EEstudent Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 Greetings All, This forum is a nice collection of information for the various wood working topics, I've learned a fair amount just reading through the forum and the site. I am looking for some suggestions with a current set of tool purchases. I am fortunate to expand my woodworking hobby and have decided to start building projects with non-dimensioned lumber. I happen to have a nice hardwood dealer close to me. I found a 6 inch jet jointer via craigslist over the past 6 months but have not had any luck finding a decent planer. I do not live within 3 hours of a major city and so finding another deal on craigslist is starting to seem unlikely. And I am starting to get impatient and would like to get working on some projects with hardwood that I have planned out. I currently have a 2.5k budget for new tool purchases. Currently my biggest need is for a planer and I would also like to get a bandsaw as well. I've done some rough calculations and looks like I will anticipate running about 1000 bft through this planer I purchase in the next year or so. I am currently considering two options of tool purchases. 1. dewalt 735 + byrd shelix head, with grizzly 17 inch bandsaw (approx 2.2k) 2. grizzly 15 inch hylical head (approx 1.8k) I think I've read most of what is available on the internet about lunchbox planers vs stationary planers and I probably fall into the lunchbox planer category since I don't plan on spending hours upon hours planing wood on a consistent basis. But at the same time I like to buy things that will last a long time and are just a little more than what I probably actually need. As such having a nice big cast iron planer would be nice. I am not short on space so that isn't a factor for me. Then if going this route save for bandsaw in the future. But on the other hand it would be nice to get both a planer and bandsaw with my current budget and then save up for other tools in the future. Getting a helical head seems like a very nice upgrade for the planer. I plan on building several large table tops and a traditional work bench in the next year or two and so having a smoother finish on the planer seems very appealing. My experience has all been with dimensioned lumber and mostly framing so I do wonder if I am assuming a need more than I really need to start building things out of nicer hardwoods. So I turn to the internet of wisdom. I hope in the future I can contribute back to a community that has collected so much knowledge. I'd appreciate if you had this situation what would your choice be? Thanks Quote
Isaac Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 Go for Option 1. A 15" wide planer is pretty massive and kind of odd to pair with a 6" used craigslist jointer. Not sure you need the 17" bandsaw either. Might be just fine with a 14" model. How are you doing on the rest of your set up, table saw, dust collection, hand tools, etc? Do you have these, and what brand/size/quality? Quote
..Kev Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 Agreed.. The 735 with either the Laguna or Grizzly 14" would be well within your budget and serve you very well. Quote
wdwerker Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 I've gotten along with a 12" planer and a 6" jointer for 30 years in my small pro shop. Don't have much info on current machines in those categories. 14" bandsaw w a riser kit lets me resaw to 12" but it's a far heavier built 14" bandsaw than anything available today. Several of the guys here have gotten Laguna bandsaws and are happy with them. And several have griped about the quality & customer service from Grizzly. Not specifically about bandsaws but still...... Quote
EEstudent Posted December 18, 2017 Author Report Posted December 18, 2017 I have a jet cabinet tablesaw with the extension I got off craigslist with the jointer. I found an older 3hp delta dust collector with two bags that I plan on reducing down into one filter + cyclone setup. Currently working on modifying that setup. I have standard drills, circular saw, jig saw, belt and orbital sander. No hand planes yet. So in regards to the bandsaw, I see many people either seem to recommend getting a 14 inch band saw or 20 inch or bigger. But not too many recommendations for sizes in between. Is there a reason for this? I thought bandsaw was considered to be a tool where there isn't a downside to going bigger besides space and money? The hardwood dealer by me has good pricing on 8/4 stock so I was thinking i'd buy that primarily and then mill it down to more correct sizes with bandsaw and planer. Quote
..Kev Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 I have a 14" and a 17" (both Grizzly) and the 14 sees much more every day use than the 17. I primarily only use the 17 for resewing. Having used both the Laguna (Thanks Chet!) and the Grizzly (mine) 14" saws, I can say that the blade changes are quicker on the Laguna. In hindsight, if I had my bandsaw decisions to do over, I would probably get the Laguna 14" and only have the 1 bandsaw. With that said, I have had awesome luck with both my Grizzly saws! Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted December 18, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted December 18, 2017 I think your option 1 is good, except perhaps I would skip the shelix head for the 735, and put the money toward a nicer bandsaw instead. The straight knives on tge 735 make cuts that are plenty smooth. Perhaps upgrade to HSS knives from Infinity Tools, they are reported to last much longer. Having said that, let me point out one big disadvantage the 735 has when compared to any floor model planer... It is LOUD! Not just "kinda noisy" loud, more like "get arrested for disturbing the peace" loud. If you live in a residential area, don't plan on running that thing after 9:00 pm. The shelix head might improve that a little, but its loud even when not cutting. 4 Quote
Isaac Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 17 minutes ago, EEstudent said: I have a jet cabinet tablesaw with the extension I got off craigslist with the jointer. I found an older 3hp delta dust collector with two bags that I plan on reducing down into one filter + cyclone setup. Currently working on modifying that setup. I have standard drills, circular saw, jig saw, belt and orbital sander. No hand planes yet. So in regards to the bandsaw, I see many people either seem to recommend getting a 14 inch band saw or 20 inch or bigger. But not too many recommendations for sizes in between. Is there a reason for this? I thought bandsaw was considered to be a tool where there isn't a downside to going bigger besides space and money? The hardwood dealer by me has good pricing on 8/4 stock so I was thinking i'd buy that primarily and then mill it down to more correct sizes with bandsaw and planer. Resawing is fine, but you may struggle getting super wide boards square on four sides with a 6" jointer. I'd plan to put some of that cash into hand planes, chisels, dovetail saws. Also think about the hardware for the bench you plan to build. The vices aren't cheap. Quote
Chet Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 Have the Dewalt 735 and I am really happy with it. I think it is a real good purchase and if you need to, to help you get other tools, buy it with regular blades and then get the Byrd when you need to replace the blades. I also have the Laguna 1412 band saw which has been great and it has a resaw capacity of 12 & 3/4 inches guides are real easy to adjust. Quote
..Kev Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 The above comments are accurate! The 735 is loud! As for the jointer, I've posted my thoughts here before and wouldn't waste my money to upgrade my 6" jointer to gain 2 inches. Quote
Jfitz Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 I have the 735, and it's a great planer. Loud, yes - and also much quieter (but still pretty loud) even with the Shelix. I think the chip ejection fan is a big part of the noise. I agree with the comments above - option (1) seems like your best bet, but I'd also question the need for the 17" saw. If you think you need it for what you want to build then OK, but there might be better options in the 14" range. On the 735, definitely get the infeed/outfeed tables but I'd suggest you leave the Shelix as an upgrade for later - use the cash to get all the 'other' items you'll need (clamps, measuring/marking tools, some planes and other basic hand tools, chisels, etc etc). The factory knives will get you going, and then if you're all set up and there's still money left in the budget you can upgrade to the Shelix. Also, you don't mention dust collection - as much fun as it is to get the necessary power tools, I hope you consider dust collection equally important. 1 Quote
gee-dub Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 Sounds like you have a good idea of what you are going to make; that's an advantage. Being able to resaw on the bandsaw is not just for rough lumber. I would rather resaw a piece of material to get my 5/8" stock and have a usable piece of spoil than joint and plane all the extra material away into chips. Resaw height used to drive bandsaw size selection but, the taller 14" saws have changed that up a bit. If your planned furniture does not involve bandsaw cuts that require a deep throat, the 14" should do you fine. I ran a DW 734 (12-1/2" width and three knives but, single speed) for years before I went to my floor standing planer. Dad has the DW735 and while it is nicer I did not ever think it was $200 nicer although the price gap has closed I believe. The 734's knives outlast the 735 by a noticeable margin between Dad and I. Putting a spiral head in either the 734 or the 735 is not exactly like putting lipstick on a pig but, it is a cost increase for a small machine that is not insignificant. The weight difference is only 10 pounds so neither are easily mobile but, mobile if that is required. The point is that you always want to buy the best you can afford but, "best" is subjective and specific to our needs. If you don't need the larger saw and don't need the dual speed planer you could push that unspent money at nicer cutters, better hardware and more material. For the sake of transparency I should say that I have a large and small bandsaw and a spiral head jointer and spiral head planer. Enjoy the journey. Quote
EEstudent Posted December 18, 2017 Author Report Posted December 18, 2017 Thanks everyone for the replies, honestly I am surprised there isn't one vote for getting the bigger planner. It looks like I am leaning towards the 735 especially based upon the price at farm and fleet posted on the other thread. Partially I am considering the shelix head in the 735 because how frequently I hear feedback about the knives not staying sharp and needing to replace them somewhat frequently. I guess at about 400 vs 40 bucks at one time adds up to about 10 knife changes. But it seems to be the right trade off in the end from my perspective. Besides hand planes I have most other basic wood working equipment, including clamps, sanders, drill, hammers ect. Currently my main equipment needs are planer and bandsaw. Also in the process of getting dust collection setup. I appreciate the focus on not forgetting all the other little things. Quote
Tom King Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 If you can get a CL larger planer cheap enough, don't turn it down. I bought a 15" for $400 off CL, and it didn't even need the knives changed. I admit that was unusual luck, but I jumped on it the same day it was posted. Quote
Unknown craftsman Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 I'm agree with the 735 is a good first planer. I read reports about the machine being a little underpowered for the Bryd head.When I had a 735 I put infinitys carbide tipped knives in it. It really made it into a finishing planer because it left a surface better then Pm with HHead. Good luck sound like your in for some fun. Aj 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 1 hour ago, EEstudent said: Thanks everyone for the replies, honestly I am surprised there isn't one vote for getting the bigger planner. It looks like I am leaning towards the 735 especially based upon the price at farm and fleet posted on the other thread. Partially I am considering the shelix head in the 735 because how frequently I hear feedback about the knives not staying sharp and needing to replace them somewhat frequently. I guess at about 400 vs 40 bucks at one time adds up to about 10 knife changes. But it seems to be the right trade off in the end from my perspective. Besides hand planes I have most other basic wood working equipment, including clamps, sanders, drill, hammers ect. Currently my main equipment needs are planer and bandsaw. Also in the process of getting dust collection setup. I appreciate the focus on not forgetting all the other little things. The knives do last longer than people give them credit for. It took me 4 years to use 4 sets of knives so i guess a set would last me about a year and that was completing a project every 3 months. If you use any sort of dirty wood it's going to wear the blades considerably faster. Another thing to consider is the Infinity blades that are popular for it here. They are able to be sharpened a few times. I'll also plant the bug of getting a 14" bandsaw but also consider getting a cheaper 14" (laguna 1412 or rikon 10-326) for detail work and if you have the space a bigger saw in the future for resaw. A lot of the new style 14" saws can handle a lot of resawing. I have a Laguna 14bx (same as the 1412 basically) and ran a 12" resaw not that long ago. In the future you could get a 16 or 18" saw and have both a resaw and a curve setup so you don't have to switch blades. Just something to consider. Quote
Popular Post minorhero Posted December 18, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted December 18, 2017 11 hours ago, EEstudent said: The hardwood dealer by me has good pricing on 8/4 stock so I was thinking i'd buy that primarily and then mill it down to more correct sizes with bandsaw and planer. Other folks have given you great advice on the machines so I am going to address this part. Be aware that when you resaw 8/4 stock you do not get two 4/4 boards. You will almost certainly get two 3/4 boards and then only if you resaw it pretty perfectly and there is no additional movement in the wood. It will almost certainly be cheaper and significantly easier to just buy 4/4 wood if 3/4 is your ultimate goal. Additionally if you want a finished size of 1" thick then if you resaw 8/4 you basically get one usable board and a whole bunch of kindling. Same with any other size that is thicker. My advice is only buy 8/4 if you actually plan to use 8/4 and buy other sizes as you need them. The reason you see most people only buying 14" bandsaws is because resawing is a nice thing to do in a pinch but it's a slow process and not the primary purpose of a bandsaw. Most folks are using a bandsaw for curves or small cuts like tenon's or dove tails where the reduced chance of kickback and vertical blade make the process easier than a table saw. For those applications a 14" bandsaw is great. What do you plan on building first? If you don't need a bandsaw right now I would hold off until the project you are doing actually requires a bandsaw. The reason being that you will know more then about what you need and also companies are constantly coming out with new models. Laguna has released a couple of new great models in the last few years and grizzly seems to be improving as well. If building something with mortise and tenon joinery you may be better served with a planer and domino for example. 2 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 Also resawing 8/4 can release tension in the wood or a expose a different moisture content. Resawn wood can cup, twist etc. It usually does something . Most of us will resaw a board to make a bookmatched panel or to try and get the most out of a limited amount of stock. Any time you cut a board into smaller pieces stickering it overnight (at a minimum) to see if it's going to move on you is a good practice. 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 Also to note for me 8/4 is more costly than buying 4/4 so it's cheaper to buy the proper thickness at least for me. Quote
drzaius Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 I have an old Delta 22-580 planer which, if it wasn't Delta & was still made, I'd recommend to anyone. The stock blades on it last a long time. The current blades (just 1 side) have gone through a lot of lumber, including milling about 150 BF of 4/4 hard maple down to 3/4" & they're still in decent shape. I wouldn't go with a helical head on a lunchbox planer cause I bet the machine would be worn out before you got your money's worth out of the head. Quote
Ronn W Posted December 18, 2017 Report Posted December 18, 2017 18 hours ago, Chet said: Have the Dewalt 735 and I am really happy with it. I think it is a real good purchase and if you need to, to help you get other tools, buy it with regular blades and then get the Byrd when you need to replace the blades. I also have the Laguna 1412 band saw which has been great and it has a resaw capacity of 12 & 3/4 inches guides are real easy to adjust. Ditto both for me. One thing about the Dewalt is that changing the blades, when necessary, is a breeze since you just drop them into place. The disadvantage is that you don't sharpen these blades, you buy new ones. Back on the birght side is that the blades are reversable so you are realy buying 2 sets. Quote
AJ_Engineer Posted December 19, 2017 Report Posted December 19, 2017 Another vote for the DW735 and a quality 14" bandsaw if you have a specific need in the near future for a bandsaw. For your budget take into account how much blades and accessories cost, they add up quick. I have the dewalt planer and it serves me just fine. Prices are good on Amazon. Quote
RichardA Posted December 19, 2017 Report Posted December 19, 2017 16 hours ago, Ronn W said: Ditto both for me. One thing about the Dewalt is that changing the blades, when necessary, is a breeze since you just drop them into place. The disadvantage is that you don't sharpen these blades, you buy new ones. Back on the birght side is that the blades are reversable so you are realy buying 2 sets. That's true for the Dewalt blades, however if you purchase HSS blades from Infinity tools, you can rehone those blade up to 5 times. {That's the number I'm working with mine] Quote
Ronn W Posted December 19, 2017 Report Posted December 19, 2017 2 hours ago, RichardA said: That's true for the Dewalt blades, however if you purchase HSS blades from Infinity tools, you can rehone those blade up to 5 times. {That's the number I'm working with mine] Great. But as you hone them doesn't that change relationship of the blade to the rollers? To sya it another way - doesn't the depth of cut change slightly? Maybe it's sucha samll amount that it does not matter. Do you have infinitiy re-hone them? Quote
RichardA Posted December 20, 2017 Report Posted December 20, 2017 8 hours ago, Ronn W said: Great. But as you hone them doesn't that change relationship of the blade to the rollers? To sya it another way - doesn't the depth of cut change slightly? Maybe it's sucha samll amount that it does not matter. Do you have infinitiy re-hone them? The change is minute, and I hone them . The depth of cut doesn't matter until, they no longer cut. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.