Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted September 14 Popular Post Report Posted September 14 I find that a double-sided diamond stone (600/1220 grit) and a slab of mdf covered with green honing compound meet my needs. I use an inexpensive eclipse-style guide, or freehand. Stropping often seems to be the key, once the initial edge is established. Total investment < $100 if you go with less-known name brand for the stone. I strongly suggest an 8x3 inch stone, or larger. 4 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted September 14 Popular Post Report Posted September 14 First, Chris' book is a great resource and well worth reading. Echoing others: I don't recommend going out and buying his system wholesale. In part because that's a huge cost, but in part because the journey to your own system is important. Like most of us, I expect you didn't go buy a shop of tools all at once and there is no reason to go buy your whole sharpening system at once. You need to figure out what works for you. Some of that will depend on what you sharpen most often and some of it will depend on your personal taste. Pick one task, your biggest need, (e.g. sharpening chisels) and go get what you need for that. Then add another tasks, etc. At some point maybe you circle back and improve. In terms of stuff, I've been very happy with the DMT diamond stones and I think a double-sided stone there is a great way to start. I know have the full set of six stones with the magnetic base and love it, but it was a $200 investment I didn't jump on until I knew I liked the path. I also found honing guides aren't my thing and I like hand sharpening, so I stopped investing in that direction for now. 3 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted September 14 Popular Post Report Posted September 14 On 9/14/2026 at 7:48 AM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: You can make a very effective kit by adhering 3 grits of sandpaper onto a flat substrate, and picking up a cheap honing guide. Good call Ron Jr. I forgot all about Scary Sharp. I have a set that I have had for well over 20 years. It is a good way to get started and get a feel for what works for you. You can see my original DMT to the left. This pic is from somewhere in 2006. I use plate glass for the sub-micron level stuff. For coarser grits I just went to the BORG and bought a piece of polished floor tile. At the time they would give you one cut for free so I got two plates for few bucks. This works fine for the coarser grits. Once you start getting past 1000 grit or into .15 micron type stuff, glass is the way to go. It works really well but the abrasives wear quickly. This is only a bad thing if you sharpen frequently. As I eased into retirement I spent more time making stuff and my use-case changed the diamond stones started to make financial sense. It's like carbide insert heads; they seem really expensive. If you do the math over time they are way cheaper than knives. 6 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted September 15 Popular Post Report Posted September 15 Despite weeks of 90 and 100 degree weather we have had rain. California doesn't do rain well . . . . wrong soil type. One of my daughter's horses (Bela) managed to get stuck in the pen in a wet spot. She got some of the neighbors to come over and help her get the old girl out and get her back on her feet. Not Bela's fault. The soil here just doesn't off load water well. Despite being really hot and dry there was a spot of quicksand in her pen. No injury, all recovered, all is well. 4 2 2 Quote
legenddc Posted September 15 Report Posted September 15 All good points everyone. The initial price tag of Chris’s kit is around $750. I don’t have a lot of hand tools but I’ve already seen how helpful they are to finesse the last little bit. I think I started looking at stone options but some of the companies had changed ownership. Heading out on a work trip now but will try to look at some options while I’m away. 2 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted September 15 Popular Post Report Posted September 15 Quickie lumber run for some more maple. The purple heart was an impulse buy. I need some purple heart for some inlays on the liquor cabinet pulls (the accent wall it will stand against has purple hues) and the current piece in the rack is huge. It was worth buying this narrow piece just to not have to lug the existing beast down and cut a small little part off of it and then lug it back up into the rack. 4 Quote
Popular Post Chet Posted September 15 Popular Post Report Posted September 15 On 9/15/2026 at 9:40 AM, gee-dub said: lug the existing beast down and cut a small little part off of it and then lug it back up into the rack. This is why I decided to go with vertical storage on the floor. I last some floor space but I am not on the ladder with big sticks of lumber. 3 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted September 15 Popular Post Report Posted September 15 @Chet - I hear ya. I am working to empty the wall racks but being a wood collector for 20 years, there's a bit to go. Several years ago I didn't think a thing of hopping up on the tilt ladder and bringing down a sizable board. Times have changed. South wall getting smaller: North wall getting smaller: West wall getting smaller: Shorts; I swear they multiply overnight. I don't know where this stuff comes from: Outbuildings: I want to get all of this reduced down to my vertical storage area in the west hallway. Now that I have a lumber yard nearby I can let them store my wood for me. I'll go get it when I need it and stay off the ladders. Once I finish the current liquor cabinet and a military flag case for a neighbor . . . I am going to attack all that stuff you see in the bottom right of the fourth picture. That is a stack of shorts too small to make much out of but, too nice to burn. I feel a . . . Box-a-thon . . . coming on. Guess what everyone is getting for Christmas 3 1 Quote
Popular Post Tom King Posted September 15 Popular Post Report Posted September 15 My balance still seems to be fine, but I don't do anything while standing on a ladder any more. Even short stepladders. I will only do work standing on the platform of a platform ladder. For some years now, a ladder is only for going up and down to get to another stable working level. 4 Quote
Popular Post pkinneb Posted September 16 Popular Post Report Posted September 16 Cleaned my shop after a long summer of outdoor projects Looking forward to getting back to the tool cabinet soon. 7 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted September 16 Popular Post Report Posted September 16 On 9/15/2026 at 5:13 PM, pkinneb said: Cleaned my shop after a long summer of outdoor projects That is one sweet looking space. I could get totally calm in a space like that. 2 1 Quote
Popular Post Immortan D Posted September 16 Popular Post Report Posted September 16 I also cleaned my shop: Didn't take long 6 1 Quote
Von Posted September 16 Report Posted September 16 59 minutes ago, Immortan D said: I algo cleaned my shop: Didn't take long Neat! I would enjoy a tour. 1 1 Quote
Popular Post Mark J Posted September 17 Popular Post Report Posted September 17 @Immortan D, It looks like your workshop is in the living space of your house? And it looks like all of it is mounted or stored on your workbench? I'd definitely like a "tour". 4 Quote
Popular Post Immortan D Posted September 17 Popular Post Report Posted September 17 On 9/17/2026 at 8:49 AM, Mark J said: @Immortan D, It looks like your workshop is in the living space of your house? And it looks like all of it is mounted or stored on your workbench? I'd definitely like a "tour". Yep. I live in an apartment, so my workbench stands in my living room most of the time. Most of the tools I need for my small projects are right there under it or hanging from it. 6 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted September 17 Popular Post Report Posted September 17 On 9/17/2026 at 7:33 AM, Immortan D said: Yep. I live in an apartment, so my workbench stands in my living room most of the time. Most of the tools I need for my small projects are right there under it or hanging from it. As much as I admire and envy the large, really well equipped full shops,I really respect the guys who make it work in extremely limited space. WW is a hobby like almost no other. You can spend North of $200k outfitting a 2000 sq foot, ultra modern shop, or you can work in 6 square foot shop, with $100 in used tools, and both of those extremes can produce good work. 6 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted September 17 Popular Post Report Posted September 17 I remind myself that the first woodworker probably used a sharp rock. All tools since since are just optimization. 2 1 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted September 17 Report Posted September 17 On 9/17/2026 at 8:39 AM, Von said: I remind myself that the first woodworker probably used a sharp rock. All tools since since are just optimization. That, and they're all just variations of the chisel when you get down to it. 2 Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted September 17 Popular Post Report Posted September 17 On 9/17/2026 at 5:47 AM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: As much as I admire and envy the large, really well equipped full shops,I really respect the guys who make it work in extremely limited space. Agree. I have seen very small basement shops that look totally inviting. For me it is about the process and the journey, not the destination. Doing woodworking is what is enjoyable for me. This means that sometimes I get things done quickly and sometimes I move pretty slow. As long as I'm moving and on this side of the grass I'm good. 4 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted September 17 Popular Post Report Posted September 17 On 9/17/2026 at 9:11 AM, gee-dub said: Agree. I have seen very small basement shops that look totally inviting. For me it is about the process and the journey, not the destination. Doing woodworking is what is enjoyable for me. This means that sometimes I get things done quickly and sometimes I move pretty slow. As long as I'm moving and on this side of the grass I'm good. Well said!! 3 Quote
Popular Post Tim O Posted September 17 Popular Post Report Posted September 17 Made a heart-shaped bandsaw box for my wife for our anniversary. I still need to do final sanding & finishing on it and it's about a week late, but it'll be a completed project (out of the 5 or 6 projects I've started so far). 7 Quote
Popular Post Sergio Escudero Posted September 21 Popular Post Report Posted September 21 I know I don't hang around here much, but I wanted to share my progress with my learning about saws. I finally have two usable saws. It hasn't been easy and I tend to overthink things for fear of messing up, so things that should take me two days take me 2 weeks. The vast majority of my saws were at a pre sharpening stage, so the handles had been repaired and finished again with shellac, blades had been sanded and derusted, the bolts cleaned and everything reassembled. With the saw vise I could now joint the teeth and get them ready for sharpening, but I realized that a few passes with the file with the jig I made wasn't enough for me, but rather some were going to need to be fully filed and have the teeth made again since the TPI was irregular in some. The rear third is perfect at 3 1/2, the first two inches came out immaculate at 4 1/2 (it's common for saws like this to have the first two inches with +1 TPI), but the middle zone was around 4 TPI ± 0.25, so the teeth didn't have uniform spacing along the whole length. Partly yes, but in some stretch I think there's an extra tooth. In the end I corrected what I could, sharpened it as best as could be done under those conditions and left it like that; otherwise I was going to have to file all the teeth and start from 0, and that means a lot of metal loss in a saw with these huge teeth. The rake angle is relaxed at 7 degrees, so it's very aggressive and cuts like a beast. To sharpen I used a huge triangular file by hand and without a handle. I did the set with an old Eclipse 77 and of the 12 numbers the anvil has to set the degree of tooth bend I left it at 10, very subtle, but I don't notice it binding. The teeth are HUGE. The other one I've finished is a Disston D8 of no less than 30", quite a beast. This one is dated between 1896-1917 and has 5 TPI; on this one I filed them almost completely and made them from 0. The funny thing is that I bought it on Wallapop from a guy who was selling a handful of saws of dubious quality as a lot and I saw it in the photo. I had been wanting one of these at all costs for a while, especially the one that has the thumbhole in the handle. In the end I bought it for 30€ because I get the feeling he didn't know what he had on his hands, which is common. This one has a fixed TPI but I gave 3 degrees backward to the rake angle as a Reddit user advised me. I almost would have liked it too if I had given it 0º and the front of the tooth were at 90º -as was my initial idea-. Subtle difference anyway. I used the Veritas sharpening guide on this one, but it wasn't indispensable either since I had a blade with the tooth pattern drawn on it, so I just had to remove metal until touching the line. On this one I left the set at 12, the highest number. What a machine at cutting, less aggressive than the 3 1/2 Keen Kutter for obvious reasons, but I can almost start the cut on the first push, since the other one with such a tooth is impossible. I tested both on a block of white oak about 6cm thick. As you can see my means for sawing are still crap, I used a stool on which I put a block of mongoy about 6cm thick to be almost at the proper work height. 7 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted September 21 Report Posted September 21 Nice job, those saws should serve you quite well. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.