Chestnut Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 So this year I'll be remodeling 3 bathroom vanities by replacing the cabinet and vanity tops. I will also be remodeling the cabinets in our laundry room slightly changing things around that will involve a utility sink and counter top. So I'm reaching out to the community on what my options are and what your opinion is on the best option? Are there options I'm missing? Right now the options I see are: Vanity top from a home center (home depot, lowes, etc) but I'm not really fond of how thin and kinda cheap they look. Their benefit is the sink is molded into the top so no seams to clean. Counter top place with under mount sink. Look is a bit higher end but the sink will have a seam. Not sure if that seam is a deal breaker or not. Laminate counter top cheaper, maybe not as desirable. Diy solid surface/ corian, this seems like a bit more work for me but could be less expensive Quote
BillyJack Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 Sounds like you need to decide to commit money... Quote
Chestnut Posted January 7, 2021 Author Report Posted January 7, 2021 26 minutes ago, BillyJack said: Why would there be a seam.. 29 minutes ago, BillyJack said: Sounds like you need to decide to commit money... Moulded in place or factory attached sink vs added after. The seam between the under mount sink and counter top. Not sure what you mean about needing to decide to commit money... The money is allocated and comitted, i want a product that i won't hate in 10 years. Quote
JohnG Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 Following. We are adding a full bathroom to our basement this year and need to start deciding on fixtures, etc. 1 Quote
BillyJack Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 A seam in the undermine sink? Guess I'm confused.. Most people when they upgrade are looking for that WOW factor. Have you looked at pinterest? Quote
Tpt life Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 5 minutes ago, BillyJack said: A seam in the undermine sink? Guess I’m confused... The seam between the bowl and the top. Quote
BillyJack Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 I get that ,I'm not understanding the deal breaker part... My daughter had one put in her kitchen? Its a sealed seam... When I redid my kitchen counter top I just relaminated it and put trim around it to upgrade it. The same as my bar... 1 Quote
Tpt life Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 It really depends on how the under mount is sealed. Older silicones did not have good inhibitors and were notorious for growing mold. I don’t think that is as big an issue any more. Quote
Chestnut Posted January 7, 2021 Author Report Posted January 7, 2021 13 minutes ago, BillyJack said: I get that ,I'm not understanding the deal breaker part... Wife wants easy to clean and doesn't accumulate gunk. If an under mount is possible with out a large crevice that is goign to look dirty than I'm on board. Below is an example of what I DO NOT want. This gap is almost 1/2" wide at the top and about 1/4" deep. I don't want to clean that ever. This is spiraling in a direction I'm not sure I want. Looking for recommendations on what has worked for people in the past and there experiences with the above options and input on other options I'm not aware of. Also opinion on mounting the counter my self or just having a pro do the entire thing. Cost is a background consideration. I don't want to spend money stupidly but I'm not goign to turn away a good thing because of cost. Quote
Immortan D Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 I'm not sure I like them, but google silestone integrity sinks. 1 Quote
BonPacific Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 I've got undermounts for both my sinks and wouldn't consider any other option if we had to remodel again. Bathroom vanity was bought pre-made (off of some furniture site I can't remember) with a porcelain basin and marble top, kitchen was a steel homecenter sink I purchased and handed off to the marble installers. Pre-made has a gap similar to your picture but it's hidden by the overhang of the countertop. There's no gunk in there, but a bathroom will have a lot less buildup than a kitchen sink. The kitchen sink is almost a perfect flush fit, you can't even see the silicone unless you look from inside the cabinet. I've never owned a molded-basin, but when I've encountered them at friends houses or the like I've never been a fan. They're almost always too shallow and end up splashing water all over the place. So I guess my recommendation if you want the best seam is going to be get it custom fitted and pick out the sink you like with the sharpest 90 degree angle for mounting. I should mention we have a cleaning/maid service that comes through monthly. They're the ones who would be scrubbing out any trapped gunk, but we never noticed an issue for the years before we had them either. 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 My bathrooms have one-piece molded sink/counter tops. Cleaning is a breeze, and there is no extra joint to leak. No experience with under-mounts. But I thought the trendy thing these days were the surface-mount sinks that look like a bowl sitting on the counter? I've seen glass, ceramic, and wood versions, but the coolest (IMO) are the hollowed-out granite boulders... All of which seem problematic for realistic daily use. 1 Quote
pkinneb Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 Couple things. First any of the options would work and I would add one more make your own and use epoxy for the top. While I'm not sure I would use in my kitchen they are definitely solid contenders for bars baths etc. Very cost effective and highly flexible as you get to design /build the counter. Here is an example from one of our baths. 1 Quote
Popular Post BonPacific Posted January 7, 2021 Popular Post Report Posted January 7, 2021 I'll let my curmudgeon flag fly. I hate those vessel sinks with an unreasonable passion. 3 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 @pkinneb, do the bowls seem deep enough to limit splash-out? I like the look of that style, but always worried about it being messy. 1 Quote
Chet Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 Drew, We have had a vanity top in our master bath for 10 years, it's made by a company called Swanstone. We have been super pleased with it and it cleans real easy. We purchased it through Lowes but I don't think they carry it any more. But Swanstone still exists and I am sure they would be able to point you toward a retailer if they don't sell direct. Its a product that is similar to Corian and the whole thing is molded in one piece. Our shower enclosure and shower pan are the same thing and the same color which can be nice when planing what you want. What looks like dark streaking in the picture isn't stains it the faucet shadow. After having our kitchen counters done recently in Corian I am not sure I would look at it as a DYI project especially if you want one of their sinks molded in, or the coved back splash which in appearance alone is worth the extra money over the regular splash. I am sure that you could have the vanity top made by a pro shop and then install it yourself. Their sinks only come in three shades of white. Again even though we haven't had the kitchen counter that long we are real happy with the fact there are no seams with the Corian sink. 1 Quote
BillyJack Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 I would talk to your local cabinets vanity supplier and see what they offer. They have options 1 Quote
Tom King Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 Back when I was building new houses, and Solid Surface was the top choice for countertops, I fabricated a number of them for both bathrooms, and kitchens. I think the first was in 1982, and the last sometime towards the end of the '90's. There's nothing hard to do about it, but you do need some specialized router bits. Using the router is no different than on wood, but you need good dust collection. The bits I don't think are much different than other carbide tipped router bits, but the bearings are made out of solid surface material, so there is no markoff from the metal. The big bit for the sink to top joint is like a big roundover bit, but it tapers down to match the bowl slope, rather than being 90 degrees. I used to have to go to Richmond, Va., or Raleigh, NC to find suppliers, but the cost was a Fraction of getting someone else to fabricate them. 2 Quote
BillyJack Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 I went to work for a solid surface company about 20 years ago. The companies name was Fabricor. There were two main companies in kansas city and you have to sign a agreement you couldn't work for your competitor for 5 years onepce yo left either one. It was a joke back then. Highly competitive labor force. They needed a highly skilled cabinet maker to do some high end work on columns. It was interesting . most of the work is done with basic cabinet tools. After two weeks and almost being hit at 4:30 in the morning by late, half aslerp, drinking coffee maniacs and after I found out the forman didn't like me because I made as much as he and he had been there 10 years. I quit... I'll never go back. Quote
Chestnut Posted January 7, 2021 Author Report Posted January 7, 2021 1 hour ago, BonPacific said: I've never owned a molded-basin, but when I've encountered them at friends houses or the like I've never been a fan. They're almost always too shallow and end up splashing water all over the place. So I guess my recommendation if you want the best seam is going to be get it custom fitted and pick out the sink you like with the sharpest 90 degree angle for mounting. I should mention we have a cleaning/maid service that comes through monthly. They're the ones who would be scrubbing out any trapped gunk, but we never noticed an issue for the years before we had them either. Thanks for the input. Do you have any idea on depth of the sinks you have? I just did a custom design thing through a local box store and they have 5" depth 6.5" depth and 8.5" depth sink options. 8.5" seems like a bit much but would it really hurt anything other than reducing storage in the vanity? The cleaning service skews your opinion slightly . 1 hour ago, Immortan D said: I'm not sure I like them, but google silestone integrity sinks. They are offered at Home Depot that is 0.5 miles from my house I'll have to take a look. They look interesting none the less. I'm not entirely sure if I like the angular sink opposed to the traditional bowl shape. 1 hour ago, wtnhighlander said: My bathrooms have one-piece molded sink/counter tops. Cleaning is a breeze, and there is no extra joint to leak. No experience with under-mounts. But I thought the trendy thing these days were the surface-mount sinks that look like a bowl sitting on the counter? I've seen glass, ceramic, and wood versions, but the coolest (IMO) are the hollowed-out granite boulders... All of which seem problematic for realistic daily use. Been there done that. I thought the vessel sink was a breeze to clean. Have to post a picture because i should be publicly shamed for this. @wtnhighlander I never had issues with splash out. Water splashed out occasionally but not a significant amount. Intended it to be temporary, as you can see I didn't even sand off the factory skew number on the right side of the front apron. Everyone liked it and the house ended up being sold with it this way.... oopps. Megan hated it she said never again. So wife veto. 1 hour ago, Chet said: Drew, We have had a vanity top in our master bath for 10 years, it's made by a company called Swanstone. Good recommendation. I like the look of the sink having the same texture as the top. It seems the trend is to have the bowl be white or "bisque" color... As far as DIY your are right. It was a thought for about an hour and i have thought better of it until i read Tom's comment above. I'm not a back splash fan and will be option for none. If I do anything it'll be tile or something similar, but likely nothing. 1 hour ago, pkinneb said: First any of the options would work and I would add one more make your own and use epoxy for the top. This was supposed to be on my original list. I may do the bathrooms from a store so I can have the all "match". It's very tempting to do I've went back to your basement journal multiple times. 1 Quote
BonPacific Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 5 minutes ago, Chestnut said: Thanks for the input. Do you have any idea on depth of the sinks you have? I just did a custom design thing through a local box store and they have 5" depth 6.5" depth and 8.5" depth sink options. 8.5" seems like a bit much but would it really hurt anything other than reducing storage in the vanity? The cleaning service skews your opinion slightly . 6" for the vanity. In a perfect world I'd want about another inch of depth, just because my mitts are a bit too big to wash inside the sink. In my defense on the maid, we had the sinks at least a year first :). 1 Quote
legenddc Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 We have 2 bathroom sinks with an undermount lip and they stay just as clean as the silly bowl vessel one. Even the ones the kids use daily stays clean there. The rest of it is another story but no issues with it getting grimy. 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted January 7, 2021 Report Posted January 7, 2021 Drew, why don't you convince Megan that at least ONE of those sinks should be a Frank Klausz - style waterstone pond? DIY, easy-peasy! 1 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted January 7, 2021 Author Report Posted January 7, 2021 Thanks for all the input on the seams to sinks. I wasn't leaning granite but now I'm considering it. 35 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said: Drew, why don't you convince Megan that at least ONE of those sinks should be a Frank Klausz - style waterstone pond? DIY, easy-peasy! I would LOVE to have a sink like that. Or even to make an entire vanity top out of Ipe top sink and all. It'll NEVER happen. I guess never say never. Maybe if i run plumbing to my shed and put a sink out there.... 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.