pridmore Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 All- I am in the process of building the Farmhouse Table project in The Guild with Master Fromona. I am at the point where I am needing to drill holes for draw-boring. I purchased some store bought dowel stock and drilled some 3/8" holes in a test piece using a Forstner bit and a Brad-point bit (both in my drill and at my drill press), with the resulting holes being way too loose for the dowel. I measured the dowel stock and found that it was slightly undersized, so I purchased a dowel plate to hammer out my own stock. The fit was slightly better, with the fit being more like a "sliding" fit. The stock wouldn't fall through, but would slide through the hole without hardly any force being applied. Maybe it wasn't the stock after all... I could see the drill bit "walking" a little bit in the hand drill but expected as much. With the drill press, though, I could see the quill wobble, which caused tons of runout. It doesn't surprise me. The DP is a hand-me-down floor model from my brother. It's about 20 years old, I have never taken care of it, and the chuck is rusty. I've never needed to drill precise holes before and it suited my needs. I don't want to spend tons of time trying to fix it. I will give it to somebody else who is newer in the hobby. Now I get to buy a new toy. Does anybody have a recommendation for one that he/she is happy with? I would prefer to not go to the $1500 price point for the Nova or the Powermatic, but I'm not opposed. Thanks for the input. 1 Quote
bgreenb Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 Yes. No brainer. This one: https://www.amazon.com/Jet-JDP-17-Drill-Press/dp/B00NF6P8PI/ref=sr_1_1?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1494951266&sr=1-1&keywords=jet+jdp-17 Here's a thread where @Tom Cancelleri reviews it. I bought based on his review and have been very happy with it since. Doubt you'll find a better value anywhere. 1 Quote
Eric. Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 I have a PM2800, and if I could go back in time I'd buy the one Brian just linked. It's like the Supermax of drill presses...quality unit, best bang for your buck. LOL @ Master Fromona Quote
OldSouthWoodCraft Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 The guys answered a very similar question last night on the podcast. Cremona says himself there is nothing wrong with a simple bench top drill press. Honestly alot of guys I've watched say the same thing and even go as far as saying the Harbor Freight models are fine to use. Clearly Cremona built all of his projects just fine with his unit. Honestly I've never had an issue with mine. Just have to check for square between the bit and the plate. Ask long as you back down on your rpms with bigger material and use quality bits a cheap model should last for a long time with very little work done to it. Just my honest opinion though. Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk Quote
Pwk5017 Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 Id be all over craigslist looking for an old delta or powermatic. You dont have digital readouts for RPMs etc, but you should be able to get one of the great vintage models for $300-400. My 60s delta was $100, doesnt change speeds, has no appreciable runout, quill travel of 5-6", has a busted light, and its dirty af from 50 years of being in a fab shop. Despite all that, it drills all the precise holes i need it to, and ill sell it for the same or more than i bought it for. I like to K.I.S.S. with some machines, and i think a drill press is one of them. Quote
Eric. Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 Just now, Pwk5017 said: digital readouts for RPMs Maybe it's just me, but I find this the biggest waste of plastic and wires on earth. I set my DP on a moderate/slow speed when I bought it...and haven't touched it since. I don't understand the real need to mess around with speed that much in the context of woodworking...as long as you're not spinning a bit so fast that it's heating significantly (or it's dangerous, e.g. big forstner)...I truly don't get why people ever touch the speed. I agree with the last two posts...a simple unit is all that's needed in a woodshop...as long as it works reliably and accurately...which is the real wild card with cheap or old machines. Quote
gee-dub Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 I had looked in vain for a benchtop DP with a decent swing. A 14" machine proved too shallow for me too often. Otherwise I would still be running Grandpa's Delta from the 1940's (gave it to a relative and visit it regularly). A 15" would probably cover me 85% of the time with a 17" being 99% effective. The 14" just came up short often enough to make me move on. It was like my 30" rip on the tablesaw and my 6" jointer . . . just a bit too wanting in capacity often enough to make me change. I had also looked at just lopping a floor model off and setting it on a drawer unit but, built drawers around the floor unit instead. Your satisfaction with a DP will be proportional to what you do with it. I drill holes at lots of angles, use Forstners, use circle cutters, run small sanding drums and buffing wheels. My table tilts left, right and forward. My fence accepts all sorts of holddowns, stops and what not . . . some folks just want to drill a hole. Consider your requirements and forge ahead. Quote
krtwood Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 1 hour ago, OldSouthWoodCraft said: The guys answered a very similar question last night on the podcast. Cremona says himself there is nothing wrong with a simple bench top drill press. Honestly alot of guys I've watched say the same thing and even go as far as saying the Harbor Freight models are fine to use. Clearly Cremona built all of his projects just fine with his unit. Honestly I've never had an issue with mine. Just have to check for square between the bit and the plate. Ask long as you back down on your rpms with bigger material and use quality bits a cheap model should last for a long time with very little work done to it. I wasted the entire last weekend just trying to get my Ryobi 10" DP to consecutively drill two straight 1-1/8" holes. It won't do it. I stopped using the table and built up a solid support resting on the base with levelers to precisely dial in the table. I can definitely say it's not the table. It's just incapable of drilling precisely straight. You generally don't need it to be that precise for woodworking, so yes you can go years and years without it truly being a problem. Quote
ben_r_ Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 Ive got the Delta 18-900L and love it. Upgraded the chuck to a Jacobs the day I got it. It's performed wonderfully since day one. 1 Quote
drzaius Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 I have a General 75-260, which is a 17" with a 1HP motor. It drills straight & square, has minimal runout, is solid as can be, has more power than I've ever needed, & didn't cost a lot. It has a couple of weaknesses; the speed changes aren't as convenient as some others, and the depth stop has no quick adjust nuts on it. As @Eric said, the speed change thing isn't important & doesn't bother me. And one of these days I'll upgrade the depth stop. Good solid value though. Make sure you have a buddy to help assemble it though, cause that head weighs a ton. Quote
AJ_Engineer Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 I have been happy with my floor standing Porter Cable from Lowes, but if I were to do it again I would get the Jet linked above. More travel, more power, better warranty, but twice the price or more... Quote
Tom King Posted May 16, 2017 Report Posted May 16, 2017 When buying dowels from a store, buy a cheap set of digital calipers (if you don't already own one), and take them with you. Some dowels will be slightly oversize. I buy those, and put them somewhere that will dry them as much as possible. Check them when you know they are dry. The last bunch of 3/8's were bought at .183, and stayed a little over after cooking on the hearth in front of a fireplace for a week. There were two sizes of 3/8" Oak dowels in the bin. The ones that weren't .183 were .168. I wouldn't trade my two green Powermatic 1150's for three new ones (unless maybe they were Ellis's). 1 Quote
pridmore Posted May 17, 2017 Author Report Posted May 17, 2017 10 hours ago, bgreenb said: Yes. No brainer. This one: https://www.amazon.com/Jet-JDP-17-Drill-Press/dp/B00NF6P8PI/ref=sr_1_1?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1494951266&sr=1-1&keywords=jet+jdp-17 Here's a thread where @Tom Cancelleri reviews it. I bought based on his review and have been very happy with it since. Doubt you'll find a better value anywhere. Ordered. Thanks to all for the input. 1 Quote
Vyrolan Posted May 17, 2017 Report Posted May 17, 2017 14 hours ago, pridmore said: Ordered. Thanks to all for the input. If you bought it from Amazon, I hope @bgreenb put @thewoodwhisperer affiliate code in the link. Quote
Pondhockey Posted May 27, 2017 Report Posted May 27, 2017 On 5/16/2017 at 11:49 AM, ben_r_ said: Ive got the Delta 18-900L and love it. Upgraded the chuck to a Jacobs the day I got it. It's performed wonderfully since day one. After reading all the good advice on here, a Delta 18-900 came up on Craig's list in my own little mountain town. Hardly used, mortising kit still in the wrapper. $300. I considered it to be a divine sign, so now I have a drill press - and immediately upgraded the quality of my mortises on a version of Mark's Rustic Outdoor Table. Thanks to all! Quote
ben_r_ Posted May 27, 2017 Report Posted May 27, 2017 1 hour ago, Pondhockey said: After reading all the good advice on here, a Delta 18-900 came up on Craig's list in my own little mountain town. Hardly used, mortising kit still in the wrapper. $300. I considered it to be a divine sign, so now I have a drill press - and immediately upgraded the quality of my mortises on a version of Mark's Rustic Outdoor Table. Thanks to all! $300 for a Delta 18-900L!?! Seriously? Yea I wouldnt let mine go for less than maybe $800 with no accessories. They still retail for $1000. If it looks good and works perfectly I definitely wouldnt let that deal pass! Quote
Cliff Posted May 27, 2017 Report Posted May 27, 2017 I also have floor standing PC unit from lowes, which has increased from $319 to $379 for some reason. Anyways, I bought a woodpecker drill press table and slapped it on there. Works great. But the real reason I got that is someone got it for me xmas. That was my second choice next to the Jet Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.