JRE Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 Hello, I am new to woodworking ( 3 years ) and have been limited to tools like miter saw, circular saw and jig saw. I am looking to purchase a table saw and would like to buy a Sawstop. There is a used contractor model for sale on Craigslist that I went by to see yesterday. He has it priced at 1550. I have concerns about the machine's condition as it was used extensively (as expected) and shows signs of damage . 2012 contractor saw with 36" table, mobile base included. My questions is, are the following concerns much of an issue, and is the price reflective of the current condition(in your opinion)?I'm going to attempt to attach pictures for a better description. I appreciate any help offered. 1)The blade clearly contacted the fence and has a shallow indention from the blade. there is a piece at the bottom that is chipped out. Would I need to replace? 2)The legs on the table are bent significantly and appear to have been reattached. They are not at the end of the table, but are instead attached more toward the middle. 3) The motor appears to sit funny. Is this the normal position as I see it can be adjusted. It hangs down exposing the spring and bolts on the plate it attaches to. Additionally the belt seems to be excessively exposed. The safety cycle that the sawstop runs through went fine and showed solid green. It fired up as well. I can tell this was probably used as a job site saw as the plastic on the fence is fogged out from sun exposure and there is some mud/dirt residue underneat the saw. This thing has definitely gotten some good use from the previous owner. Apologies for some obvious ignorance, but hoping someone can help bridge a bit of the gap. Thanks, JRE Quote
drzaius Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 Welcome JRE. SawStops have pretty high resale value, but that seems way high for a contractor machine that has seen heavy/rough usage. I'd pass. If you can swing it, the PCS is a much nicer saw. 1 Quote
mdbuilder Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 Ditto, 5 years old, heavily used and only 25% or so off new price - no... 2 Quote
OldSouthWoodCraft Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 Spend a little bit more money and buy a brand new powermatic instead. Sawstop saws are widely overrated and horribly overpriced IMHO. It's just a gimmick to me. Safety is your responsibility not the responsibility of your equipment. Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk Quote
Popular Post BonPacific Posted April 20, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 20, 2017 $1550 is a lot of money for a used Contractor saw, even a SawStop. I specc'd this out on their website, and a brand-new version of this setup would cost $1950, so $400 savings for some reasonably heavy use. Why are you trying to buy this saw? Is it just for the safety feature? Because there are comparable Cabinet saws out there which will serve you better for fine woodworking, and comparable contractor saws (without the safety) that cost $1000 less, which you could then save for other woodworking tools, or for a more permanent SawStop cabinet saw. If you are already spending this much money, I'd recommend getting the saw you want to use forever, rather than a stopgap. I can't comment on the motor, but if you've got this much concern on a Craigslist sale, my advice is walk. There are always going to be things you didn't notice until after you've owned the tool. 4 Quote
Gnarlywoodguy Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 PC175 owner. I'd pass. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Quote
Popular Post Eric. Posted April 20, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 20, 2017 52 minutes ago, OldSouthWoodCraft said: Spend a little bit more money and buy a brand new powermatic instead. Sawstop saws are widely overrated and horribly overpriced IMHO. It's just a gimmick to me. I pretty much completely disagree with this since Sawstop and Powermatic are so closely priced and similar in quality...for a few hundred bucks more you get the safety feature which is NOT a gimmick. That doesn't make it a necessity but let's call a spade a spade...the safety feature has saved fingers - period. So if I was in the market for a higher end saw it would be a no-brainer to buy the Sawstop. If you don't like their politics that's fine, but let's not deviate from reality over it. However, in this case, I'd rather have a brand new 3hp Grizzly cabinet saw than a beat up old Sawstop contractor saw for the same money. That makes no sense whatsoever. I do not own a Sawstop and everyone knows my opinions about Grizzly...and I love Powermatic. But sometimes practicality plays the trump card. 8 Quote
Woodenskye Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 I would also recommend the PM1000 which is about $2000. I believe it's 1.75 hp, and doesn't need 240v. But if you are already at max budget, then look at grizzly. Quote
Llama Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 Pass on the used machine. Price is too close... I have done a TON of research on tablesaws, and I'm with Eric on this. If I were in the market for a high end cabinet saw, I'd buy the SawStop without hesitation. The PM is too close in price to be a strong consideration. Next step down is the Grizzly at roughly a third to a fifth of the cost of the competition. If I were limited to under 2K for a saw, I'd buy the Grizzly. 2 Quote
Chet Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 I have A SawStop and I am real happy with it, but that saw does not look used it looks abused! I think you would be smart to pass. Quote
ben_r_ Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 Id keep saving and get a PCS. Sooo much nicer in every way than the contractor version. Quote
OldSouthWoodCraft Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 I pretty much completely disagree with this since Sawstop and Powermatic are so closely priced and similar in quality...for a few hundred bucks more you get the safety feature which is NOT a gimmick. That doesn't make it a necessity but let's call a spade a spade...the safety feature has saved fingers - period. I don't doubt that the Sawstop has saved fingers or whole hands. I just come from the industrial safety environment where there are alot of safety checks and proprietary safety equipment. But that doesn't stop accidents from happening. Like I said before safety is my responsibility. There are literally thousands of things in my daily job that can severely hurt me or kill me in the blink of an eye. So I have to rely on my own judgment and my own two eyes to see that things are safe. That's why I don't back Sawstop because it seems to give an inherent false sense of security and it doesn't fly with me. Sorry to hijack the post. Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk 2 Quote
Llama Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 14 minutes ago, OldSouthWoodCraft said: That's why I don't back Sawstop because it seems to give an inherent false sense of security and it doesn't fly with me. And also lowers insurance premiums on those types of shops. I don't disagree... But it's not the same as putting a cage around a robot. Someone will jump over the cage. If someone puts their hand on the blade, they won't get something cut off. 2 Quote
Eric. Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 22 minutes ago, OldSouthWoodCraft said: I don't doubt that the Sawstop has saved fingers or whole hands. I just come from the industrial safety environment where there are alot of safety checks and proprietary safety equipment. But that doesn't stop accidents from happening. Like I said before safety is my responsibility. There are literally thousands of things in my daily job that can severely hurt me or kill me in the blink of an eye. So I have to rely on my own judgment and my own two eyes to see that things are safe. That's why I don't back Sawstop because it seems to give an inherent false sense of security and it doesn't fly with me. Certainly people are responsible for their own safety and they shouldn't rely on machines to protect them from doing stupid things. The complacency argument is a valid one, and anyone with half a brain would consciously battle against such complacency in a routine way...by reminding yourself every time you start the saw that you need to pretend there is no safety mechanism and if the blade touches your hand you get hamburger. But for reasonable people who practice safe table saw habits in the first place, it's a hard argument to make that a secondary safety net isn't a good thing to one degree or another. The question then becomes...how much value is in the safety mechanism? These points of diminishing returns are different for everyone, and I think if a Sawstop of similar specs was twice the price of a Powermatic, far fewer Sawstop units would be sold. But that's not the case...they're very close in price and they stand toe-to-toe in build quality. If the safety mechanism on the Sawstop costs only a few hundred more than the Powermatic without the safety mechanism - and you're not sacrificing power or capacity or build quality in any other way - then the extra few hundred for the safety mechanism becomes a significant value...especially when you're already dropping thousands on a machine in the first place. It would be like buying a luxury vehicle with leather and heated seats and headlight wipers and a sunroof and everything else...but not paying the extra few hundred for power windows. (Not that they make luxury vehicles without power windows anymore but you get my point.) 2 Quote
knotscott Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 $1550 is very high for that saw in that condition with the steel wings IMO., and God only knows what's happened to make the motor sit funny. You can buy a new one with warranty with the T-Glide fence for ~ $1800. Do you have 220v available? Quote
Tom King Posted April 20, 2017 Report Posted April 20, 2017 Any kind of decent dust collection is almost impossible with a contractors saw. I used one as my main saw for over 20 years, and guess I'm just lucky that I can still breathe. 1 Quote
Popular Post Chet Posted April 21, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted April 21, 2017 4 hours ago, OldSouthWoodCraft said: That's why I don't back Sawstop because it seems to give an inherent false sense of security and it doesn't fly with me. Eric saved me a lot of typing but I would like to add that as an owner of a SawStop there hasn't been one day of use that I have taken anything for granted. It is still a spinning blade that need to be respected and everything still has to be set up properly and safely. The braking system has to be looked at as an added feature not an instead of feature. The braking system that is there doesn't stop kickbacks or other unsafe operating mishaps. Anybody that uses a SawStop saw in a complacent way just shouldn't be in a shop in my opinion. I don't think that you can turn on stupid when you are using your SawStop and then turn it off and turn on smart when you go to another power tool in your shop. 5 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted April 21, 2017 Report Posted April 21, 2017 I'll weigh in just to say that that saw looks almost EXACTLY like my 15 year-old Rigid contractor saw, except mine is in much better condition, and is worth about $200 in my market. That price is outrageous, safety feature or not. Aside from purchase price, one must also consider the extra maintenance costs that go with owning a sawstop. If the cartridge fires, you're out a blade and a cartridge. There are extra electronics that can fail and keep the saw from working. I assume repairs to the safety system must be performed by a licensed repair center. The blade brake is a genius idea, and appears to work well. Its value to YOU is totally up to you to decide. My personal choice is to NOT own one, because I value a reliable, low-cost machine over the safety feature. If Sawstop's creator had been succesful in his bid for legislation to mandate this brake system on every table saw, I would be priced out of machine woodworking. 1 Quote
Andrew1 Posted April 21, 2017 Report Posted April 21, 2017 Parts are bent that you can see. What about what you haven't seen yet. Pass. I would take my cheap Ridgid I tuned over a machine I don't know if I could even tune. Quote
jplemons Posted April 21, 2017 Report Posted April 21, 2017 I think it's way overpriced. If you can continue to save for a 1.75 PCS, do so. I enjoy working with my Sawstop every time I turn it on. To me, it was worth the extra couple hundred over the Powermatic. It's a damn good saw without the brake, and no one can really dispute that. And this is coming from someone who recently destroyed a nice crosscut blade and brake due to a mistake -- not one that would have cost any flesh -- but I would buy a Sawstop again in a heartbeat. Quote
gee-dub Posted April 21, 2017 Report Posted April 21, 2017 You've figured out by now that the price is way high and the abuse too severe. My first saw was a used c-man contractor. After throwing a couple hundred bucks in after-market stuff at it to make it usable, I bought a hybrid; loved that saw but, wanted more power. I then bought a 3HP 10" cab saw (Saw Stop) and never looked back. If you have $1500 to spend on used, save for a few months and just by a cab saw and be happy. It doesn't have to be a Saw Stop. There are a few saws in that price range ($3k) that will serve you well. The safety feature is just a bonus. 2 Quote
Nestor Posted April 21, 2017 Report Posted April 21, 2017 I'm with most everyone else. It's not much of a deal. Save some more and get the cabinet saw. ______________________________________ Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Quote
JRE Posted April 21, 2017 Author Report Posted April 21, 2017 Wow! Thank you all for the responses and feedback, it is greatly appreciated! I'm very glad I stumbled on the site, this place appears to be very active and informative. I have decided to pass, which appears to be the unanimous feedback. And as many of you recommended, I'm just going to wait longer and save up for a cabinet saw. It sounds like most end up there eventually so waiting sounds like a good move. Again, thanks for all of the responses. JRE 2 Quote
RichardA Posted April 21, 2017 Report Posted April 21, 2017 Since you were about to spring for$1500 for the sawstop, why not get a cabinet saw from Grizzly in that price range? Generally the saws that Grizzly has in that price range are decent, and will last you many years. They're not a sawstop, but then with care you can keep your fingers. and still have a good working tool. 2 Quote
knotscott Posted April 22, 2017 Report Posted April 22, 2017 If you do have 220v, I'd give the Grizzly G1023RL or G0690 a good look at around the same price as the used SS contractor saw. Both are 3hp industrial cabinet saws that are among the best bangs for the buck on the market. They don't have the flesh sensing technology, but are a much more substantial saws than that particular Saw Stop model. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.