other things I wish I could get but can't, yet, are push button start and memory seating my wife and I are about a foot different in height LOL. One thing of note to woodworkers is that the box 60" long but measured from the inside front wall to the tailgate. The front wall has a lip so if you buy 5'x5' BB like I do you cannot fit it in with the tailgate up. On the positive side it has several tie down points and places to add more. If you have any specific questions pm me but I would buy this truck again without hesitation. Full disclosure my previous vehicles were 2012 Wrangler Unlimited, 2005 Chevrolet Avalanche, 2001 Honda CRV, 1996 F250 LD, Many many years of Ford Escorts.

  • Like 1
Posted

Awesome, great review.  Your complaints don't really bother me at all...since this truck won't be a daily driver, I'm not at all concerned with creature comforts like navigation, push button start, etc.  The truck we're going to look at is actually a work truck, bare bones package, and I'm very OK with that.  I finally found dimensions, and it looks like it will fit in the garage no problem.

This will be a usable second option car for the family that I can use to STOP hauling lumber and other things in my wife's SUV.  Last week we had to use her car to transport landscaping bricks.  It took two trips because of weight and left a hell of a mess. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 30 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,007
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    FurniCore
    Newest Member
    FurniCore
    Joined