drzaius Posted February 3, 2020 Report Posted February 3, 2020 I have not done a project, beyond the simplest, that I haven't screwed something up. It's nice that you thoroughly discuss the missteps and the solutions to them. Not only is it a great learning experience for the rest of us, but it's also good to know that others mess up sometimes.
Chestnut Posted February 3, 2020 Report Posted February 3, 2020 Derek, i tried browsing your website and i couldn't help but to notice all of the links on the home page are broken and all result in 404 errors.
derekcohen Posted February 4, 2020 Author Report Posted February 4, 2020 Thanks for the heads up. The link should be sorted now. Cheers Derek 1
Chip Sawdust Posted February 5, 2020 Report Posted February 5, 2020 @derekcohen you may want to update your tool links too. I clicked on Blue Spruce chisels and page not found, although it did get me to their site. No biggie....
derekcohen Posted February 5, 2020 Author Report Posted February 5, 2020 CS, which page (on my website) has this link? Thanks Derek
Bmac Posted February 6, 2020 Report Posted February 6, 2020 I just caught back up to this. I misunderstood what you were going to do with the end spacers that are glued cross grain to the case. I thought you were going to make vertical cuts into the spacer to relieve the potential restriction of movement of the case. If you make a few vertical cuts into and through the spacer these cuts will not be visible and they will allow the case to move more freely. No longer would you need to hope the spacers "stretch" if the side of the case expands. I think this is an easy thing to do that would add some piece of mind.
Chip Sawdust Posted February 6, 2020 Report Posted February 6, 2020 14 hours ago, derekcohen said: CS, which page (on my website) has this link? Thanks Derek http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Links/ToolLinks.html
derekcohen Posted February 6, 2020 Author Report Posted February 6, 2020 4 hours ago, Bmac said: I just caught back up to this. I misunderstood what you were going to do with the end spacers that are glued cross grain to the case. I thought you were going to make vertical cuts into the spacer to relieve the potential restriction of movement of the case. If you make a few vertical cuts into and through the spacer these cuts will not be visible and they will allow the case to move more freely. No longer would you need to hope the spacers "stretch" if the side of the case expands. I think this is an easy thing to do that would add some piece of mind. It is not possible to make vertical cuts into the space. The sections came out so cleanly that it is likely that I will remove the side spacers and replace them. Regards from Perth Derek 34 minutes ago, Chip Sawdust said: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Links/ToolLinks.html That is an old page which is no longer on my website. How did you access it? Regards from Perth Derek
Chip Sawdust Posted February 7, 2020 Report Posted February 7, 2020 10 hours ago, derekcohen said: That is an old page which is no longer on my website. How did you access it? Regards from Perth Derek I clicked on your link and wandered through your stuff and found it. I think it's from a page called "Links". I've perused your site many times in the past; this is no big deal just thought since someone mentioned your links were 404 that you may want to fix - or delete - that one (it's your site after all ).
derekcohen Posted February 7, 2020 Author Report Posted February 7, 2020 I thank you for this - I was just curious how you found that page since I thought that I had not provided a link to it in an index. It is very out-of-date. Kind regards Derek 1
Popular Post derekcohen Posted February 16, 2020 Author Popular Post Report Posted February 16, 2020 As a reminder, we are building a version of this table ... The plan is to attach the legs, which were made near the start of this project. The attachment method is by inserting the legs into compound angle mortices in a base, which will be fixed to the carcase with a tapered sliding and stopped dovetail. We don't mess about here! It will be necessary to do this over two articles, the first being the base for the legs, which will be dovetailed (tails). The second will be the socket (pins) for the base. Before we begin, I want to mention what I did at the end of the last session. I had replaced the central drawer dividers as the grain ran in the wrong direction. The spacers at the ends also did so, and my response was to cut out half the spacer ... Well, I fretted over the end spacers, and just could not leave them this way. Encouraged by the way the halves had come out cleanly, I removed the remainder and replaced the spacers with correctly grained versions ... OK, onto the leg base ... I spent a while playing with angles for the legs, and finally accepted this (mocked up base) ... I have drilled angled mortices with a brace on a number of occasions. This time I decided to used a drill press and some Japanese Star-M augers, which are specially designed for this type of work (no lead screws). I built a 10 degree ramp for the resultant angle. The auger is 30mm ... [ The tenon is straight, but the mortice will receive a slight reaming, and the tenon will be glued and wedged. This is probably overkill since the weight of the case rests on the legs. These are the bases for the legs. The final prototype is at the rear ... Drilling the bases ... The design requires that the legs do not go over the boundary of the case (to avoid tripping over them) ... This is how they should be ... There was a small dilemma: The base at one side measures 3" from the end ... ... and the other side measures 1/4" further ... I could not work out how this occurred. The angles are the same. In fact, I made another set of bases, and the same error showed up again - exactly the same! So what to do? Actually, the decision was obvious after a little think - make the bases the same. What is more likely to be noticed is if the bases are different distances from the sides. No one will notice a 1/4" difference where the legs hit the ground. So be it. This is one of the bases for dovetailing ... First step is to remove a 2mm taper from one side. The taper will be on the inside of the base, with the outside parallel to the side of the case. Taper line drawn ... Easiest way to do this is with a #604 smoother .. This is the one end of the base ... .. and this is the other end ... mmmm .... 0.39 mm oversize. What to do ...? I'm kidding The dovetails will be 7mm deep. A shoulder was planed with a rebate plane ... The squareness of this rebate is important, so check ... The dovetail is now to be created, and the preparatory step is to colour the outer edge of the rebate with a sharpie. This will warn that the planing does not lower the external edge of the rebate. The dovetail is created with a modified Stanley #79 edge plane ... The fence has a 1:6 ratio wedge ... Details of this dovetail plane here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/SlidingDovetailsWithTheStanley79.html The result of planing. That is a 1:6 dovetail marker ... So what are the numbers for the taper? This will give an indication of the accuracy of the joint. One end is 44.12mm ... ... and the other is 46.46mm, which is a difference of 2.34mm. This will work - the pin socket is measured from this (in the same way as dovetails for a drawer. The reason for the 7mm depth? The case is 20mm thick. the dovetail should be about 1/3 of this thickness. I decided to take it to the depth of the rebate for the rear panel ... So, here is one of the completed bases ... And this is where it will be fitted ... Regards from Perth Derek 7
Chip Sawdust Posted February 16, 2020 Report Posted February 16, 2020 I’ve made splayed angle-legged plant stands for my wife but they generally scare me. My drill press is a small bench top version with no stops so that an added challenge to my already overtaxed brain. Those are interesting bits; I’d’ve grabbed a Forstner and not given it a second thought. Now I have to look those up! I love the dovetailed leg bases, they’ll be ultra sturdy at the end. I’d use my router table and careful setup as I don’t have a handy little dovetail plane. Looking forward to more progress Derek 1
Bmac Posted February 17, 2020 Report Posted February 17, 2020 Wonderful post and that little dovetail plane is quite interesting. I agree completely with your reasoning of putting the base of the legs in the same place on the underside of the case. Really curious why the location of the leg bases were off, and the fact it was exactly the same the second try makes me even more curious.
Chestnut Posted February 17, 2020 Report Posted February 17, 2020 That 1/4" is curious. The only way that someone would notice the 1/4" difference is if the piece sits on plank flooring. I've found a couple pieces of furniture that were not square at all when i had them set on hardwood floors and each leg was sitting on a different row of hardwood. Even still 1/4" is goign to be hard to spot then. 1
Popular Post derekcohen Posted February 17, 2020 Author Popular Post Report Posted February 17, 2020 Following hot on the heels of the last post, where we created the male or tail section of the tapered sliding dovetail, now comes the female or pin socket to house the base for the legs. These are the bases. This post will focus on the socket for the one closest the camera. The base is positioned exactly 3 1/4" from the side. The tapered side is on the inside, with the outside face square to the front and rear of the case ... This process is essentially the same as transferring marks from the tail- to the pin board with drawers. The base tapers towards the toe, that is, the sliding dovetail will tighten up as the base is pushed into the socket. The first step is to register the far end of the base in such a way that the position is repeatable. This is done by placing a long board along the "square" side. The position for the end of the board is marked ... Now the base can be stood up to mark inside the tail with a scratch awl. You can make out the mark aligning the baseline of the tail ... Look carefully for the dots. This is repeated at the other end. The dots are now joined up ... The plan is to saw the socket sides, as if sawing dovetails in a drawer. The angle ratio is 1:6, as it was with the base. Since the socket is blind or stopped, the saw needs to have space in which to begin the cut. An area at the toe is excavated with a router. The depth of the cut is set using a 7.0mm drill bit. I am aware that the actual depth is 7.5mm, but this will be a second pass. I intend to clear the waste with the router - this Jarrah is bloody hard, and I am not a masochist! Using an angled saw guide, the end is chopped to the line .. Now this is space to register the azebiki saw ... I have roughly marked a depth to aim for ... Both sides have been sawn ... The waste is removed with the router, leaving a few mm close to the sides ... This is chopped away with a chisel in two passes, and then cleaned up with a hand router ... The side rebate #79/dovetail plane is used to clean any rough sections .. The power router drops a 0.5mm to 7.5mm and this is cleaned up ... Amazingly, the base slides in and tightens up about 1/4" from the end. It will need a tap to be fully secure. That's it for now. Regards from Perth Derek 8
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted February 17, 2020 Popular Post Report Posted February 17, 2020 Derek, I've made tapered sliding dovetails before, but mine were through-cut. Fitting stopped sockets so that the tail tightens just as you approach the stopped end seems like sorcery! 3
Coop Posted February 19, 2020 Report Posted February 19, 2020 Derek, first off, you continue to amaze. Secondly, what is an angled saw guide and what are the round inserts shown in the pic? It just struck me, it’s being used for it’s intended purpose? Is this something that you ripped at that angle or a purchased product. And the inserts? 2
Popular Post derekcohen Posted February 19, 2020 Author Popular Post Report Posted February 19, 2020 Hi Coop That is a straight edge/guide I made for sawing sliding dovetails. It is made from Jarrah, with one square and one angled (1:6) side ... The underside has non-slip made from 240 grit sandpaper ... These photos were taken before I inserted a series of rare earth magnets along each side, which will pull a saw blade against the side. In addition to chopping at 1:6 (9.5 degrees) .. ... sawing sliding dovetails or dados ... ... it can be used on the square side to plane through dados with a HNT Gordon dado plane ... ... or at an angle to plane the female socket of a sliding dovetail (with a plane I made for this task) ... The two planes here ... It's a useful item. Regards from Perth Derek 5
Mark J Posted February 19, 2020 Report Posted February 19, 2020 On 2/16/2020 at 10:57 AM, derekcohen said: I could not work out how this occurred. So back to that niggling 1/4", it didn't seem so farfetched to me. It would only take a tiny difference in the mounting angle of the legs to the carcass to create that much difference in the position of the feet. So dusting off some old (very old) geometry with the Google brush, I was reminded of this (OK, I probably never actually knew this): http://mathcentral.uregina.ca/QQ/database/QQ.09.07/h/lucy1.html So given that you have the three lengths of a triangle you can calculate any of the three angles. If I've done the calculation correctly and assuming the legs are 100cm long it would only take an angle of .363 degrees to move the tip of the leg .635 cm (1/4"). This may not be the exact dimension, but it makes the point that the error here is easily within the surface variation of the "flat" bottom of the carcass. The good news, I don't think anyone visiting your niece is just going to happen to have a plumb bob in there pocket. 1
Popular Post derekcohen Posted February 19, 2020 Author Popular Post Report Posted February 19, 2020 Quote The good news, I don't think anyone visiting your niece is just going to happen to have a plumb bob in there pocket. Mark, you recall that this table will be a wedding present? Well, the groom’s father is a woodworker as keen as you and I, and very knowledgeable . No doubt he and I will at some stage be discussing the build in some detail. Regards from Perth Derek 1 1 2
Coop Posted February 20, 2020 Report Posted February 20, 2020 Thanks Derek. I was wondering if they were magnets but figured they would bind the saw if so. I guess they are recessed enough so as to just to keep the saw aligned. Great idea.
Chip Sawdust Posted February 21, 2020 Report Posted February 21, 2020 Very creative Derek. Beyond my capacity to figure out. I’ve never seen Jarrah so of course have never used it, but it sounds awesome. Probably the closest I’ve come to it is wenge? Although it appears to be much more open-grained.
Popular Post derekcohen Posted February 22, 2020 Author Popular Post Report Posted February 22, 2020 The legs are on. I must admit to mixed feelings at this stage. This is not my style of leg, but it is what my niece wants. Perhaps I will feel differently with a finish on the wood. The tenons were kerfed for a wedge ... Installed in the bases ... And glued into the socket. Note that only the first third is glued. The rear is free to move ... The bases have been shaped to reduce their impact ... The legs were evened up .. Side view from underneath (one does not see the base otherwise) ... Regards from Perth Derek 6
Popular Post derekcohen Posted February 23, 2020 Author Popular Post Report Posted February 23, 2020 It's time for the drawers. Once again there is a challenge. The design calls for drawer fronts that stretch across the front without being broken by drawer dividers. In other words, "lipped drawers". There are two ways to do this. The easy way is to used "planted fronts", that is, attached fronts to the front of a box ... The hard way is to make the drawer front a single piece. This requires rebating the drawer front and forming a half blind dovetail in the side of the rebate. Courtesy of Christian Becksvoort ... I've chosen the high road (sigh). Today I spent my time preparing for three drawers. Why three and not two, as in the original design? Simply because I can build them narrower, and this will make them less likely to rack. They'll end up somewhere around 280mm wide and 290mm deep. I anticipated that 375mm wide and 290mm deep would be a disaster waiting to happen. The only way drawers that dimension could work is on runners, which I do not do. The wood for the drawer front is more Fiddleback Jarrah (by request), while the remainder of the drawer is quarter sawn Tasmanian Oak (which is actually a Eucalyptus, and is quite unstable unless quarter sawn. I keep a stock for drawers). It is a lot like US White Oak in appearance and hardness. I have a bunch of narrower boards, which I re-sawed to make 7mm thick drawer sides, and glued together two to get the height needed ... No clamps, just blue painter's tape, which is stretched across. It pulls the edges together. This is enough for 4 drawer sides (one spare) ... The drawer bottoms will be 1/4" (6.35mm) thick ..... I cannot go metric here as my plough blade is imperial .... this is re-sawn from a wide board, which saves some effort as only two boards are needed for the bottoms (the grain runs across the drawer) ... Same trick with the blue tape, and cauls are also added to keep it flat. This will be sawn up at the time it is needed, and the panel will remain in the cauls until thn. The narrow drawer sides necessitate using drawer slips, which is a strip added to the sides with a groove for the drawer bottom. This also adds extra width as a runner. The slips are made with a plough plane. In this case, I used both a Veritas Small Plow (to plough the groove) and the Veritas Combination Plow (to plough a bead - the bead lies at the join of the slip and drawer bottom). Setting up both save time switching set ups back and forth, and once begun, making these slips was a quick process ... First plough the bead ... A tip on how to avoid over-planing the bead. This comes from David Charlesworth. Scribble pencil along the top of the bead, and when it is gone, the bead is complete ... Now flip the board around to plane the groove ... The first line is where the groove begins, which is 3mm below the bead. There will follow a 1/4" groove, and there will be 4mm below this to support the groove/drawer bottom. This makes the slip a smidgeon over 12mm high. It is 10mm deep, which allows for a 5mm deep groove. As mentioned, once set up, no further marking is necessary. Just plane ... ... and then rip off the slip on the table saw. This is a mock up: the bead at the top and the groove on the side ... I have a strategy to fit the drawer fronts, so that the edges align with each other. It is all about accurate marking out. This will hinge on getting the opening exact, and transferring the respective measurements to their drawer fronts. First order of the day was to fit (what will become) drawer backs to the front between the drawer dividers. This is what the result looked like ... The table saw can cross cut really close, but only a shooting board will get the final dimension ... On to the all-important drawer fronts! I was heartened that all the verticals were indeed vertical still ... well, except for one (if you look carefully, you will see light in the top half) ... This meant a slight adjustment of that side .. again a job for the shooting board. Set one, mark the angle with a small sliding bevel ... ... transfer this to the side of the board, and head for the shooting board. As the side is no longer square, a shim is used to create the needed angle ... A good result ... This is the join I need to manage ... These are the fronts fitted in sequence ... And here were are now, waiting for the next build day ... Regards from Perth Derek 6
Recommended Posts