Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Shopping around for a new shop

Featured Replies

We are looking at buying a new to us house and with it a new shop for me. I currently have a 1.5 detached garage that is all my space. The drawback has always been no heat and a single 20 amp circuit. We knew we weren't staying forever so we didn't put in a panel or heat. Location is SE Wisconsin so the lack of heat has always kept me from working in the winter, the best time to be in there.

I am thinking for my next shop I wouldn't mind it being in the right basement space. It will make it much easier to find a house and get more space, potentially. There are not really any houses with detached shops where we are looking. We will have a garage, but we keep cars and mowers in there. If we found a third stall i might use that. In a basement, I would also have a much cheaper route to get appropriate power, heat and ac. I also think it would be nice to easily spend 15 minutes working or putsing and always having glue warm and wool acclimated. Frankly I'm stoked to look at a basement alternative.

I would look to increase the 325 square feet I currently have and make sure I have relatively easy access. I am hoping for a window or two as my current space has great light with five including a picture window. What else should I look for? What do you like about your basement shops?

Find one with walk out access. We just bought a house with a 2 car garage and a full, unfinished basement that has an outside door with 4 steps. Going to install air compressor in garage and plumb to basement. Considering same for DC.

 

Sent from my Nexus 9 using Tapatalk

 

 

Basement shops have a lot of problems associated with them. Most people avoid them whenever possible. The biggest issues are dust and noise. If you have children expect to be unable to use the shop whenever they are sleeping. 

The other issue dust is a huge concern. It gets into ventilation and will go everywhere in your house. Apparently it doesn't matter if your ventilation is only blowing out in your basement, it can still drift in when the air turns off and go everywhere in the house. This is a huge problem and not to be underestimated.

I would seriously reconsider a detached alternative or a 3 bay garage and take everything that is not a car and put it in an unheated shed. 

I am also tempted to use my basement, as it's unfinished and big (2.5x my garage).  However, I decided a while ago not to make the move.  The problems associated with using a basement are well documented, so do lots of research before going that route.  With that said, lots of people love their basent shops, and there are also many benefits (heat, for one).

Yep, good recap of the con's of a basement shop. Both can be mitigated in the right circumstances. I have a basement shop in a 1400sqft ranch. It honestly isn't that loud upstairs in the living quarters. If you have small kids, this is going to be a problem. I do most of my stationary machinery work on weekends when my wife is at work or doing something else. I don't think it bothers her much. When we got a puppy a couple months ago I was really concerned for his hearing and well being. He doesn't even twitch when I do something downstairs. Weatherstripping the door down to the basement helped some. If you have a drywall ceiling in your shop, that would help a ton too. 

 

You need to take the appropriate steps to handle dust. I'm no scientist, but 3-5hp cyclone with quality filter is paramount. Quality ambient air filter is important too. I know people call BS on these, but plenty of evidence showing they work. After that, I would stay up on quality hvac filters, and do your best to keep the living quarters sealed off from the shop. Lastly, never finish in your shop. Do the finish work in a garage or something. To me, VOCs exposure scares me more than dust. Basements aren't ideal by any stretch, but it is nice to pop down after dinner for 20 mins to sand something, or glue a panel, or scrap glue etc. In the summer they are always cool, and mine typically holds around 55 degrees in the winter. All the vents are taped off in my basement. 

Look for > 8 foot ceiling height. When I built my house there was an option for '9 foot' ceilings for I forget, 2k or 4k extra. Excellent investment since sheet goods are all 8 feet long :).

I put 9 feet in quotes because the actual height is a few inches short but it is > 8.5 which makes a big difference. 

Lot of good comments above.  I am in a basement shop as are lots of other folks.  

If you can't get a walk out you have to look at how you get big equipment in (and out).  

Ceiling height is a limiting factor for me, 8ft.  I have 4 windows, I can open them for ventillation which is nice, but I can't look outside which is not.  

It's cool in the summer, but cold in the winter so I needed to add a heater for when I am working, but it's too cold for finishes to cure overnight in the winter.

  

  • Popular Post

Maybe instead of a basement, have you considered something south of the Mason-Dixon? We touched on 31* twice this year. 

Just move to Colorado like every other sane Wisconsinite has. :) 

I have a decent space in my basement, and it's a walkout, and for the dust control issues alone I think I'd sacrifice half my space to be in a garage.  My wife says the noise isn't an issue, but without a big 5 hp dust collector I don't think I'll ever be really comfortable having my shop within the house.  I gotta save my pennies...

I love my basement shop because it is mine but truthfully I hate that it has to be there. It is set up nice and all but it severely limits my working time as it is directly below the bedroom and the 7'6" ceilings make it stupidly difficult to work with anything 8' or longer (I have the notes from my grandfather when he built the house and he took off the last row of block to save money and sacrifice the 8' ceiling........ He saved all of $120 in 1979) I would love to build a detached workshop and will, eventually, but, for now, I will make the best of my 400sqft.

3 hours ago, CandorLush said:

........ He saved all of $120 in 1979)

Wow, guess he wasn't predicting that festool sandpaper would sell for that in 2016.

18 minutes ago, Pug said:

Wow, guess he wasn't predicting that festool sandpaper would sell for that in 2016.

Well, to be fair, that's like $400 after inflation, so he could afford the entry-level sander to go with the paper!

1 hour ago, Pug said:

Wow, guess he wasn't predicting that festool sandpaper would sell for that in 2016.

And for the price it would cost me to fix his "savings" I could probably build a 1200sqft shop with HVAC

You need to take the appropriate steps to handle dust. I'm no scientist, but 3-5hp cyclone with quality filter is paramount. Quality ambient air filter is important too. I know people call BS on these, but plenty of evidence showing they work. After that, I would stay up on quality hvac filters, and do your best to keep the living quarters sealed off from the shop. Lastly, never finish in your shop. Do the finish work in a garage or something. To me, VOCs exposure scares me more than dust. 

 

If you really want to know your exposures for a relatively small fee you can have a industrial hygiene study done to determine noise, chemical, and particulate exposures. The only part that might be more difficult is the chemical exposures as each chemical has their own limits and specific analysis types. But if you aren't in a rush for any of the info you can slow boat the analysis and bring the cost way down.

 

This will give you peace of mind plus you can have hard data to show what your shop actually generates.

 

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

 

 

  • Popular Post

Personally I love my basement shop.  It's always the right temperature for working and can go down for a 15 minute session whenever the opportunity presents itself and can re-appear to rest of the family at a moments notice.  I do have a walk out, actually a small overhead door into this shop even (was intended for mower storage and such I think)

Noise wise it isn't too big of an issue, the living room is directly overhead, so does require turning the TV a bit louder if I have the planer going (Dewalt 735 w/ noisy blower).  Right now with an infant that sometimes sleeps in the living room before everyone goes to bed it can be an issue, but that will be short lived.  Bedrooms are all on the second floor so that's not an issue.  

Maybe I am not concerned enough with the dust, but have been at it for 3+ years now in this shop and still don't have much concern.  I did go through and caulk/tape up the ducts that do run the shop.  I am sure that's not 100% but can't hurt.  The one thing I do have going for it is that the furnace and water heater are on the first floor, so there are less mechanicals in the basement.

Ceiling height is limited, but for the most part that doesn't hinder much work, but would be an issue for running dust collection ducts and such.  I don't have enough space to keep tools stationary, so no duct work for me.  

(Pictures are a couple years out of date, improved bench and other changes since these)

IMG_20140322_222958_738.jpg

IMG_20140322_223012_959.jpg

IMG_20140322_223023_120.jpg

IMG_20140322_222938_165.jpg

Nice shop. It is good that you have a door to open up on nice days also.

  • Author

Thanks all and thanks danbell. 

For those with outdoor shops in northern climates. How do you keep wood acclimated in the winter? I understand turning on the heat to work, but doesn't it hinder the process to have wood cold and then "acclimate" it in a few hours. Don't you need a couple weeks at relatively stable temps? I think this issue would give basements a leg up.

Basement? That ain't a basement, no sir, that's a fine looking shop. Nice layout! As far as winters, can't help you as we haven't had one in several years.

1 hour ago, atlinwi202 said:

Thanks all and thanks danbell. 

For those with outdoor shops in northern climates. How do you keep wood acclimated in the winter? I understand turning on the heat to work, but doesn't it hinder the process to have wood cold and then "acclimate" it in a few hours. Don't you need a couple weeks at relatively stable temps? I think this issue would give basements a leg up.

I keep my garage/shop at about 3C normally & then warm it up for work. Never noticed any adverse effects. If I've done a glue up or finishing I'll leave it at 18C or so until things are cured.

13 hours ago, drzaius said:

I keep my garage/shop at about 3C normally & then warm it up for work. Never noticed any adverse effects. If I've done a glue up or finishing I'll leave it at 18C or so until things are cured.

I'm in the same situation during the winter I keep my shop at 50 when not working and 65ish when working, no issues. One thing have noticed is the more the heat runs the more lack of humidity becomes an issue so I do use a humidifier in the winter. In the the summer the air conditioning is set at 75 24/7.

59 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said:

I'm jealous of shops with climate control. Mine is generally a few degrees above ambient outdoor temp.

I gotta say it is nice, but around here it's pretty necessary in the winter.

I installed an ac/heat pump type thingy last August. Not only is it nice and cool, but with the doors closed, I compensate for the extra electric cost as it keeps the neighbors out and I save on beer costs. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.