Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Head is Spinning.... A Newbie and I need some help!

Featured Replies

Ok, so I am new to woodworking.  I purchased a 115 year-old home and have been working to restore it.  I have previously been using an inexpensive table saw, that really doesn't cut it past very minor trim uses.  I need to build several different types of cabinets (kitchen and built-ins), not to mention I am interested in making some furniture.

I have two questions:

1). I know that I need to buy a decent table saw - but where to begin....  I have done a lot of reading on here and other sites and honestly I am more confused now than ever....  Contractor, hybrid or cabinet???  I am leaning towards a 36", as that is about all that I would have room for.  However, is 36" large enough?  How big of an out-feed table do you recommend?  What features do I absolutely need?  Any specific brands (I know SawStop will be up there, just not sure that I can afford it...)?

2). What other tools are necessary for cabinet/furniture construction?  

2A)). Before I forget - What should I be looking for with dust collection?

Budget - I am concerned about this one, but also willing to save up to get the right things first time.  However, I don't want to go crazy.  I need to be smart, as I don't do this for a living - it is a hobby/side-job.

What am I missing?

Thanks in advance!!!  My head is really spinning from all of the research I have done to date.

Where will the saw be located? If a detached garage, you can get away with dust masks and no dust collection longer than if the same saw is in your basement. 

Get the best saw you can afford. Sounds like you have a lot of panel cutting to do, so a cabinet saw would be ideal. The heavy base and large table surface make it ideal for panels. A deep outfeed table can double as a assemble space and can house drawers below. A cabinet saw is also the best option for furniture work later. Sawstop makes great tools. They are expensive, but if you can afford one, get it. I've never tripped mine, and never plan to, but it is good to know the safety feature  is there.

 You might also consider a plunging track saw. 

Don't try to do everything at once. Pick your next specific project and get the tools you need to do that specific task. 

  • Author

@Isaac Thanks!  

My shop will be in my basement.  I do have exterior access via three stairs, but whatever I get will have to come/go through that opening (about 38" wide).  

The more that I have read, the more that I am leaning towards a cabinet saw.  But then my question becomes should I even consider a hybrid or just go straight to cabinet.  Of course SS keeps coming up over and over, so I am leaning a bit in that direction.

Will definitely check into the plunging track saw.

Next project is some cabinetry and closet organizers, so basically cabinets....  

I've been using a contractor saw for 10+ years.  It's done everything I've asked it to do.  They are out of fashion these days so the choice is really between a hybrid and cabinet saw.  A cabinet saw isn't going to make you a better woodworker.  The hybrid saw will be 100x better than what you have now, cabinet saw marginally better than that.  36" is fine.  People just pile up the safety gear and whatnot on the end of their 50" tables.

What else do you need?  Clamps.  Lots of clamps.  Good clamps are expensive.  A nail gun and air compressor if you want to get things done.  The list can be as long as your project list if you want it to be.

Like KRTwood I have a contractor saw that has served me well for twenty years, would I like a cabinet saw, yup but not enough to buy one. If a lot of cabinet work is in the near term I would take a different approach. I have a Makita track saw and just bought a Festool MFT3 the tracks for both are the same. Coupled with a midi vac. and the dust deputy that is made for it is to me the best method of breaking down plywood for cabinets. I am currently building an armoire and used the mft to trim the bottom of the doors.

I'll toss in another vote for the usability of a contractor style saw. The blade spins, and the fence is true, just as with a cabinet saw. The drawback to the older design as I have, is the motor hanging out the back makes dust collection difficult, and also interferes with a normal outfeed table when tilted to 45 degrees. In your basement shop, I would lean toward a design that fully encloses the motor, to help contain dust. But many modern contractor saws are built that way. Personally, I would avoid models that use a two piece front fence rail, as that is just another place to get misaligned.

I was looking at Craigslist around there, and found this:    I'm not suggesting you go buy this one, but other guys here will be drooling over it.   If it wasn't so far from me, it would probably be on my trailer.

https://hudsonvalley.craigslist.org/tls/d/felder-k915-table-saw/6456354773.html

Craigs list for me often has a decent selection of saws but that is regional. You mention cabinets, i built a full set of cabinets for a kitchen a year ago for the plywood i almost only used a track saw. I had a cabinet saw at the time but i could have handled all the face frame material and doors on my jobsite saw if i had to. A good table saw is nice but a medicore one you know how to set up well can be just as good.

A cabinet saw sure is nice, but a good contractor saw will certainly do. I had a 52" fence for many years & was soooo glad to get rid of it in favor of a 36" that's attached to a SawStop PCS 3HP. That saw does not disappoint.

One of the first things to get made is a good solid work surface with some kind of provision for securing work. It can also serve as an outfeed table & assembly table.

A track saw would be great, but if budget doesn't allow, then just get a good circ saw & make a guide for it.

IM area. CL is a junk yard filled with over priced rusted out machinery priced almost as much as brand new equipment

I've only been doing woodwork for 1 1/2 years now. I started with a craftsman contractor saw that I out grew quickly and purchased a Delta 36-725 contractor saw that is  absolutely everything I need from now to end.

You don't mention your actual budget, or perhaps I missed it, but if it is unlimited yea, a cabinet saw is what I would want as well,  However, I would expect, as you say you are remodeling a 115 year old home, I expect you to have to spend quite a bit on incidentals you haven't even thought of yet. Which is why a contractor saw not only is an affordable option, but also gives you more budget for other tools and incidentals.

Besides, if you have the room you can build onto and expand your contractor saw - outfeed tables etc. I've seen some contractor saws that take up 30 sq ft easily with all the add ons and feeders!

My opinion of course

 

Oh, forgot to add, if you go used for a table saw, be sure to get one with a riving knife or good splitter & guard. In my opinion, the goodness of SawStop's riving knife & guard, & the ease of changing them out is a more important safety feature than the wiener saving technology

Ill toss my .02c in here as well. I bought a Craftsman hybrid saw off Craigslist about a year ago for $250. It the same model as the Ridgid you can buy from Home Depot for I think $600. Although the saw has some things about it that irritate me a little, It does everything I need it to do.

 

I used a contractors saw for 25 years.  Dust collection is hopeless on a contractors saw. I always had to wear a respirator, and often under a supplied air hood.  I can use the cabinet saw inside a finished house, and get no dust on anything.   That's with a 3hp DC though.  People may think that they have dust collection with a contractors saw, and DC less than 3hp, but in my opinion, it's wishful thinking.  

We still use the contractors saws when the saw needs to be close to the job, and the big saw is too far away, but we always move it outside to use.

Prefacing this by saying I personally have a sawstop jobsite saw, but if I had the option, I'd really like a cabinet saw for the increased stability, power, and ease of dust collection. My shop is in my basement, and I vent my dust collector directly out the window, but I still do use a respirator when making cuts. It really is hard to capture all that dust.

If you don't need a sawstop, and have the power available, I'd look at an option like this

http://www.grizzly.com/products/10-5-HP-240V-Cabinet-Left-Tilting-Table-Saw/G1023RLWX

That is a lot of saw for under $1600, and having your router table built in is a nice space spacing option. 

In a basement shop, with the main goal of building cabinets, I would consider just a track saw, Festool vac and Festool MFT, as was mentioned above.  Whether you get a Festool saw or the Makita version, you're likely to get better dust collection than you would with anything less than a cabinet saw.  The point is to be able to cut sheet goods perfectly square.  The combination of track saw and MFT will do that just as well as a table saw.  Lugging a big TS down a narrow staircase into a basement doesn't sound like a lot of fun to me.  Sure it's possible, but is it necessary for what the OP is doing?  If down the road he wants to get more into furniture, then he's looking at the whole table saw, jointer, planer, DC, etc.

If I was starting now, knowing what I know, I'd buy a Grizzly. I spent $600 on a Delta contractor saw and regret it daily. 

  • Author

Everyone - Thanks for the feedback and comments.  After listening to many people, reading even more and talking with the guys at Woodcraft, I am leaning towards a 3hp SawStop.  My better half is very concerned that I might lose a finger/hand (even though I am careful) and has convinced me to spend the extra $1000 for the safety.  I will continue to use my cheap saw for what I need to in the interim and then fork over the full $$$.  The Woodcraft guy (they really are great - much like you all) said that if I can wait until April SS regularly runs a special where you can get the overarm DC or the cart free.  So I am definitely waiting for that.

On the other items (jointer, planer, etc), I think I am going to buy them used.  Except for the Dust Collection.  Still figuring out how I am going to do that, but Rome wasn't built in a day.

You all are the best!  You have given me a great deal to think about and outstanding advice.  I really appreciate everyone's feedback/thoughts.

Thanks,

Kevin

I think that is a good choice. I'm doing the same thing, saving for a Sawstop.

You have the best Craigslist I've ever seen for tools up there.  I'm not saying this is a good choice for a basement shop, but I've never seen one of these anywhere on CL before.

https://newhaven.craigslist.org/tls/d/northfield-jointer-8/6444545304.html

If I wasn't already so far behind on stuff I need to do because of weather, I've think about coming to get this one myself.

https://hudsonvalley.craigslist.org/tls/d/oliver-jointer-24/6452197703.html

It's strange that both of those jointers have 5 hp 3 phase motors. I wonder what that 24" X 105" jointer weighs ? And how much it would cost to move it and set it up ? Bet it tops 1K in a heartbeat !

Probably something over 2.5k.  Even if I went after it, that would be three days of expenses, and three days not making money.  I could get it on, and off my trailer without a great deal of trouble, but don't really have enough use for it to burn the time going to get it.  I'd just like to have one.  5hp is a lot for an 8" jointer, but I think it would be okay for the big'un.

23 hours ago, klaugh said:

Everyone - Thanks for the feedback and comments.  After listening to many people, reading even more and talking with the guys at Woodcraft, I am leaning towards a 3hp SawStop.  My better half is very concerned that I might lose a finger/hand (even though I am careful) and has convinced me to spend the extra $1000 for the safety.  I will continue to use my cheap saw for what I need to in the interim and then fork over the full $$$.  The Woodcraft guy (they really are great - much like you all) said that if I can wait until April SS regularly runs a special where you can get the overarm DC or the cart free.  So I am definitely waiting for that.

On the other items (jointer, planer, etc), I think I am going to buy them used.  Except for the Dust Collection.  Still figuring out how I am going to do that, but Rome wasn't built in a day.

You all are the best!  You have given me a great deal to think about and outstanding advice.  I really appreciate everyone's feedback/thoughts.

Thanks,

Kevin

You can also take heart that it is not $1000 extra for the safety.  There are saws in the Saw Stop 3HP PCS price tier that do not have the safety function.

On 1/19/2018 at 8:36 AM, klaugh said:

has convinced me to spend the extra $1000 for the safety.

Just remember that it is an added safety feature, NOT an instead of safety feature.

  • Author

@Chet. Agreed. It is more safety. I can’t afford to lose a finger or hand. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.