Recommended Posts

Posted

We painted a house a couple of years ago with Home Depot's Marquee.  The nearest Home Depot, to where we were working, was about 60 miles away.  I underestimated by about a gallon, and needed to get one more gallon.  The only reason we were using the HD paint was because the owner had read a Consumer Reports test that rated it as the highest, and that's what he wanted us to use.

I didn't want to drive all the way to Home Depot, so I bought a gallon of white to match from Sherwin-Williams, so we could finish up that day.

Today, I gave a tour of that house to a group of Historic Preservation experts.  I didn't bring out what I saw about the paint, but to me, there was an obvious difference.

The Home Depot paint had released from two different types of caulking.  On the exact matching, mirror image side of the house, on the opposite side of the back porch, the Sherwin-Williams Emerald was still perfect all over, with no blemishes anywhere, including over that same caulking.  The caulking used for the different things was not only identical, but probably out of the same tubes, because we didn't need to use much.

The Emerald also covered better, in spite of the one coat claim of Home Depot.   The 20 dollar difference in the price, from one to the other,  with the HD paint being the cheaper, mattered not in saving anything on that job.  In fact, it would have been cheaper to use the Sherwin-Williams, even if we had paid full price for it, and that was before the issue with the bonding to caulking.

Posted
2 hours ago, Tom King said:

We painted a house a couple of years ago with Home Depot's Marquee.  The nearest Home Depot, to where we were working, was about 60 miles away.  I underestimated by about a gallon, and needed to get one more gallon.  The only reason we were using the HD paint was because the owner had read a Consumer Reports test that rated it as the highest, and that's what he wanted us to use.

I didn't want to drive all the way to Home Depot, so I bought a gallon of white to match from Sherwin-Williams, so we could finish up that day.

Today, I gave a tour of that house to a group of Historic Preservation experts.  I didn't bring out what I saw about the paint, but to me, there was an obvious difference.

The Home Depot paint had released from two different types of caulking.  On the exact matching, mirror image side of the house, on the opposite side of the back porch, the Sherwin-Williams Emerald was still perfect all over, with no blemishes anywhere, including over that same caulking.  The caulking used for the different things was not only identical, but probably out of the same tubes, because we didn't need to use much.

The Emerald also covered better, in spite of the one coat claim of Home Depot.   The 20 dollar difference in the price, from one to the other,  with the HD paint being the cheaper, mattered not in saving anything on that job.  In fact, it would have been cheaper to use the Sherwin-Williams, even if we had paid full price for it, and that was before the issue with the bonding to caulking.

Good to know I have some trim that needs painting this year the less I have to do it the better.

Posted

I might be painting the outside of our house soon this is good to know.

For interior paint I've used a can of most of the box store paint, and they all despite the cost need 2 coats. They all seemed about the same to me with the cheap stuff having a bit more gunk in it than the expensive stuff so i normally just go mid grade or what ever is on sale. I should try some Sherwin Williams for interior and see how it compares. I'm sure it's awesome.

Posted
10 hours ago, mat60 said:

My wife likes HD paint probably because of the price.  I try to explain it may be cheaper but it takes more coats to cover and it doesn't last.   After that I go get what she wants. 

Smart man.

Posted
51 minutes ago, Chestnut said:

I might be painting the outside of our house soon this is good to know.

For interior paint I've used a can of most of the box store paint, and they all despite the cost need 2 coats. They all seemed about the same to me with the cheap stuff having a bit more gunk in it than the expensive stuff so i normally just go mid grade or what ever is on sale. I should try some Sherwin Williams for interior and see how it compares. I'm sure it's awesome.

The Sherwin Williams interior paint is great. We used it when redoing our guest bedroom, and my wife picked a vivid teal as the color she wanted. We primed the walls first (they were mustard yellow before), then put down 2 coats of the SW paint and holy crap was it awesome. It was the easiest paint job I've ever done, it went on smooth, with no running or clumping. We could have stopped at one coat, but my OCD saw a few spots that were marginally lighter than the rest so I put another coat on. I'm gonna be sticking with SW paint for inside from now on. I'll take a picture when I can if you want.

Posted

Around here Home Depot pushes Behr paint & I hate the stuff. It is just a little cheaper but is lacking in durability & coverage. Most annoyingly, any kind of staining or discoloration on the substrate will bleed through. The paint over latex caulk will develop a slightly sticky surface that attracts dust & discolors.

I'd much rather spend extra on Sherwin Williams or Benny Moore.

Posted

Man, I just don't know. 

I obviously don't paint near as much as you Tom.  I know that several years ago we painted with paint from Wal-Mart (of all places) and it was awesome...I think it was a line of paint from Killz, and we were told at the time we bought it it wasn't going to be offered anymore.  I was blown away by the quality of that paint, being from Wal-Mart I guess I had low expectations.  A couple years later we switched to a big box paint, Behr I think it was, and it was terrible.  Poor coverage, needed more than two coats, even then had obvious thin spots.  After that awful Behr, we switched to Sherwin Williams and I was never truly impressed by it.  It was much better than the Behr, but still needed more than one coat and was just OK for the price.  Next time, we switched to what I THINK was probably the Marquee stuff from HD, and I thought it to be about on par with the Sherwin Williams but much cheaper.

Granted, each of these uses were two or three years between, not exactly side by side comparisons.  As dumb as it is, it seems like I'm always chasing the results I got from the stuff from Wal-Mart. 

Posted
11 hours ago, mat60 said:

My wife likes HD paint probably because of the price.  I try to explain it may be cheaper but it takes more coats to cover and it doesn't last.   After that I go get what she wants. 

I'm pretty much with you, it it's just her opinion vs mine.  On the other hand, if I'm doing the work and am armed with a story like Tom's, my wife will relent. ;-)

  • Like 1
Posted
3 hours ago, drzaius said:

Around here Home Depot pushes Behr paint & I hate the stuff. It is just a little cheaper but is lacking in durability & coverage. Most annoyingly, any kind of staining or discoloration on the substrate will bleed through. The paint over latex caulk will develop a slightly sticky surface that attracts dust & discolors.

I'd much rather spend extra on Sherwin Williams or Benny Moore.

Behr stain is equal garbage.  Lasted less than a year. 

A no VOC paint is my priority.  Paint off-gases for years.

Posted

I worked at a local chain hardware store for years. I mixed and sold several brands of paint, and was always amazed at the range of feedback I'd get from our customers (some homeowners, some contractors/business owners). However, you could never make a direct comparison because there were too many conditions and factors at play. Coverage varies greatly based on substrate color and paint color (not just light vs. dark). Adhesion can be greatly affected by substrate/air temperature, humidity, cleanliness, how well it was mixed, etc.

It's not often you get a direct comparison like this, where all other factors are equal and it really comes down to the paint brand/line itself.  Thanks for sharing!

Posted
17 hours ago, mat60 said:

My wife likes HD paint probably because of the price.  I try to explain it may be cheaper but it takes more coats to cover and it doesn't last.   After that I go get what she wants. 

"Yes, dear.  Whatever you say, dear."

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Posted

Here's a picture of the siding on the other side of the front porch.  This is the only place I could be sure that had some caulking under the paint, because there is a crack there.  That whole half of the house front, same side of the house, with same exposure as the previous picture, painted on the same day is perfect all over, so I had to look for a spot that I knew had caulking under it in that middle board in the picture.  This is with Emerald. 

Specs are just dirt.  We'll pressure wash this 1850 house late this August, after we're past the humid part of the Summer.

 

IMG_0878.JPG

Posted
2 hours ago, Tom King said:

Here's a picture of what the Marquee did over caulking.   This is maybe a little less than two years old.

IMG_0877.JPG

Behr does that too. Did I mention how much I hate Behr products?

Posted
11 hours ago, Minnesota Steve said:

I really like Benjamin Moore.

We have Benny M for our relatively new house, both interior and exterior for extraneous reasons (a friend was a dealer.)  It covered well with paint left over - but it was more expensive than the builder's choice!  Arguably, the cost difference was minimal.

 

[edit: I'd love to revisit this topic in a few years!]

Posted
8 hours ago, drzaius said:

Behr does that too. Did I mention how much I hate Behr products?

The Marquee is the top of the line Behr paint.  I'll not use it again regardless of what an owner requests, but after showing them this, I shouldn't have to argue.

I'm very glad I put my foot down on using Emerald for the window sash.  They all still look perfect.

Posted

We have had excellent experiences with Sherwin Williams over the past four years of remodeling projects. Previously used HD paint and this stuff is just tons better. I like repainting less.

  • Haha 1
  • 1 month later...
Posted
On 5/30/2018 at 6:37 PM, Tom King said:

The Emerald also covered better, in spite of the one coat claim of Home Depot.   The 20 dollar difference in the price, from one to the other,  with the HD paint being the cheaper, mattered not in saving anything on that job.  In fact, it would have been cheaper to use the Sherwin-Williams, even if we had paid full price for it, and that was before the issue with the bonding to caulking.

Tom, I'm going to buy paint for my shed tonight. How much coverage do you typically get out of a gallon of SW Emrald?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 45 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,007
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    FurniCore
    Newest Member
    FurniCore
    Joined