Recommended Posts

Posted

I read Marc's article about 6" vs 8" and it sounds like I want a 6".  That decided, which brand?  I was hopping around Amazon and think the following is pretty representative of the range of blades:

It seems like Forrest is a very popular manufacturer, at least for the WWII blades.  I'd prefer not to spend that much if I don't have to.  I expect the majority of my dado usage will be for M&T and some plywood dados.

I mean yes, I am looking for someone to tell me I can spend $73 instead of $279 - and I know I'll find that.  But if I do go lower, what am I missing/cursing?

Posted (edited)

==>I read Marc's article about 6" vs 8" and it sounds like I want a 6"

Well, that's one opinion...

I'd go 8" if you care about the quality of your cuts... For DIY, yea 6" is fine...

Edited by hhh
Posted (edited)

==>Jobsite saw

I'm not sure jobsite saws have arbors long enough for a stack... And if they do, then enough power to spin them... Check the manual for restrictions...

Edited by hhh
Posted

==>Jobsite saw

I'm not sure jobsite saws have arbors long enough for a stack... And if they do, then enough power to spin them... Check the manual for restrictions...

from the manual (R4510):

Capture.thumb.PNG.662867b764756e48d700a9

Posted

So the dial-a-dado from your list is out...

From your list, I've got the Dado King and the Super Dado. Both are good. The King leave a better cut and can be reshaprened more times...

Posted

I have the Freud Super Dado 8" set.  Works good for me.

I debated (with myself ?) between the Freud and the Dado King - In the end I went with the Freud (cheaper) and I get clean, accurate cuts.

The Dado King may be a better set but I don't cut dados very often and so far I don't regret buying Freud.

 

Posted

==>I read Marc's article about 6" vs 8" and it sounds like I want a 6"

Well, that's one opinion...

I'd go 8" if you care about the quality of your cuts... For DIY, yea 6" is fine...

What makes an 8" better cut quality? Wouldn't it only affect how deep you cut? 

Posted (edited)

==>Wouldn't it only affect how deep you cut? 

No.

 

As Eric pointed-out, I'm doing double duty... So I'll be channeling Don for awhile and just giving answers -- not explanations... :)

Edited by hhh
  • Like 1
Posted

I have had many but right now I was in a pinch so I grabbed a 8in Dwalt on sale and it will get me by.I liked my Freud....I bet I didn't spell that right :unsure:

Posted

I picked up a Dadonator (I know, goofy name) this past Summer from Ebay (was new, but much less expensive than getting it from a store) and it cuts beautiful.  They also make a 6", but it's still $200 :-/..

I think I got mine for $120 give or take?  Keep an eye out on ebay, occasionally they have one listed.

Posted (edited)

What makes an 8" better cut quality? Wouldn't it only affect how deep you cut? 

This may not be the right answer here, but use this as fuel to use in your search. 

8" teeth move faster at the same RPM being further away from center. 8" teeth intersect the table at a shallower arc. High end commercial manufacturers are not building 6" sets for anyone but hobby shops. 

Edited by C Shaffer
  • Like 2
Posted

This may not be the right answer here, but use this as fuel to use in your search. 

8" teeth move faster at the same RPM being further away from center. 8" teeth intersect the table at a shallower arc. High end commercial manufacturers are not building 6" sets for anyone but hobby shops. 

well damn, wish I had known that 6 months ago. Ha.

Posted

There is so much in wood working that is not a simple good vs bad. If your 6" does the job, don't feel regret or envy. Don't read everything in my post as a qualitative remark as much as a quantitative. Too many just don't engineer in three dimensions often. 

  • Like 2
Posted

The Infinity Dadonator Jr should rival, if not exceed the performance of the Forrest, but at a more reasonable price (~$200).  As expected, both the Forrest and the Infinity will have better performance than the Oshlun or Freud 206, but all will do a decent job. 

If you're willing to go with an 8" set, the Dewalt/Delta 7670 will also outperform the Oshlun and SD206 for ~ $120, though it's not quite as good as the premium sets.  It also has a great carrying case and excellent shim stock.

 

Posted

The Infinity Dadonator Jr should rival, if not exceed the performance of the Forrest, but at a more reasonable price (~$200).  As expected, both the Forrest and the Infinity will have better performance than the Oshlun or Freud 206, but all will do a decent job. 

If you're willing to go with an 8" set, the Dewalt/Delta 7670 will also outperform the Oshlun and SD206 for ~ $120, though it's not quite as good as the premium sets.  It also has a great carrying case and excellent shim stock.

I'd heard that of the DeWalt.  Thing is this saw won't swing an 8".  Too bad because that price is right.

I'll add the Dadonator to the list.

Posted

So, what is the arbor length that the stack requires?  I have an old Craftsman (Emerson) 113.29902 and it has a pretty long arbor shaft.....I have a copy of the manual and it covers dado stacks, but not the max width.  Also, its a 1967 saw, so I suppose the 6 in is the better stack given my low power?  What do you think?

 

Jeff in KC

 

Posted

So, what is the arbor length that the stack requires?  I have an old Craftsman (Emerson) 113.29902 and it has a pretty long arbor shaft.....I have a copy of the manual and it covers dado stacks, but not the max width.  Also, its a 1967 saw, so I suppose the 6 in is the better stack given my low power?  What do you think?

Do you have a set of calipers?  Take the blade off, put the washer and nut back on and get full engagement - then measure.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 56 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined