Bombarde16 Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 OK, insignificant but off-the-wall gripe and I can't be the only one who's noticed this: Just about any time a chisel makes an appearance in a woodworking vid, the host (be it Norm, Tommy, David, Marc, Sandor, etc.) specifies that he or she is using a "good, sharp chisel". The phrase "nice, sharp chisel" is a close second. I love me a sharp chisel as much as the next fellow, but isn't this a bit redundant? Why not just reach for a "chisel". Apart from opening paint cans, is there any reason one would reach for a dull chisel? Is there such a thing as a "bad sharp chisel" or a "good dull chisel"? Quote
Popular Post wdwerker Posted November 8, 2013 Popular Post Report Posted November 8, 2013 I have 3 levels of chisels in my shop. Razor sharp wood handled set for fine work. Fairly sharp plastic handled 30 year old Stanley set for general work and hauling to job sites . And an assortment of cheap crudely sharpened chisels for rough work like chipping off hardened glue and working where the risk of hitting metal is possible, these get sharpened with a belt sander sometimes. 4 Quote
Boatworks Today Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 Ditto Wdwerker.. It all depends on the surface that the chisel is being used on.. If it's always fresh, new wood then it's either sharp or it's not. Personally I use then for removing caulking, remnants of epoxy, etc (all of which dull the edge much faster than plain wood). I keep 2 sets; finish chisels and beater chisels.. One set is used strictly on new wood (and not allowed to be touched by anyone other than me!), and the other for whatever purpose it may fit (not always pretty) . Quote
wdwerker Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 "Not allowed to be touched by anyone other than me! " I have several tools including my good set of chisels in that category! My Veritas block plane and the old tools I inherited from both of my Grandad's . They come out, I use them and then they get cleaned and put back up. I have the handsaw my grandad used to build parts of the house my dad was born in. He gave it to me and had engraved it " To Steve from Grandad Duncan" Quote
G S Haydon Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 Another vote for Steve. I can only assume that the level of sharpness required is mentioned to add clarity for the less experienced. For those with the skills I can appreciate this may get annoying but perhaps the comment is not aimed at them. 1 Quote
duckkisser Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 I have been collecting chisels for some time now. they are all dull. but as of right now I have one cheap plastic chisels that I use on a regular basis because honestly I don't use them often enough for cabinet type work to warrant buying expensive set. I use my chisels more for carving so when they get dull I just throw on my bench grinder with its paper wheel and hone it back to sharp. I plan on some day getting a forge and trying my hand at black smithing so I have been saving chisels, files, band saw blades, and one set of springs from my truck. Quote
Guest Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 OK, insignificant but off-the-wall gripe and I can't be the only one who's noticed this: Just about any time a chisel makes an appearance in a woodworking vid, the host (be it Norm, Tommy, David, Marc, Sandor, etc.) specifies that he or she is using a "good, sharp chisel". The phrase "nice, sharp chisel" is a close second. I love me a sharp chisel as much as the next fellow, but isn't this a bit redundant? Why not just reach for a "chisel". Apart from opening paint cans, is there any reason one would reach for a dull chisel? Is there such a thing as a "bad sharp chisel" or a "good dull chisel"? some people just like to use extraneous adjectives and adverbs when they speak or write. i think "good sharp" this falls into that category. Quote
Cochese Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 Well, there are my good and sharp Narex chisels and then there are my crappy and sharp Harbor Freight chisels. I reach for those when I need to slice open a package or cut some hose. Perhaps that's what they mean? Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk Quote
ChrisG Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 I use a bad dull chisel with a big ole convex bevel for splitting off small pieces of wood for things like wedges and pegs. Quote
Popular Post Ozwald Posted November 8, 2013 Popular Post Report Posted November 8, 2013 I thought I had some bad sharp chisels, but from Graham's insight this morning, perhaps they're just angry. Either way I need to restock the bandaids. 4 Quote
Jfitz Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 "I have the handsaw my grandad used to build parts of the house my dad was born in. He gave it to me and had engraved it " To Steve from Grandad Duncan" OK, that's awesome!!! 1 Quote
krtwood Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 My dad's chisels... I don't think they've been sharpened since before I was born. I'm 37. The corners look like they've been run through a 1/4" roundover bit. It makes me feel better about the miserable state of mine. I picked one I don't use often and was befuddled by its sharpness. Quote
Tpt life Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 When you are speaking to the inexperienced, you need to address possible faults without talking down to your listener. Your listener knows that his/her results do not match yours ("Are my chisels good and sharp?") You have not wasted those precious TV seconds saying "Be sure to use quality steel and hone it sharp often." I think this is a little of what makes his demeanor seem laid back. Quote
Trip Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 ==> Ditto Wdwerker.. +1... I'll add a forth level... A set that my wife uses to open paint cans... Well, OK... She only did that once... In all seriousness... Several years ago, I put together a 'DIY' tool bag for when the wife needs a hammer, chisel, scraper, screwdriver, wrench, tape measure, etc. The bag is kept in a kitchen cabinet (along with a flashlight, fire extinguisher, etc). That way, my shop tools aren't suddenly co-opted for a DIY effort when I'm conveniently out of town... Speaking of DIY, this brings to mind the story of how/why this 'wife-bag' got created... and yes, part of it was the indecent of the Japanese chisel being used to open a paint can... But it's part of a larger narrative... Our home had the unfortunate luck to be built in a era where 'sea foam' was a popular bathroom tile scheme*. We'd lived in the place a couple of months and the frequent dinner conversation topic was what room to renovate first -- we really couldn't come to an accord.... and then....quite suddenly, it was decided for me... Late one night (around 2am), quite unexpectedly, I was jerked awake by a large crash... Didn't know what it was or where it came from... Quite startled, I jumped out of bed and rushed into the hall -- just when another crash occurs... Trust me, it's quite unsettling... I burst into our bathroom (the source of the noise) and see my wife standing in the tub (in just her undergarments) holding a 3lb small sledge (a tool that remained largely virginal in our home -- and must have taken quite some time to locate).. As I enter the room, she turns to me and says, "Sorry, it's got to go" and proceeds to pound the tile wall... I stand there rather dumbfounded... Just agape at the ever-growing hole in the wall... and starting to realize that the "Girl Power" thing is not a myth... After a couple more hammer blows that "revealed her Norse heritage", she turns to me a says, "Don't just stand there, get a garbage can and start cleaning up." I get the garbage can --- and my Hilti demolition hammer, SawZall and wrecking bar.... we spend the remainder of the night demoing the bathroom... True story... *Note: For those of you not old enough to remember the 'sea foam' color scheme... For about a decade it was considered quite fashionable to tile bathroom walls/floors with a 1"x1" tile mosaic of light green, pale green and white tiles -- looking like, well sea foam... It was truly hidious and represents possibly the all-time-low in Western culture... Right after bell bottoms... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dy37DDkwI70 1 Quote
G S Haydon Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 ==> Ditto Wdwerker.. +1... I'll add a forth level... A set that my wife uses to open paint cans... Well, OK... She only did that once... In all seriousness... Several years ago, I put together a 'DIY' tool bag for when the wife asks for a hammer, chisel, scraper, screwdriver, wrench, tape measure, etc. The bag is kept in a kitchen cabinet (along with a flashlight, fire extinguisher, etc). That way, my shop tools aren't suddenly co-opted for a DIY effort when I'm conveniently out of town... Speaking of DIY, this brings to mind the story of how/why this bag got created... and yes, part of it was the indecent of the Japanese chisel being used to open a paint can... But it's part of a larger narrative... Our home had the unfortunate luck to be built in a era where 'sea foam' was a popular bathroom tile scheme*. We'd lived in the place a couple of months and the frequent dinner conversation topic was what rooms to renovate first.... Late one night (around 2am), quite unexpectedly, I was jerked awake by a large crash... Didn't know what it was or where it came from... Quite startled, I jumped out of bed and rushed into the hall when another crash occurs... I burst into our bathroom and see my wife standing in the tub (in just her undergarments) holding a 3lb small sledge... As I enter the room, she turns to me and says, "Sorry, it's got to go" and proceeds to pound the tile wall... I stand there rather dumbfounded... After a couple more hammer blows that revealed her Norse heritage, she turns to me a says, "Don't just stand there, get a garbage can and start cleaning up." I get the garbage can --- and my Hilti demolition hammer, SawZall and wrecking bar.... we spend the remainder of the night demoing the bathroom... True story... *Note: For those of you not old enough to remember the 'sea foam' color scheme... For about a decade it was considered quite fashionable to tile bathroom walls/floors with a 1"x1" tile mosaic of light green, pale green and white tiles -- looking like, well sea foam... It was truly hidious and represents possibly the all-time-low in Western culture... Right after bell bottoms... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dy37DDkwI70 Quote
Tom King Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 ==> Ditto Wdwerker.. +1... I'll add a forth level... A set that my wife uses to open paint cans... Well, OK... She only did that once... In all seriousness... Several years ago, I put together a 'DIY' tool bag for when the wife asks for a hammer, chisel, scraper, screwdriver, wrench, tape measure, etc. The bag is kept in a kitchen cabinet (along with a flashlight, fire extinguisher, etc). That way, my shop tools aren't suddenly co-opted for a DIY effort when I'm conveniently out of town... Speaking of DIY, this brings to mind the story of how/why this bag got created... and yes, part of it was the indecent of the Japanese chisel being used to open a paint can... But it's part of a larger narrative... Our home had the unfortunate luck to be built in a era where 'sea foam' was a popular bathroom tile scheme*. We'd lived in the place a couple of months and the frequent dinner conversation topic was what rooms to renovate first.... Late one night (around 2am), quite unexpectedly, I was jerked awake by a large crash... Didn't know what it was or where it came from... Quite startled, I jumped out of bed and rushed into the hall when another crash occurs... I burst into our bathroom and see my wife standing in the tub (in just her undergarments) holding a 3lb small sledge... As I enter the room, she turns to me and says, "Sorry, it's got to go" and proceeds to pound the tile wall... I stand there rather dumbfounded... After a couple more hammer blows that revealed her Norse heritage, she turns to me a says, "Don't just stand there, get a garbage can and start cleaning up." I get the garbage can --- and my Hilti demolition hammer, SawZall and wrecking bar.... we spend the remainder of the night demoing the bathroom... True story... *Note: For those of you not old enough to remember the 'sea foam' color scheme... For about a decade it was considered quite fashionable to tile bathroom walls/floors with a 1"x1" tile mosaic of light green, pale green and white tiles -- looking like, well sea foam... It was truly hidious and represents possibly the all-time-low in Western culture... Right after bell bottoms... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dy37DDkwI70 Actually, I liked the seafoam a half-step better than the sick pink from the same manufacturer and time, and that was a good decade before bell bottoms. My wife regretted having to buy a 3/8" SnapOn screwdriver after she picked that one to dig rocks out of the jumping ring with. I made her a toolbox too after that, but she still had to replace the screwdriver. I kept that screwdriver with the worn out tip, and gave it to her every time she asked to borrow a screwdriver, until she stopped asking. Quote
Bombarde16 Posted November 8, 2013 Author Report Posted November 8, 2013 Late one night (around 2am), quite unexpectedly, I was jerked awake by a large crash... Didn't know what it was or where it came from... Quite startled, I jumped out of bed and rushed into the hall when another crash occurs... I burst into our bathroom and see my wife standing in the tub I was expecting you to say that she was chipping away at the tile and mortar using one of your good chisels... 2 Quote
wdwerker Posted November 8, 2013 Report Posted November 8, 2013 We had a peach colored bathroom and a light grey one that wasn't near as revolting. An earlier house had a mint green bath, sink, toilet and tub all mint green! My Mom had a yellow set of tools in the kitchen and she was strict about them coming right back where they belonged. She had learned a good bit about tools from her dad. Guess it runs on both sides of my family. Quote
Trip Posted November 9, 2013 Report Posted November 9, 2013 ==> half-step better than the sick pink from the same manufacturer and time Yea, I forgot about that one... When I was a kid, we moved into a home with that.... I was the designated 'shop helper' in those days.... It went quick... Quote
Trip Posted November 9, 2013 Report Posted November 9, 2013 ==> chipping away at the tile and mortar using one of your good chisels... Nope... Channeling her 'inner Thor'... Her nickname has always been, "Zena, Warier Princess"... Quote
Tpt life Posted November 9, 2013 Report Posted November 9, 2013 Hmm, pink. Kids bath, not sure when it will be changed:-) Quote
Trip Posted November 9, 2013 Report Posted November 9, 2013 ==> not sure when it will be changed Not sure what happened in the '70s and '80s... Did folks just detox from the '60s and decide that truly ugly interior decorating schemes were a path to redemption -- maybe step thirteen in a twelve-step program? Note: A few months ago, my wife and I watched a rerun of the pilot for a 'brand new home-improvement show on PBS' – something called 'this old house'… There was this young guy wearing a bold paisley shirt, bell-bottoms, a belt buckle that Elvis would be proud to own, a face full of hair and sporting an enormous afro (a very young Bob Vila looking like a ‘70s porn star)… He was introducing the 'kitchen of the future'… what 'every forward-looking contractor was going to install'… He called the style 'timeless'… The 'timeless' decor sported dark oak cabinetry (MDF carcass), sunset orange melamine counter, sea foam backsplash (appliance faces to match), etc, etc... Each 'feature' more hideous then the last... I'm not making this sh*t up... It was truly the most awful kitchen imaginable and would have been truly funny ---- had we not moved into a house with one just like it.... Those must have been some good drugs in the '60s... Quote
ColinF Posted November 10, 2013 Report Posted November 10, 2013 ==> Ditto Wdwerker.. +1... I'll add a forth level... A set that my wife uses to open paint cans... Well, OK... She only did that once...In all seriousness... Several years ago, I put together a 'DIY' tool bag for when the wife asks for a hammer, chisel, scraper, screwdriver, wrench, tape measure, etc. The bag is kept in a kitchen cabinet (along with a flashlight, fire extinguisher, etc). That way, my shop tools aren't suddenly co-opted for a DIY effort when I'm conveniently out of town...Speaking of DIY, this brings to mind the story of how/why this bag got created... and yes, part of it was the indecent of the Japanese chisel being used to open a paint can... But it's part of a larger narrative... Our home had the unfortunate luck to be built in a era where 'sea foam' was a popular bathroom tile scheme*. We'd lived in the place a couple of months and the frequent dinner conversation topic was what rooms to renovate first.... Late one night (around 2am), quite unexpectedly, I was jerked awake by a large crash... Didn't know what it was or where it came from... Quite startled, I jumped out of bed and rushed into the hall when another crash occurs... I burst into our bathroom and see my wife standing in the tub (in just her undergarments) holding a 3lb small sledge... As I enter the room, she turns to me and says, "Sorry, it's got to go" and proceeds to pound the tile wall... I stand there rather dumbfounded... After a couple more hammer blows that revealed her Norse heritage, she turns to me a says, "Don't just stand there, get a garbage can and start cleaning up." I get the garbage can --- and my Hilti demolition hammer, SawZall and wrecking bar.... we spend the remainder of the night demoing the bathroom... True story...*Note: For those of you not old enough to remember the 'sea foam' color scheme... For about a decade it was considered quite fashionable to tile bathroom walls/floors with a 1"x1" tile mosaic of light green, pale green and white tiles -- looking like, well sea foam... It was truly hidious and represents possibly the all-time-low in Western culture... Right after bell bottoms... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dy37DDkwI70I'm sorry, but if I find my wife standing in the tub in her under garmets with a 3lb sledge, the first thing in my mind is sexiest wife ever! I have woken my wife up trying to quietly destroy something, usually it starts out with the idea I can surprise her in the morning and I only need hand tools and moves onto needing a grinder, torch, or any other tool that is extremely dangerous when your tired and frustrated! Quote
Byrdie Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 As a kid a I remember a couple different homes where the bathrooms were pink tile trimmed with black from my childhood. As far as co-opting my tools, I've had one wife and one long term partner. Both of them pretty much went the opposite way of what was described here. I once made the mistake of asking my ex-partner to help me stretch fence on the pasture. She came out and helped me with the first length, turned to me and said, "If I'd wanted to learn how to stretch fence I'd have taken the course in college. That's what I have you for." She then left me standing there to figure out how to tighten the remaining mile or so of fence by myself. More just telling the story than complaining too loudly as it helped become pretty self sufficient. I'm pretty good at figuring out how to do things without calling for a second set of hands. In fact, I've had to relearn in some cases when it's appropriate to ask for help. 2 Quote
Ozwald Posted November 11, 2013 Report Posted November 11, 2013 I hear ya Byrd. I've used Irwin fast clamps as my 2nd & occasionally 3rd person too many times to count. Sometimes in rather odd situations. But whatever works. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.