Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dimensional lumber lawsuit

Featured Replies

  • Popular Post

I saw this the other day and can't decide how I feel about it.  Sometimes we are getting screwed by Mr. Big but I am also tired of all the adults in this country demanding that their hands be held as they go through life.  For crying out load how long have we been calling them 2 X 4's and 4 X 4's knowing that they weren't.

  • Popular Post

They could call me as an expert witness in this one.   I remember when 2x4's became 1-1/2x3-1/2 here.  It was long before Home Depot opened their first store in 1978.   They were just following industry standards from their start.

I would say that there are very few builders who now even remember when a 2x4 was actually 2x4.  Then, they were only available from local mills, which most building suppliers owned, and had on the premises.

Having worked on houses built every decade over the last 250 years, I can tell you when sizing standards changed for about any house framing part.

Yeccch.  Barfff.

A frivolous lawsuit if there ever was one.  I'll be disappointed if it isn't squashed (not settled.)

 

4 hours ago, Tom King said:

They could call me as an expert witness in this one.   I remember when 2x4's became 1-1/2x3-1/2 here.  It was long before Home Depot opened their first store in 1978.   They were just following industry standards from their start.

I would say that there are very few builders who now even remember when a 2x4 was actually 2x4.  Then, they were only available from local mills, which most building suppliers owned, and had on the premises.

Having worked on houses built every decade over the last 250 years, I can tell you when sizing standards changed for about any house framing part.

So here's a serious question, kind of related (I don't have enough hardwood buying experience to know):  what is the usual practice when sawing a 4/4 thickness board - is it usually sawed a bit over nominal?  I would say that our local guy usually leaves it about 1/16 above nominal.

Edited by Pondhockey
milling -> sawing

For me its been 1 1/16 to 1 1/8.       So yes it is milled a bit over.

Up until the 1860's they were 1-1/8" since the mid 18th Century around here.  I've seen a lot of boards almost 1-1/8" thick, hand planed on one side.   I always thought they wanted to make sure they gave full measure, up until things got tight after the Civil War around here.  Since then, just close to an inch one way or the other.

Quick, start compiling a list of other misleading measurements you could sue over if this case succeeds, and maybe you can make a fortune. The most confusing has to be iron pipe where, say, half-inch pipe has nothing remotely half-inch. OK, We all know why but it is at least as misleading as lumber sizes.

  • Popular Post

I think the plaintiffs in that case should be sued for being morons.

48 minutes ago, Eric. said:

I think the plaintiffs in that case should be sued for being morons.

And a thousand Likes be upon you! :-)

My Dad, born in 26, appeared to grow up in the transition. When I was helping him tear down some old late 19th & early 20th c. rural homes the studs were clearly 2x4, etc.

He used to cuss the shrinking/milling done to the boards when building our added-on garage. Perhaps because it had been decades since he'd purchased lumber and had an expectation.

But today anyone who knows anything about lumber knows the conventions for construction. If they're starting construction without learning the conventions, that's their fault. They are, as @Eric. says, are morons.

**

Then again, is there actually 1/2" of lost material in prepping the 2x4 that makes it 1.75 x 3.5?

**

At least with woodworking lumber we get it in quarters and reasonable calculations of b/f.

My opinion is that the labeling is stupid, and It should be fixed. Even if we all figured out the difference, there's no reason (beyond tradition) to call them 2x4's. I'd rather it be done without a lawsuit, but if charges get handed down I won't be crying for HD, Lowes, ProBuild, or the American softwoods industry. Europe sells the exact same product by it's actual dimensions (38mm x 89mm x 2400mm).

I like to think about it like this. How would you react if the supermarket advertised OJ by the volume of the oranges that were juiced to make it? No one would put up with that, yet we're all putting up with HD advertising "2 in. x 4 in. x 96 in. Premium Kiln-Dried Whitewood Stud" where only one of those inch measurements is accurate.

Now, if someone can pass a law banning the word "premium" from all advertising, I could really get behind that.

If you know so little about construction that you don't know a 2x4 isn't actually a 2x4, then you probably shouldn't be operating a saw.  Guess what? 16 penny nails aren't actually made from 16 pennies.

It would be like suing the local frozen custard place for not filling your large custard absolutely to the brim of the cup.  Get over it.

4 minutes ago, Eric. said:

If you know so little about construction that you don't know a 2x4 isn't actually a 2x4, then you probably shouldn't be operating a saw.  Guess what? 16 penny nails aren't actually made from 16 pennies.

It would be like suing the local frozen custard place for not filling your large custard absolutely to the brim of the cup.  Get over it.

Or McDonald's because their coffee is hot LOL...oh wait they actually lost...it's a crazy world we live in some days. Every time I see a stupid warning label my first thought is somebody did what :) 

 

And 4/4 S2S lumber is no longer 4/4.  It is what it is.  

This is a troll lawsuit.  The law firm recruited these people to go shopping and file a suit.  

I am probably in the minority when I say that class action attorneys and litigators are a net positive for consumers and health care patients.  But there are always examples of folks working the system, and this is exhibit A.  

1 hour ago, Mike. said:

This is a troll lawsuit.  The law firm recruited these people to go shopping and file a suit.  

I am probably in the minority when I say that class action attorneys and litigators are a net positive for consumers and health care patients.  But there are always examples of folks working the system, and this is exhibit A.  

To the first point, absolutely.
To the second, I see it as a bit of a mix. Those late-night tv class action trolls will sue for indigestion from spicy food.

2 hours ago, BonPacific said:

My opinion is that the labeling is stupid, and It should be fixed. Even if we all figured out the difference, there's no reason (beyond tradition) to call them 2x4's. I'd rather it be done without a lawsuit, but if charges get handed down I won't be crying for HD, Lowes, ProBuild, or the American softwoods industry. Europe sells the exact same product by it's actual dimensions (38mm x 89mm x 2400mm).

 

Home Depot actually includes the correct dimensions in their product detail. It's just in little tiny print under the name. 

1 minute ago, thatCharlieDude said:

Home Depot actually includes the correct dimensions in their product detail. It's just in little tiny print under the name. 

Yep, they hide it in the specifications online, and in small-print in the store. Really they don't need either. It's not like constructions companies or contractors are going to rebel if they label it 1.5 x 3.5, or just call it a whitewood stud and be done with the false dimensions in the name.

I have noticed that rough 4/4 hardwood is now 15/16 rough at my supplier.  I think I remember that it used to be a full was 1". When did this happen?

 

  • Popular Post

The last mill I knew about that sold finished lumber to full dimensions went out of business in the late '80s.   They were also the last mill that sold Yellow Pine lumber, around here, that was very stable.  They did it the old fashioned way of air drying it on sticks for a year, then slowly kiln drying it by heat generated from burning sawdust.  After it was kiln dried, they ran it through straight line saws, and planed it.  A Yellow Pine 2x4 was not only a full 2x4, but it was straight to start with, and would stay straight.

They changed to 1-1/2 x 3-1/2 in the mid to late '70s, because of complaints with the full sized studs not working out exactly right with rolls of insulation.

Another similar thing is that so many people call 240 volt electricity 220, because it used to be 220 before the industry as a whole changed to a unified voltage in teh 1930's.   I expect all of the people who actually worked with electricity when it was 220 volts, have gone on now.

That McDonalds coffee lawsuit gets quoted all the time, but almost no one noticed that the multi-million dollar judgment was lowered by a judge to some more reasonable amount that didn't have 7 figures.

I'm pretty sure Lowes settled theirs because it was the cheapest way out.  I can't believe that this is a lawsuit that the sellers couldn't win, but it would still cost a LOT to try it.  I also expect the lawyers bringing this suit are hoping for the same thing.

In the most recent (I believe 393?) WT show, Shannon et al dive into the lawsuit pretty well, and discuss both sides of it, how it's tradition and people should know, but because it's tradition, newer people may not know.  Worth the listen to, good episode too. 

I thought Shannon raised a good point that saying "everyone knows" is not accurate, because not everyone knows.

Like you think it's 1/2 less than the actual size... but a 1x8 and wider are 3/4" less in width...

And if I buy a Pressure Treated 2x4 it's actually more like 3.75" wide rather than 3.5"... And for some reason PT boards are not consistently 96", sometimes they come at 97".

 

The real lesson is you can't trust any measurements at the lumber yard.

If carried to trial, plaintiff will have to prove that they were harmed by this.  I have a hard time figuring out how some millions of dollars of harm could have been done.

In other types of Complaints, such as Negligence, there is a term used a lot- "knew or should have known".

41 minutes ago, Tom King said:

If carried to trial, plaintiff will have to prove that they were harmed by this.  I have a hard time figuring out how some millions of dollars of harm could have been done.

In other types of Complaints, such as Negligence, there is a term used a lot- "knew or should have known".

It's a class action suit, so a few hundred morons would get a check for a couple thousand bucks or less.  The outlay from the box stores would be peanuts to them even if it was in the millions, and the morons will be happy because they're morons...but the big winners will of course be the lawyers, because they'll take 30% of the total payout right off the top.  As usual, the lawyers always win.

Guaranteed the suit was started by a law firm, not by a disgruntled consumer.  Some ambulance chaser has a light bulb moment and they send out mass mailers:

"Have YOU been screwed by the box stores when you bought 2x4s and they weren't actually 2x4s?  Join thousands of others whose lives have been ruined by shrunken lumber by calling 1-800-JACKASS, and help us make lots of money off your minor inconvenience!"

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.