Recommended Posts

Posted

Hello,

I received some Home Depot gift cards for Christmas, so I am thinking of putting them towards my first planer.

Background on me/uses:

- Skill Level: novice

- Budget: $400 max

- do not currently have a planer (or jointer)

- interested in cutting boards and other beginner projects - in the future, I would love to get into furniture and larger projects

- no experience with rough sawn lumber

- I understand that machines much much more expensive would be better, but that's not feasible. Plus, with my skill level, not sure I would notice a difference.

In scanning Home Depots website, it looks like three options are out there that fall into my parameters.

1) DeWalt 734

http://t.homedepot.com/p/DEWALT-15-Amp-12-1-2-in-Corded-Planer-DW734/100634640/

2) Rigid R4331

http://t.homedepot.com/p/RIDGID-13-in-Thickness-Corded-Planer-R4331/100634358/

3) Delta 22-555

http://t.homedepot.com/p/Delta-15-Amp-13-in-Portable-Thickness-Planer-22-555/205404458/

What feedback or guidance can your provide on these units?

Posted

I'll just toss out that you might consider saving for the 735.

 

Frankly, it's the one everyone raves over.  It will be in my shop as soon as I kill off my Grizzly..

  • Like 1
Posted

I have the 735x and they do go on sale at Rockler and Woodcraft at times...as well as other places I am sure.  I think I paid just under 600 for mine and it included the stand, in/outfeed tables and an extra set of knives.

Posted

Another vote for the DeWalt 735. It's a great planer as is, but you can add a helical cutter head down the road and have a fantastic bench planer. There are step by step videos instructions on You Tube describing how to install the helical cutter head. I did mine myself with no problems in about an 1.5 hours. Pretty much the king of lunch box planers once you do that.

Posted

I'll just toss out that you might consider saving for the 735.

Frankly, it's the one everyone raves over. It will be in my shop as soon as I kill off my Grizzly..

I had a Ryobi trimmer that took me 5 years to put it out of its misery so I could get a Stihl. Sometimes POS tools seem to run better once they know they're going to be replaced.

Back on topic I had the Dewalt 733 which was a solid performer and I think the 734 just adds an extra knife.

Posted

Thanks for th comments everyone.

Yes - I realize I couled continue to save for the DeWalt 735. But, who has the patience? :) Also, I guess I am curious if a complete newbie like me would see any difference between the two models. Any big differences in the models?

Any other thoughts on the three models?

Posted

I don't own any of the models listed but from what I've seen the dust collection on the 735 would be well worth the wait and extra $$$. If you've never run a planer you'll be shocked at how much dust and chips they produce. I would wait. Once my old Craftsman dies I will be getting one. 

Posted

+1 for the Dewalt DW735X

 

Here's a useful bit of information, if you're planning on doing woodworking, buy once buy right. I've bought tools and wound up being disappointed and should have held out a bit longer to get the next model, etc. I have the 735X and it's fantastic for the price. I say hold out a bit and get the 735.

Posted

I have a ridgid TP1300, which is now out of production.  If you can get one used, its a super planer and does nice work.  The only issue I am having is getting blades (special order only).

 

That being said, I was looking at getting the Dewalt myself, but decided to hold off.  My planer does a great job and does not need to be replaced.  I do wish the DC was a bit better on the Ridgid.  It has a 4" collection, but it still spits a bit of dust/chips out the front when taking moderate cuts.

Posted

One difference to consider is about 15 pounds. I have a 735, and love it. However, my shop space is shared with vehicles, so my planer sits under the workbench until I need )it. 95 lbs is bear to drag out of there every time! I think you will see the same quality of cut with a 734, but no built in chip blower.

Posted

Start checking CL in your area. They come up around here sometimes. Well taken care of, they are not super cheap, but might be in your price range.

Maybe you'll get lucky and find someone that upgraded for Christmas.

Posted

Start checking CL in your area. They come up around here sometimes. Well taken care of, they are not super cheap, but might be in your price range.

Maybe you'll get lucky and find someone that upgraded for Christmas.

My thoughts exactly. CL, especially for someone who might have upgraded.

Posted

Ah, missed that part. From what I've read those are all good choices, esp the 734. Will you notice the difference from the 735? If you've never used a 735 then I would say "no" :)

Posted

A couple years ago I ALMOST pulled the string on the 734 but held out for the 735.  Wasn't easy.  Now I'm sooooo glad I waited.  the 735 is awesome.  Two speeds - fan assisted chip ejection.  Add a Wixey to it and you're set.

Posted

A couple years ago I ALMOST pulled the string on the 734 but held out for the 735.  Wasn't easy.  Now I'm sooooo glad I waited.  the 735 is awesome.  Two speeds - fan assisted chip ejection.  Add a Wixey to it and you're set.

I have the Wixey on my 15" planer and should have added that upgrade years ago. It's so nice not having to get out calipers, rulers, etc. and measure after each pass. 

Posted

I have the Wixey on my 15" planer and should have added that upgrade years ago. It's so nice not having to get out calipers, rulers, etc. and measure after each pass. 

Heck yeah....no matter which planer you get.....get a Wixey [Tony the Tiger Frosted Flakes] THEY'REEEEE GREAT!!!!

Posted

I have been doing some more looking at the DeWalt 734 and the Ridgid.

Couple of questions hoping someone can clarifying:

1) The Ridgid appears to have a couple of really nice features - the "Indi-Cut" that tells you how much you will be taking off and the "Exacta-repeat thing" that allows you to plane multiple boards down to the same thickness. Does the DeWalt 734 have similar features? How do you manage both tasks on the DeWalt? I have not been able to confirm.

2) The Ridgid looks to have fairly decent dust / chip extraction. If I am following correctly, the 734 lacks in this area (one if the big pros for the 735). Am I following correctly? Or is dust / chip extraction on the 734 no different than the Ridgid?

Posted

My 735 has a depth scale and the repeatabke depth stop thingy. "Meh!" is about all I can say. The depth scale gets you pretty close, and I've never found a reason to use the stops.

It looks like the Ridgid and the 734 have pretty much the same feature set. The only thing I see that leans me in a particular direction is that the Dewalt photo shows a crank handle for depth adjustment, where the Ridgid photo just shows a knob. I'd go with the crank handle, as using a knob to raise or lower the head several inches would be a serious pain in the wrist.

Posted

i have a 734 hooked up to a HF 2hp dust collector.  i have no issues with excess chips or dust escaping.  i can see the 735 being marginally better, but not hundreds of dollars better.

 

now, thats not to say that other features dont put the 735 well above the 734. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 45 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined