bob493 Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Been on the fence about getting a biscuit jointer. Is it simply a bandaid for less than perfect face joinery, or does it provide stability for things i haven't had to deal with yet? please note ,this is NOT bashing those that use them. I am sincerely curious. Quote
Chestnut Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I own one and i firmly believe that there are no uses where you need one. Classic joinery will take it's place 75% of the time and for the other 25% save and buy a domino. I don't even like festool. 2 Quote
bob493 Posted May 9, 2016 Author Report Posted May 9, 2016 Just now, Chestnut said: I own one and i firmly believe that there are no uses where you need one. Classic joinery will take it's place 75% of the time and for the other 25% save and buy a domino. I've never seen a joint where I've wanted a biscuit,but I've been doing SMALL projects. For large panel glue ups, what do you think about em? Quote
Chestnut Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I join almost all my tops together with it, but it's not structural it's purely alignment. I've done some shop tables where i attached the legs to the aprons. That was a mistake that resulted it me falling 4 feet off of a broken table back first on to the floor. I will say that that was probably more my stupidity than biscuit joints being poor. I use mine for cabinets a lot to join plywood together for that it works pretty good but it's only because I'm to lazy to get a dado setup. Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I use have had a biscuit joiner for many years and I use it often in my work. It works great for helping to align edge joinery glue-ups, especially in boards that are not perfectly straight. It is common that the dimensions of plywood don't fit my needs and I can use biscuits to join them and they look factory made when I am done. It also works well for right angle sheet goods joinery in plywood, MDF, and particle board. I also own a Domino when I need something more like true tenon joinery because biscuits are not tenons. The Domino largely took the place of using my floor standing mortiser and cutting tenons at the table saw or WoodRat. I have the smaller Domino so if I need larger M&T I fire up the big mortiser again. Overall, I would say that a biscuit joiner has it's place and you will probably end up using it. Quote
Popular Post Eric. Posted May 9, 2016 Popular Post Report Posted May 9, 2016 "Need" is always a strong word in woodworking. A Domino makes the biscuit joiner obsolete. But if I didn't have a Domino I'd own one. I still have mine but it doesn't get much use anymore. They ARE useful tools, they're just almost universally used for the WRONG things, which is why they get a bad rap. "This apron to leg joint sucks!" No...YOU suck. Idiot. It is not a joinery tool, it's an alignment tool. And as long as you use it as such, it's great. 4 Quote
..Kev Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Eric is correct! It's a good tool for alignment but, is not meant for joinery. That's why so many like the domino because it can do both. Quote
toddclippinger Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 2 minutes ago, Eric. said: "Need" is always a strong word in woodworking. A Domino makes the biscuit joiner obsolete. But if I didn't have a Domino I'd own one. I still have mine but it doesn't get much use anymore. This is a very accurate statement. Quote
gee-dub Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I bought one way back. A very nice Porter Cable before they went south. After using it once I realized I was not sure why I thought I needed one (peer pressure without a doubt, that's why I have a CMS out in the shed too) and sold it for not too great a loss. The buyer did the sort of work where one is used a lot and was glad to get another one. I found that for alignment they are not accurate at all, as tenons they're not but, could allow for some shear strength if your only alternative is a butt joint. Take this with a grain of salt from someone who couldn't really find a use for one. Someone who knows how to make one sing will have a different opinion Quote
Brendon_t Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Used one a few times, got let down every time. Bought a domino, have barely used it.. Quote
AceHoleInOne Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 Don't bother with one. Mine rarely is used. Funny though, this year I used it for joining some sheet good's for large quilt sewing table tops. Think it was in the drawer for over 5 years without use. -Ace- Quote
treeslayer Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 i have the dewalt biscuit cutter and i use it mainly for alignment on long boards, and it does work good for other things as mentioned above. but if i had a domino i would sell it in a heartbeat Quote
wdwerker Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I have 2 Lamello biscut joiners ( one of the finest ones made) I used them for years to help align panel glue ups and casework corners. Then I got a Domino and the biscut joiners sit collecting dust. Quote
rodger. Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I bought a domino, and thought I would save the PC biscuit cutter for alignment of panels, as biscuits are far cheaper than dominos. After it sat unused for a year or two, i sold it off and bought a stack of 4/4 cherry with the proceeds. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I don't have a biscuit cutter OR a domino, and so far, I don't feel particularly under-priviledged. Watching stuff like this: on youtube has convinced me that almost all of MY tools are pure luxury... 2 Quote
Cliff Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I don't like them. I have used mine on 3 projects and gotten poor results. I don't know if I mess it up every time or what but my panels do not come out nearly as well as not using biscuits. Quote
Chet Posted May 9, 2016 Report Posted May 9, 2016 I have had on a long time. Like stated above I use it for alinement not for joints. Quote
drzaius Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 I've had a biscuit joiner for years, since before Lamello's patent ran out, & still use it occasionally. But not for aligning for glue ups; there are better ways of doing that. They are great at reinforcing butt joints in sheet goods projects. I just glued up a 45 degree joint in a prefab butcher block counter using double rows of biscuits. Easy, quick & strong enough. The key to getting any strength at all with biscuits is to THOROUGHLY apply lots of glue to both the biscuit and the slot. After saying all that, I'd go for the Domino any day over the biscuit joiner if I didn't have either. Quote
rodger. Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 1 hour ago, Cliff said: I don't like them. I have used mine on 3 projects and gotten poor results. I don't know if I mess it up every time or what but my panels do not come out nearly as well as not using biscuits. @Cliff in this one. Even though I have gotten great results with biscuits, cauls are a better choice. An no one has mentioned the WORST part of using a biscuit joiner - cutting into a biscuit! Aggggg that sucks! 1 Quote
..Kev Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 3 minutes ago, Pug said: An no one has mentioned the WORST part of using a biscuit joiner - cutting into a biscuit! Aggggg that sucks! No worse than cutting into a domino.. 1 Quote
Coop Posted May 10, 2016 Report Posted May 10, 2016 2 hours ago, wtnhighlander said: I don't have a biscuit cutter OR a domino, and so far, I don't feel particularly under-priviledged. Watching stuff like this: on youtube has convinced me that almost all of MY tools are pure luxury... That is cool as heck. Apparently he has no intention of getting married. Quote
BeardedCarpenter Posted August 8, 2016 Report Posted August 8, 2016 Interesting thread. I recently heard someone criticize biscuit joints, and I thought he was probably in the minority. But it seems that many of you see limited use for one, if any use. I searched for a thread about it because I'm currently doing a project that involves gluing 2 1/2" pieces together. My thought is that biscuits don't do much as far as adding strength to the glue joint. If I can align the pieces without biscuits, then the biscuits would be an unnecessary step. Quote
Tpt life Posted August 8, 2016 Report Posted August 8, 2016 Yes, but biscuits cut fast for what alignment help they are. There is the snipped pin nail trick also. Just know why you use them and don't use them just because Norm did. 1 Quote
Cliff Posted August 8, 2016 Report Posted August 8, 2016 On 5/9/2016 at 1:54 PM, gee-dub said: I found that for alignment they are not accurate at all That's exactly the issue I had. Biscuits have been zero help in aligning. I don't know if I'm an idiot or what but my best glue ups have all been with no helpers. Quote
Da Hammer Posted August 8, 2016 Report Posted August 8, 2016 Since I am one of the newbies on here... For those that don't use a domino or a biscuit joiner, what do you all use to keep boards aligned in glue ups? I am having trouble visualizing something else to do the same job? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.