Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm experimenting. I have a 12" SCMS with 4' of workspace on one side and 5' on the other side. You can see it on the right side in the picture. I only use it for quick breakdowns or cutting several pieces to length using stops for consistency. It's convenient but I could do a lot with that space.  

How many of you had and quit using an SCMS in your shop or think you could be just fine without yours?  What method do you use for accurate cross cutting?

image.jpeg

Posted

I went a very long time without one (my rigid crapped out and i was waiting and saving for the 12" Bosch) and used my table saw with miter sled, circ saw, or hand saw. But that being said I would not ever go back! A must have in my shop.

Posted

Not a fan of initials.

My sliding compound miter saw is a stayer. It is way too convenient and an essential if I am on site. 

That said, you do have the option of putting yours on a dewalt base and use it when needed inside or out. That can free up some space for you.DeWalt-miter-saw-stands-dwx.jpg

Posted

I do not have a sliding miter saw but I do have a Ridgid 12 in chop saw mounted on there portable base that I keep in the corner of my shop and only pull it out when I want to cut some lumber up into more manageable lengths. Then I fold it up and store it till I need to use if again... I could just use my table saw but I have the chop saw and use that ......

a-25-C-Ridgid.jpg

ee4b48cf-955d-4570-bf5e-6113585bfe6f_300.jpg

Posted

I have been contemplating this for a long time as well. I have a cheapie HF model, was planning to get the Bosch. But I am not sure I can justify it. I have a table saw and sled for precise, repeatable crosscuts. I have a pretty good jigsaw for breaking lumber down. The only way I can think of to use a SCMS is to block what will end up being my built in cabinets, and just make my life harder. Only other way is to put it on top of the workbench only when I need it. That may end up being my final solution but that moves it significantly down on my "must have" list. And I'm not sure the Bosch would fit on my lower workbench shelf for storage when I'm not using it.

1 minute ago, Gary-ks said:

I do not have a sliding miter saw but I do have a Ridgid 12 in chop saw mounted on there portable base that I keep in the corner of my shop and only pull it out when I want to cut some lumber up into more manageable lengths. Then I fold it up and store it till I need to use if again... I could just use my table saw but I have the chop saw and use that ......

a-25-C-Ridgid.jpg

ee4b48cf-955d-4570-bf5e-6113585bfe6f_300.jpg

Does that base fit other SCMS?

Posted
8 hours ago, TIODS said:

I wouldn't give mine up for all the tea in china!  

I agree and wouldn't be without one.  I planned one wall of my shop around the saw. 

 

16 minutes ago, Cliff said:

I have been contemplating this for a long time as well. I have a cheapie HF model, was planning to get the Bosch. But I am not sure I can justify it. I have a table saw and sled for precise, repeatable crosscuts. I have a pretty good jigsaw for breaking lumber down. The only way I can think of to use a SCMS is to block what will end up being my built in cabinets, and just make my life harder. Only other way is to put it on top of the workbench only when I need it. That may end up being my final solution but that moves it significantly down on my "must have" list. And I'm not sure the Bosch would fit on my lower workbench shelf for storage when I'm not using it.

Does that base fit other SCMS?

Cliff most mobile bases adapt to other saws.

  • Like 1
Posted

The question in your thread title is "do I need one."  That's easy...NO.

Now change your question to "do I want one" and it's much more difficult to answer.  Well, actually it's not...the answer is most likely YES.

My SCMS isn't going anywhere...but it's more of a convenience than a necessity.  The same can be said about almost any other tool in your shop...they almost all have alternatives...that doesn't mean you'll enjoy their absence.

  • Like 1
Posted
40 minutes ago, Cliff said:

I have been contemplating this for a long time as well. I have a cheapie HF model, was planning to get the Bosch. But I am not sure I can justify it. I have a table saw and sled for precise, repeatable crosscuts. I have a pretty good jigsaw for breaking lumber down. The only way I can think of to use a SCMS is to block what will end up being my built in cabinets, and just make my life harder. Only other way is to put it on top of the workbench only when I need it. That may end up being my final solution but that moves it significantly down on my "must have" list. And I'm not sure the Bosch would fit on my lower workbench shelf for storage when I'm not using it.

Does that base fit other SCMS?

When I first got into this stuff < 2 years ago I was frustrated that my Craftsman SCMS was not as precise as I thought it should be. (Why is it called a "miter saw" given its inaccuracy when it is nothing more than simply a more-precise "chop saw.")  But people here helped me through that period of disenchantment.  Now I'm thinking through things differently.  So I parted with the Craftsman and picked up DeWalt, expecting more.  I was disappointed. Disappointed, that is, until I found something on it that I had missed, which the Craftsman did not have.

There is a feature on *some* SCMS that should be considered.  On the DeWalt and Festool the angle register can be moved for adjustment by loosening some screws.  This allows you to adjust for a perfect 45 & 90 degree cuts.  Many don't have this feature. (I didn't see it on the Bosch or Hitachi.)  As a result the saw cannot be adjusted for the same precision as a table saw.  But where to get that perfect 90 degree setting?

I'm looking at getting one of these for adjusting both table saw and SCMS.

http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00006RGLC/ref=wl_it_dp_o_pC_nS_ttl?_encoding=UTF8&colid=N7LXKL1PFI9M&coliid=I1EYYJ0INCY3NE

With this item the SCMS and table saw adjustments will be simplified significantly.  The first try will be to place a square against the back fence and against this plate.  It's going to be pretty darn close to true.  Then a 5-cut should resolve the rest.  (Yes, I think a 5-cut approach could be done in this instance, though I might reduce the cut count [and change the math] just for simplicity's sake.)

All this because many times the SCMS is just more convenient that the table saw and sled. No sense in letting a good tool not get used to its best advantage.

Posted

I don't have a SCMS and have been close to buying one a few times but have yet to pull the trigger. I have always used crosscut sleds on the table saw with great results. Now with the Roubo build there was a couple of times that a SCMS would have been nice. Right now if I were to buy it would be the Bosch 10" glide.

@Eric. now that you have a MFT how would you compare that to a SCMS? Obviously for complicated angles the SCMS will be better but what about for day to day woodworking? If you had to choose one which one would it be?

Posted
16 minutes ago, estesbubba said:

 

@Eric. now that you have a MFT how would you compare that to a SCMS? Obviously for complicated angles the SCMS will be better but what about for day to day woodworking? If you had to choose one which one would it be?

 

Honestly Mike I'll be using each tool for very different things.  I have the SCMS for long boards because I don't have the space in my shop to make those cuts on my table saw.  It's also very quick to set up stop blocks and make fully supported, repeatable cuts.

Although the MFT can do much more, I bought it for two main purposes: crosscutting large panels and making dadoes in case sides.

So while there's a lot of crossover between the two, my main uses for each tool set them apart from each other.

If I had to have only one or the other, I would pick the SCMS because you can do most panels on the table saw with a sled, and panels that are too large for the sled you can do with just the tracksaw and track.  Not quite as accurate or as fast, but good enough.

I consider both the SCMS and MFT to be convenience tools, luxuries.

Posted
20 minutes ago, Eric. said:

The question in your thread title is "do I need one."  That's easy...NO.

Now change your question to "do I want one" and it's much more difficult to answer.  Well, actually it's not...the answer is most likely YES.

My SCMS isn't going anywhere...but it's more of a convenience than a necessity.  The same can be said about almost any other tool in your shop...they almost all have alternatives...that doesn't mean you'll enjoy their absence.

"I really like depriving myself of things. It's fun!"

  • Like 2
Posted
21 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Honestly Mike I'll be using each tool for very different things.  I have the SCMS for long boards because I don't have the space in my shop to make those cuts on my table saw.  It's also very quick to set up stop blocks and make fully supported, repeatable cuts.

Same.

I also do a lot of flip and cut with my SCMS, for wide boards, since using my table saw is complicated (I don't have it at home).

Posted

I'll always have one. I prefer the xcut sled and miter sled for pieces under 4', but the chop saw is still my best option for long pieces or odd angles. I took the time to adjust the fence, bevel and all the stops so its fairly accurate.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk

Posted

I have always had Compound mitre saws in the construction industry so it made sense to bring the idea into my shop when I built it. As others have said, size does matter! My shop is a bit bigger than the average garage and still I need to cut lengths up to 20 feet. 

post-5160-0-94204900-1336153111_thumb.jppost-5160-0-40415800-1368847172_thumb.jp

I like the setup so much I purchased the Festool Kapex and haven't looked back. 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

i have a kapex as well, and use it on every project.. i do not break down rough lumber on it, i use a cordless circ saw or a hand saw to do so.. i am afraid i will warp or bend the blade by hacking rough lumber apart with it.

i have a very small shop (240sq feet or so) and i have it positioned for good space use.  its a keeper for sure.

  • Like 1
Posted
20 minutes ago, Janello said:

Food for thought. DeWalt is coming out with a Cordless 7 1/4 SCMS. Smaller foot print and can throw it up on a shelf.

That is pretty amazing. Looks like about $400ish. I can put it on the shelf on my bench where my HF one is. 

Posted

I lack a lot of tools in my shop so far, no jointer or planer, so I like breaking boards down to  rough dimension before flattening/ resawing on the table saw, etc.  I use my Dewalt 12" compound miter saw a lot for this, it's also been a necessity for rough framing walls and doing finish trim work in the house.  I don't see it ever leaving my small shop.  I generally move it to the benchtop or a pair of sawhorses for now.  Someday when my little shop is more organized it may get relocated to a more permanent position along a wall with tables alongside it. 

Posted
On 1/8/2016 at 9:08 AM, TIODS said:

I wouldn't give mine up for all the tea in china!  

I couldn't resist...

China produces about 35% of the world's tea, equating to 35% x 4,000,000,000 kg = 1,400,000,000 kg per year. Assuming it stays in country for about 5 months (growing leaves, processing, packaging), there is around 583,333,333 kg of tea in China at any given moment. At around $3/kg on the international markets, that means that all the tea in China is worth around $1.75 billion. A smidgen more than your Powerball jackpot, but enough for me to say, "I can do without my SCMS"!

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 67 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined