lewisc Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 Just finished making this bench out of pine and paint according to the wife's instructions. Apparently still not rustic enough!! The tapered legs are too refined, you can't see the timber through the paint and the top is too shiny. Next time I'll just throw it down some stairs and pour some stain on top and see how that goes. It did give me a chance to try some new techniques though. I hadn't done breadboard ends before or use the z type table clips. I now prefer them to making up buttons for joining the base to the top. 1 Quote
Popular Post RichardA Posted May 3, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted May 3, 2017 It looks plenty solid. Try a rope to the bumper of your car, and take it for a bumpy ride., That should rustic it up enough! 3 Quote
Southwood Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 6 minutes ago, RichardA said: Try a rope to the bumper of your car, and take it for a bumpy ride., That should rustic it up enough! That's what I was going to say. This "rustic" crap has to stop sooner or later. You could take some black wax and give it a good coat. Will get stuck in the grain and corners. Makes it look dirty 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 Put a coat of amber shellac on the top, and let it dry. Then use the highest grit pad you can find for your ROS, and just barely wear through the corners & edges. Think about how normal use would wear those areas over time, and emulate it. Then hit it with the dark wax. Most of the time, "simulated antique" will substitute just fine for "rustic", and you won't feel so bad about trashing your work. BTW, you can make your own colored wax by melting regular paste wax in a double boiler, and adding wax shoe polish until the desired tint is achieved. 1 Quote
Popular Post Llama Posted May 3, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted May 3, 2017 I agree... That's more of a country style than rustic. True rustic takes time. Time outside in the rain. Time in a field. Think barn wood... Think grey... And I don't see any cracks in the top. Might want to use it as a sawhorse for a few years first, then she'll be happy. 3 Quote
gee-dub Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 The bench looks great. For a good rustic look, just go buy something classy like this. Quote
lewisc Posted May 3, 2017 Author Report Posted May 3, 2017 3 minutes ago, gee-dub said: The bench looks great. For a good rustic look, just go buy something classy like this. That's what I'm missing. The bolts! I'll let this one age naturally. I have no idea where to start or couldn't bring myself to ding it up. Although mixing some shoe polish with wax could give some interesting results. I'll have to do some tests on that one. Quote
Popular Post Eric. Posted May 3, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted May 3, 2017 You need to take pinterest away from your wife. She's hit bottom, time for an intervention. 6 Quote
Woodenskye Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 Nice bench Lewis, but I have to agree with Eric, you need to block Pinterest from all devices in the household. My GF shows me stuff and I just shrug, not my style and we already have to much stuff in the house. So far that becomes the end of things. Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted May 3, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted May 3, 2017 7 minutes ago, Woodenskye said: Nice bench Lewis, but I have to agree with Eric, you need to block Pinterest from all devices in the household. My GF shows me stuff and I just shrug, not my style and we already have to much stuff in the house. So far that becomes the end of things. When I am in my role as an average internet 'user', nothing has so negatively impacted my internet use as Pintrest since I don't know when. It has polluted search results, made image search functions all but useless and contributed heavily to the rapid decline of western society. I don't even hate Facebook as much as I do Pintrest. 4 Quote
treeslayer Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 @lewisc, don't forget to block HGTV, i wish i had 10 years ago, i would have a lot more free time 1 Quote
Coop Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 It's a good thing you didn't fill the knot hole with epoxy, you'd have had a fight on your hands. Nice job! Quote
..Kev Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 Great looking bench! I agree completely with the comments above about the removal of Pinterest! 1 Quote
drzaius Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 Interesting observations about Pinterest. I know nothing about it except that as soon as I heard about it years ago, something deep in my soul sad 'this is bad, stay away'. So I did. Quote
Chud Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 1 hour ago, gee-dub said: When I am in my role as an average internet 'user', nothing has so negatively impacted my internet use as Pintrest since I don't know when. It has polluted search results, made image search functions all but useless and contributed heavily to the rapid decline of western society. I don't even hate Facebook as much as I do Pintrest. Ask and ye shall receive - add the following to your search query on Google -site:pintrest.com It will block results from pinterest. 2 Quote
shaneymack Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 I agree with her. I dont think it looks "rustic". And for that reason it's a nice bench. Good job ! Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk 2 Quote
BonPacific Posted May 3, 2017 Report Posted May 3, 2017 Nice looking bench. Too bad you and your wife don't have the same style. I actually like using Pinterest myself, but as a tool for finding interesting joints or examples of furniture that I can adapt. I find the image search to be just a little better than google when looking for wood working. Quote
lewisc Posted May 3, 2017 Author Report Posted May 3, 2017 Thanks. A few lessons learnt from this one. Now on to finer things. Quote
gee-dub Posted May 4, 2017 Report Posted May 4, 2017 22 hours ago, Chud said: Ask and ye shall receive - add the following to your search query on Google -site:pinterest.com It will block results from pinterest. FTFY Quote
Pondhockey Posted May 5, 2017 Report Posted May 5, 2017 Lewis, I like your work; I think it shows nice craftsmanship. I think that's what the other posters are responding to in their support. This forum is wonderfully supportive, no matter what crap I show them, including my rustic stuff (that's what I do), and I think that they value craftsmanship over "rustic". In fact, rustic is almost an excuse to skip the craftsmanship. I agree with Llama that the style you used is something that in the US (I'm being very presumptuous, here) might be called "country". Which brings up the definition of "rustic". Of course in this situation, rustic is whatever your wife calls "rustic"; she's the boss. I have had very similar conversations with my spouse, and so, for us, "rustic" is what I'm going to call "Mountain Rustic". For context, we live (yes) in the mountains, with no opera, lots of backcountry, and my house has a mudroom that's probably as big as your master bedroom (that's where a few of our "rustic" pieces are.) Mountain Rustic is what fits here. So here's my 2 cents. Rustic elements (acknowledging that this might be regional) might include 1) live edge, 2) large, black iron fixtures (e.g. bolts), 3) large pieces of wood (such as wood beams, 4) in my wife's case, it includes dark staining (over my own wishes, since I think it hides the beautiful wood figure.) For you: depending on the boss' input, you could: 1) darken the wood top (note that if you first finish the wood with a coat or two of varnish and then use Van Dyke Brown glaze, followed by more varnish, then the process is reversible.) 2) you may be able to use Van Dyke Brown right over the white paint, in an artistic fashion, simulating wood grain. 3) a few black metal brackets on the legs, although superfluous, would lend an air of "Mountain Rustic", and provide a place for rustic black bolts/screws (big ones, of course.) 4) if you can bring yourself to do it, use a plane to make gouges in the corners of the surface wood and the legs. Erik would suggest that you try all these things on scrap wood first, which allows an additional means of show and tell, to try to ferret out the Boss' notion of "rustic". I hesitate to suggest, but this may mean more shared time on (shudder) P*****est, to try to further ascertain the Boss' notion of "rustic". "Mountain Rustic" examples follow: 1 Quote
lewisc Posted May 5, 2017 Author Report Posted May 5, 2017 I like your use of the boards as a coat rack. It seems a nice way to add some interest to the wall. Making something rustic seems a little foreign to me. It just can't bring my self to make things they way I see it in the pictures. Saw marks need to go, edges need to be straight and clean. My version of rustic just doesn't make the cut. There were a few parts on the bench I could tolerate being not quite right but mostly I like to finish things neatly. I had this same issue when I made our blanket chest. I bought some used timber that had insect holes, nail holes and natural defects. I proceeded to mill it and join everything neatly. It was the first time I tried dovetails in a large peice of furniture and they turned out ok. A few gaps but on the whole they weren't bad. When it came time to sand, I worked through the grits and got to a level I was happy with and finished it. When the wife saw it, she said the same thing. Not rustic enough. For me, it was. My standard is different to hers. The lid actually shrunk and twisted a bit and I haven't done anything about it. I made it before I knew about methods to keep it flat. Maybe that can be rustic worthy. 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted May 5, 2017 Report Posted May 5, 2017 Lewis, I'll side with you on this one - that chest is perfectly 'rustic'. By that, I mean it is a well-crafted piece, of simple design, using materials at hand. Perhaps your wife's idea of rustic is what I consider 'primitive'. That would be a piece of utilitarian design and construction, again using materials at hand, but with less skill evident on the part of the maker. That might be due to a lack of skill, or simple expediency. Fit and finish are not as important as function. Primitive pieces are sometimes unfinished, bare wood. Or perhaps she calls rustic what I call (politely)"shabby". Some old piece that was dragged out of a dumpster and immediately listed on etsy. Quote
Popular Post Eric. Posted May 5, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted May 5, 2017 We have this kind of unspoken code in my house and it goes like this: I'm the wood guy. I know about wood and stuff. She doesn't. Also, I'm the one spending thousands of hours in the shop building beautiful handmade things for our house. She gets what I make and knows not to complain. She's allowed to request "which project comes next"...but what it looks like is under my jurisdiction. I know about wood and stuff. She doesn't. Everyone is happy. 3 Quote
bgreenb Posted May 5, 2017 Report Posted May 5, 2017 1 hour ago, Eric. said: We have this kind of unspoken code in my house and it goes like this: I'm the wood guy. I know about wood and stuff. She doesn't. Also, I'm the one spending thousands of hours in the shop building beautiful handmade things for our house. She gets what I make and knows not to complain. She's allowed to request "which project comes next"...but what it looks like is under my jurisdiction. I know about wood and stuff. She doesn't. Everyone is happy. Pretty much the same in my house. It seldom causes conflict because my wife and I have very similar taste. We have had a few design disagreements in the past, and literally *every single time* she looked at the finished product and admitted I was right and she was wrong. She has since learned to trust my instincts. I do get her input on minor aspects of the design (proportion, type of moulding, etc.) because I trust her stylistic eye.** She does upholstery and is a very good painter as well. In return for her leeway on my woodworking I never question her choices in her spheres of influence, so to speak. **her for proportion and spatial awareness is incredible. I can hang a picture in the "center" of a wall, and she can take one look and instantly tell me it needs to be moved 1/8" to the right. One time I was hanging a frame, and she came in and said it wasn't level and the right side had to come up a hair. I walked to where she was standing and looked myself. Said she was nuts. "look at the level, the bubble is dead nuts center", I said. "Then your level is wrong" she said. Brought my level out to my shop and checked it with a straightedge. Sure enough it was bowed. Got another level and she was right. Now I never doubt her eye. She's got fighter pilot vision. Makes me self conscious about being naked. But I suppose that's a conversation for another forum. 2 Quote
Eric. Posted May 5, 2017 Report Posted May 5, 2017 3 minutes ago, bgreenb said: Pretty much the same in my house. It seldom causes conflict because my wife and I have very similar taste. We have had a few design disagreements in the past, and literally *every single time* she looked at the finished product and admitted I was right and she was wrong. She has since learned to trust my instincts. I do get her input on minor aspects of the design (proportion, type of moulding, etc.) because I trust her stylistic eye.** She does upholstery and is a very good painter as well. In return for her leeway on my woodworking I never question her choices in her spheres of influence, so to speak. **her for proportion and spatial awareness is incredible. I can hang a picture in the "center" of a wall, and she can take one look and instantly tell me it needs to be moved 1/8" to the right. One time I was hanging a frame, and she came in and said it wasn't level and the right side had to come up a hair. I walked to where she was standing and looked myself. Said she was nuts. "look at the level, the bubble is dead nuts center", I said. "Then your level is wrong" she said. Brought my level out to my shop and checked it with a straightedge. Sure enough it was bowed. Got another level and she was right. Now I never doubt her eye. She's got fighter pilot vision. Makes me self conscious about being naked. But I suppose that's a conversation for another forum. Wow, that's impressive perception. My wife doesn't have that. She knows if she likes something or not, but that's the extent of her awareness about furniture, generally. You probably have a slightly easier situation, since you both like traditional furniture that more or less fits nicely into certain categories of style...there are "rules" to follow, so to speak. My pieces are more improvisational and built upon whimsy, and they're all different. She knows to expect only one thing, which is the unexpected. There's not a shred of continuity among my furniture...whatever tickles my wood bone at the time I go into a project is what I build. And she gives me all the rope I need to hang myself. To her credit, she's graciously tolerated some fairly weird pieces over the years. She has her favorites and her least favorites, but she never complains about any of them. She's just grateful...like she should be. I think her mother is a good influence on her in how she reacts to my pieces, because she absolutely drools over them and showers me with praise every time I finish one. She's constantly telling my wife how lucky she is to live in a house full of handmade goodies. She's a good MIL. 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.