Recommended Posts

Posted

Well friends, it's official. The Schwarz has spoken! Now you must all make Roman benches!

We'll see what type of bench we need to make in the future. Or what sells more books... 

Posted

I saw Schwarz on The Woodwright's Shop showing off a bench he designed by looking at a wall relief carving from some Roman ruins. If that's the same bench you're talking about, he can keep it. I like my mechanical advantages, thank you very much!

  • Like 1
Posted

Looks quite suited for post Neanderthal technology. Might need that info for the zombie apocalypse !

Kinda glad someone is preserving the knowledge. Kinda glad it isn't me. Looks perfect for Tom Kings historically correct restoration work.

  • Like 2
Posted
34 minutes ago, wdwerker said:

Kinda glad someone is preserving the knowledge.

I am too... I certainly toss a lot of crap at Schwarz... He gets it honestly though. I think some of it is his excitement for the next great woodworking discovery... The part that bothers me as it happens so often it comes across as disingenuous.

Steve, you should look into the Mortise and Tenon books. They are full of information! (including this Roman bench)... 

Posted

In a world filled with content creator trendsetters Chris is a major trendsetter in handtool benches.  His focus is on historical woodworking methodologies and this sparks a constant evolution of his bench design.  Handtool purists often spend a lifetime in search of the perfect bench and generally go through many evolutions, Chris just feeds this desire with ideas.  

Posted

I welcome anything that helps our understanding of the craft. I too saw the Woodwright episode about the Roman workbench. Will I build one? Nope. Do I think it helps our scholarship about how one aspect of woodworking could have been done? You bet.

As for giving someone grief because they've written articles and books about their passion, all I can say is "Go for it!" There's plenty of room in the world for more articles and books about woodworking. Writing for publication is a lot harder than it looks and we need all the successes we can get. (Spoken from experience, with 15+ books about software to my credit.)

  • Like 2
Posted

He's the first to tell you not to listen to him if you find a way that works better for you.  I've met him a few times and he's cool, I don't think he enjoys getting the messiah treatment by some of the fans.  I have quite a few of the Lost Art Press books and have enjoyed all of them, but if you're not interested in a historical bent then obviously they won't appeal.  The only criticism of the business ventures would be that I can't wrap my head around the Crucible Tools offerings, at prices that I could have the items hand forged by a blacksmith.  But I guess things cost what they cost, not much economics of scale having niche items manufactured. 

Posted

I enjoy reading and watching Schwarz's material - and Marc's, Pekovich's, Kenney's, St. Roy's, David Marks', ShannFitzpatrick, many of y'all's and others. I glean as much useable information as possible from the best teachers/practitioners I can identify. I like learning so I tend to immerse myself in whatever I'm doing. I keep whatever fits my methodology and practice then file away the rest. 

I do agree with Eric about emphasis. I need to build a new workbench but haven't decided which style. Being exposed to a variety is great but in the final analysis it must be based on how I work not how someone else does. Mine will incorporate what fits my approach which I am still refining. 

As someone who works in the field of history, I like learning about how woodworking used to be done even though I have no intention of ever building a Roman style bench. I equally appreciate Schwarz's study of the Studley tool cabinet though I will never build one. Keeping the history alive is a valuable and enlightening practice. I sincerely appreciate Chris' willingness to delve into difficult texts and trying to bring out some nuggets worth considering. I ain't reading Ruobo's tome:) 

As I improve and evolve in woodworking I tend to gravitate to people who challenge me and share a design aesthetic. I started out watching YouTube guys using pallets and plywood (forgive me Father Eric, for I have sinned - LOL) to build basic projects with pocket holes and butt joints. It was a starting point. I'm at a different stage now and am grateful there are so many opportunities and platforms to grow in the craft - including this forum!!

  • Like 1
Posted

If you read Schwarz's book on benches he boils it down pretty well.  Heavy, stable, not too wide and as long as you can fit into your space. The Roman bench fits with his ideas from the Anarchist Design Book on building furniture (and benches) without a lot of tools or difficult joints. And he clearly states you can ignore his advice. I've always found it pretty darn good.  And Eric, he only uses nails in some of his project.

Posted

Never said his advice was bad. Only that he has ALOT of it. There is nothing inherently wrong with that either. He is a little funny about calling them suggestions and not rules. :) 

Posted

I find the historical aspects of Schwarz's bech books fascinating. However,he keeps going BACKWARD through tbe evolution of the woodworking bench. Outside of historical re-enactment, why would anyone want to build a more primative bench?


  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 47 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined