Rex Edgar Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 Here's another question session. Who here uses the blade guard consistently? My previous saw was a contractor model from Ridgid and I found that it was in the way more than it served it's intended purpose. I removed it early and used caution and when it was not in use I religiously lowered the blade below deck level. I bought a SAWSTOP in December last and I am using the same procedure. I'm not bragging or looking to displease the gods of the shop, but there has never been an issue. What are you folk doing regarding the blade guard? Quote
..Kev Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 I've never used the guard for my saw.. Still brand new in the package.. I may change this when I upgrade the DC but for now, it's in the way more often than not. Quote
Tom King Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 I never used one for probably forty years, but for maybe the past ten years I use an Exactor overarm "guard" for dust collection. Quote
shaneymack Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 I have a Sawstop and the overarm dust collection. Due to the awesome dust collection, I almost never take the guard off unless I have to. It only gets in the way if you have the fence within two inches off the blade. Obviously on non through cuts i take it off as well. Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk Quote
midtnwoodworker Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 I have never used one, and probably won't unless they come out with one that works perfectly in every instance and has great dust collection. I know the Sawstop is probably the best out there, but for those few times that I have to take it off it becomes more trouble than it's worth to me. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 Never used one until I purchased an excalibur blade guard for dust collection. It is annoying to work around sometimes(cutting tenons, narrow rips), but it is nice that you can swing it up and out of the way. I consider myself to be pretty safe around the table saw, but the guard makes it idiot proof. You would have to be trying to put your hand in the blade to succeed. Quote
pkinneb Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 I have a Excalibur overarm dust collection guard that stays swung out of the way for everything but plywood. The dust collection in my experience with this unit is negligible at best and I personally do not like anything blocking my view of the blade. I do use a splitter in all operations that allow and make good use of a gripper and other push sticks. BTW I have a PM 66 and the original blade guard is a huge aluminum/metal contraption that has never been on the saw. Quote
bleedinblue Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 I really have no interest in a blade guard until I get one for dust collection. Quote
conundrum Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 Never used it. If it was not in the way and/or had good dust collection I may reconsider. Quote
wdwerker Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 Commando for 40 years but strongly considering an overarm guard mostly for dust collection. I have been using the micro jig splitters for years. If I ever get a new saw a riving knife is a must. Quote
gee-dub Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 There are certainly plenty of folks who follow good methods and procedures and have gone the distance without a guard and without injury. This is a testament to the unfair reputation tablesaws get as being man-eaters. When a ding-a-lings does bad things and has an "accident", another black mark falls on the bad side of the tablesaw scales. Catastrophic mechanical failure aside, the blade stays right where it is supposed to; it doesn't reach out and bite you, you have to go to it. I use a guard whenever it is safer than not using one (which is any cut that can be made safely with one). The fact that my guard is also my overarm DC probably makes me do this more consistently. I also make a lot of cuts without a guard as they are not the answer for all safety concerns. Sled use, miter gauge use, dados, rabbets, tenons and more are done without the guard. These are all done with their own set of safety procedures that, if followed will result in "accident" free tablesaw use. I'm not saying there aren't accidents, I'm just saying most of them aren't . . . IMHO. Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 My JET cabinet saw is from '99 so it does not have a riving knife. I never used the blade guard until I had a bad kickback accident. After that, I put the blade guard on, but I hated it because I had to tighten & loosen 3 bolts every time I needed to install or remove it and it seems with the work I do I was needing to frequently remove or install it. I realized I only needed a splitter to save me from kickback. I only run my blade high enough to clear the material and I also use push sticks. So I decided to make my own splitter which stays on most of the time. I only use the blade guard when milling reclaimed material. There is so much debris and shrapnel flying off that material, the blade guard is the best way to keep it contained and keep myself safe. 1 Quote
RichardA Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 Where did the term "commando" come from? I've heard it applied to several things in the last few years. Commando always meant to me, a warrior that fights to win, regardless of rules. Quote
Rex Edgar Posted May 10, 2016 Author Report Posted May 10, 2016 5 minutes ago, RichardA said: Where did the term "commando" come from? I've heard it applied to several things in the last few years. Commando always meant to me, a warrior that fights to win, regardless of rules. Commando in the Millenial parlance: to go without...........whatever Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 The word stems from the Afrikaans word kommando for a military unit. In the Boer war, the British found themselves outmanoeuvred and outperformed by the highly mobile and skilled Boer marksmen. Commando came to mean an elite unit, special forces, a unit that employs unconventional tactics, etc. I don't think anyone knows how it came to refer to going without underwear. Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 Ya the first thing I thought of when I saw the title: Hmmm...choosing between using a table saw guard or free balling....this should be interesting... Quote
Popular Post RichardA Posted May 10, 2016 Popular Post Report Posted May 10, 2016 It's so comfortable to be 73 years old, There's not enough time left for me to really be concerned with how the millenials have changed the landscape and the meaning of words! Here's one that I never expected...gay from the time I was a kid until about 1985 it meant light hearted, fun loving. Now it's applied to a group of people that I'm not allowed to call the "Q" word. So to be light hearted and fun loving is to be what? The world and the words are changing to fast for this old guy to keep up, and if I sound politically incorrect, don't get upset or call me names... I won't be alive much longer.. And the truth is, I really don't care anymore! 4 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 I used to always use either the guard or the riving knife. I have an older Sawstop without blade guard dust collection, and swapping the guard for the knife needs a hex wrench and it a bit of a pain. I recently started using a Grrr-Ripper for most cuts, so I just use the riving knife all the time. 1 Quote
RichardA Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 35 minutes ago, Lester Burnham said: My table saw is double commando. No guard or knife. Mines a 1948 Craftsman... it ain't got squat! Quote
RichardA Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 Just now, Lester Burnham said: I'm nowhere near 73 but I get where you're coming from. I grew up a George Carlin fan. Needless to say, language and its use has always been interesting to me. I drove tractor trailer for 32 years, and several times I've been mistaken for George. He's a bit like Eric. Or is it Eric's a bit like George? 2 Quote
RichardA Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 1 minute ago, Lester Burnham said: Wow, that's old. I don't know the year of mine. It was my dad's. Delta Shopmaster. It's 6 years younger than the guy that drives it! Quote
sjk Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 27 minutes ago, Beechwood Chip said: I don't think anyone knows how it came to refer to going without underwear. Wikipedia to the rescue: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Going_commando I first heard the phrase on the mentioned Friends episode. 1 Quote
Rex Edgar Posted May 10, 2016 Author Report Posted May 10, 2016 20 minutes ago, RichardA said: It's so comfortable to be 73 years old, There's not enough time left for me to really be concerned with how the millenials have changed the landscape and the meaning of words! Here's one that I never expected...gay from the time I was a kid until about 1985 it meant light hearted, fun loving. Now it's applied to a group of people that I'm not allowed to call the "Q" word. So to be light hearted and fun loving is to be what? The world and the words are changing to fast for this old guy to keep up, and if I sound politically incorrect, don't get upset or call me names... I won't be alive much longer.. And the truth is, I really don't care anymore! I started the thread, so this cannot be a hi-jack. I'll be 64 this year and I like Richard have a finite amount of time on this tour to get too concerned over what is happening in the world compared to what I experienced growing up. I read in the paper this morning that there are some folks that classify themselves as "non-binary", look it up. There are other controversies in this country that I do not understand, but I am sure the moderators here do not want to get into any political discussions. On a final note for me, it has been my observation that the last half dozen presidential contest have involved less and less attractive choices for us to pick. Well, I hope I haven't crossed any boundaries that will get me in trouble...............There is life expectancy for a reason! Quote
RichardA Posted May 11, 2016 Report Posted May 11, 2016 2 hours ago, Rex Edgar said: I started the thread, so this cannot be a hi-jack. I'll be 64 this year and I like Richard have a finite amount of time on this tour to get too concerned over what is happening in the world compared to what I experienced growing up. I read in the paper this morning that there are some folks that classify themselves as "non-binary", look it up. There are other controversies in this country that I do not understand, but I am sure the moderators here do not want to get into any political discussions. On a final note for me, it has been my observation that the last half dozen presidential contest have involved less and less attractive choices for us to pick. Well, I hope I haven't crossed any boundaries that will get me in trouble...............There is life expectancy for a reason! There is life expectancy for a pregnant woman. From the day of delivery there is only termination expectancy. I have exceeded my termination expectancy by well more than 50 years. This was not meant as a hijack. It was merely a question I had regarding the word "commando"! And somehow it got away from the point, which was safety at the table saw. For that, I offer my apologies. But at this point in my life, I'm facing the loss of someone more dear to me than me, and if I side tracked the issue, it's because, focusing has become difficult. Again my apologies! I'll step out of this thread, to avoid any further confusion. Bye, the way, my saw goes "commando"! Whatever the hell that is! Quote
Chestnut Posted May 11, 2016 Report Posted May 11, 2016 10 hours ago, RichardA said: There is life expectancy for a pregnant woman. From the day of delivery there is only termination expectancy. I have exceeded my termination expectancy by well more than 50 years. This was not meant as a hijack. It was merely a question I had regarding the word "commando"! And somehow it got away from the point, which was safety at the table saw. For that, I offer my apologies. But at this point in my life, I'm facing the loss of someone more dear to me than me, and if I side tracked the issue, it's because, focusing has become difficult. Again my apologies! I'll step out of this thread, to avoid any further confusion. Bye, the way, my saw goes "commando"! Whatever the hell that is! I'm only 28 and i can't keep up with my own generation. I run my saw no knife no guard. I thought that as soon as i got a nice saw with a good guard setup I'd use it but that didn't end up happening. I do always use a push stick and micro jig grippers make me uncomfortable because i don't like my hand getting even that close to the blade. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.