Recommended Posts

Posted

I need to get rid of my 200,000 mile Suburban and think seriously about a pickup. I've never had one, I know, living in Texas! All of my company vehicles have always been Fords and Chevys, but everytime I see a good looking pickup on the highway, it's either a Dodge or Tundra. I'm retiring at the end of the year so, it needs to last for a while, get good mileage and hopefully, transport a sheet of ply every once in a while. Any suggestions? 

Posted

 

Willing to go diese!? Dodge has an engine they call the 'Eco-diesel', available in the Ram 1500 trucks, and Jeep Grand Cherokees. Supposed to get mid to upper 20's, at least on the highway.

 

A friend at work has a 2017 GMC Canyon with a 2.8 liter Duramax diesel, and 4 wheel drive. He claims 31 mpg. The Canyon is a 'mid-size' truck, but the rated towing capacity is greater than my Avalanche.

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted
15 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said:

Willing to go diese!? Dodge has an engine they call the 'Eco-diesel', available in the Ram 1500 trucks, and Jeep Grand Cherokees. Supposed to get mid to upper 20's, at leasy on tbe highway.

A friend at work has a 2017 GMC Canyon with a 2.8 liter Duramax diesel, and 4 wheel drive. He claims 31 mpg. The Canyon is a 'mid-size' truck, but the rated towing capacity is greater than my Avalanche.

I have the eco-diesel and absolutely love it!  As most know, I travel for work and am currently getting 30mpg on the freeway and about 24 running around town.  It's a 1/2 ton truck, super comfortable, has all the bells and whistles, and still hauls the lumber.  I'd buy another one no doubt!

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't own a truck either (yet), but its always been Toyotas on my mind. My father was a landscaper for a couple decades, and his 06 Tundra was always reliable. More dependable than the F350 we used for equipment hauling.

If you aren't hauling rocks or a trailer, seems like a Tacoma would be a great choice. Got to drive a coworkers 2015 Tacoma sport, and that thing is a blast on the highway. It can certainly haul your lumber too.

  • Like 1
Posted

We've got a couple of Tacomas.  One fairly stripped which is my lumber hauler / do whatever truck.  The wife drives a four door which is great for hauling people.  I have taken it to the lumber yard but, I often refer to the short little bed as the truck's purse.  

Neither my ego or my lifestyle require a full sized truck at this point in my life.  I have a relative that drives a Ram Crew Cab diesel that cost almost as much as my first house.  The most he ever hauls is a couple of gun bags and an ice chest to the range. 

Think about how you will use your vehicle in retirement and build your requirements around that if you want to go practical.  If you want to go for the cool factor, there are some awfully nice pickups being offered today.  I drool over a Tundra "1794 Edition" that a coworker drives.  My Taco looks like a toy parked next to it.

  • Like 1
Posted

In my life I've owned Chevy (GMC anyway), Ford and Dodge, all three.  So I like to think I'm an objective truck buyer who goes after the best vehicle for the money and puts aside the "piss on this or that brand" nonsense...they're all fairly similar in quality and specs IMO...they all have their problems and their perks.

I think GMC and Chevy are just too expensive.  Period.  I think they probably eek out the best quality award out of the three but they're just WAY overpriced even in that light.  I personally hate the new body styles.  They used to be my favorite.  The first new vehicle I owned was a black '97 Z71...I will never love another truck the way I loved that one.  Never.

I currently drive an '04 F150.  It's been a pretty reliable truck but minor stuff is starting to fall apart now.  Door problems, the seat is ripping to shreds, other Mickey Mouse stuff keeps breaking pretty regularly.  It also sounds like a freaking freight train rolling down even the slightest bumpy road...rattles like hell.  I like the bodies on the new Fords okay and I give them second place if I were going to buy a new truck today.

I've had a RAM Promaster for my work van for about the last three years.  While it's not exactly a truck, I've gotten a good idea about RAM build quality and how they drive, and for the price tag I'm very impressed.  You just get so much more truck for the money with RAM these days, and I think they absolutely nailed the bodies...great lines.  I didn't love the interiors on RAMs, but this year they made some improvements on the high end trucks and they're pretty damn sweet.  They even make an "off-road" model that comes with chunky tires.  Awesome trucks.  I know RAM has had a reputation for slightly lower quality than the other two over the years, but I don't think there's much truth to that anymore, if any.  If I were buying a truck today I'm pretty sure it would be a RAM.  Bang/buck ratio and all.

Never owned a Toyota so I'll leave them for others to talk about.  I don't love the Tundra bodies but there's no doubt that Toyota has a reputation for reliability.

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, estesbubba said:

I had a 2006 Dodge 2500 diesel and kept it for 135,000 miles and didn't have any major problems with it. I currently have a 2015 Ram 3500 diesel and it also has been a great truck so far. I have friends that own Chevy and Ford and they are all great trucks these days. 

I do like the looks of the Ram.

 

That's a beast, Mike.  Sweet truck.  And ya gotta love black.

Posted

I've worn out several of each.  I've been driving the current Duramax Chey duallie for a bit over 16 years now.  My method of buying and using vehicles is to make one payment, and drive it until it drops.  If I need another one in maybe ten years, I'll get another one of the current models of this one.  It's one of the few things I've ever bought that ended up being better than I had thought it would be when I bought it.  I like the ride, and handling of the GM's.

  • Like 1
Posted

I would love to have a truck, but there is little I do that requires it.  It would be convenient to toss a sheet of plywood in the bed, but I have it broken down before I buy it anyways.

I have had 3 Toyota's (2 Corolla and a Yaris) and they have been great.  My last corolla went 400k km and it was still going when I traded it in (11 years on the road). My next vechile will be another Toyota.

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm an import guy because I trust the reviews and buy reliability.  This is changing though (Ford and Chevy are competitive now).  The Tacoma hasn't gotten the approval rating like the Tundra has the last 5+ years.  I'm waiting for the new Honda Ridgeline reviews.  

I might trade in my 2005 Tundra (74,000 mi) and my 97 Honda (225,000 + mi) for a Toyota 4 Runner.  I bought both vehicles in 2008 and don't need 2 cars anymore.  Love my Tundra but it's a double cab and it's way too big.  Don't like parking next to people because they're savages.

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, sjeff70 said:

Toyota 4 Runner

This is probably what I'd drive if I lived in a condo.  I love those things.  But I don't know how a guy lives without a truck if he owns a house.

  • Like 1
Posted

I've got the new Honda Ridgeline.  It's the first truck I've every owned, and so far I'm loving it.  If you're past the stage in your life where you want to impress people with what you drive, this is a great vehicle to consider.  Being a new truck there are no long term reviews yet, but Honda has always been know for reliability, so I'm not worried about that aspect of it.  It is different than most "real" trucks, with front wheel drive (with options for all wheel drive), and has unibody construction, but it drives very smoothly as a result.  The ride quality is like driving a nice sedan.

As far a practical stuff, they've designed it so that it can carry a 4x8 sheet laying flat in the back.  Also, because it has no rear axle, it has a huge trunk underneath the bed that all kinds of stuff.  It's big enough to fit my hockey bag in.  The back seat area is also designed very well, with fold-up seats that give you a ton of storage if needed.

Mileage is just ok.  I'm averaging about 13.7 L/100km (sorry, we don't do MPG up here), and they're not the cheapest to buy.  I've got the top of the line Touring edition which comes with everything under the sun, but there are much less expensive versions that get you all the important stuff.

Overall, it's been great for what I need it for.  I'm not hauling 4000 lb loads, but for plywood, lumber, landscaping stuff for my backyard, etc, it's the perfect truck for me.

  • Like 1
Posted
1 minute ago, Eric. said:

This is probably what I'd drive if I lived in a condo.  I love those things.  But I don't know how a guy lives without a truck if he owns a house.

Haha yea I know.  It could be a problem.    

Posted

When my 03 Silverado finally gives up the ghost, I'll most likey be replacing it with a year old Tundra.  

Like Eric said, Chevy has gotten way to expensive. My current truck was loaded of the lot. Every amenity they offered for $31,000 stucker.  Now the base truck is $33k and you can quickly run yourself up into 50k by adding options. 

  • Like 1
Posted
18 minutes ago, Art said:

I've got the new Honda Ridgeline.  It's the first truck I've every owned, and so far I'm loving it.  If you're past the stage in your life where you want to impress people with what you drive, this is a great vehicle to consider.  Being a new truck there are no long term reviews yet, but Honda has always been know for reliability, so I'm not worried about that aspect of it.  It is different than most "real" trucks, with front wheel drive (with options for all wheel drive), and has unibody construction, but it drives very smoothly as a result.  The ride quality is like driving a nice sedan.

As far a practical stuff, they've designed it so that it can carry a 4x8 sheet laying flat in the back.  Also, because it has no rear axle, it has a huge trunk underneath the bed that all kinds of stuff.  It's big enough to fit my hockey bag in.  The back seat area is also designed very well, with fold-up seats that give you a ton of storage if needed.

Mileage is just ok.  I'm averaging about 13.7 L/100km (sorry, we don't do MPG up here), and they're not the cheapest to buy.  I've got the top of the line Touring edition which comes with everything under the sun, but there are much less expensive versions that get you all the important stuff.

Overall, it's been great for what I need it for.  I'm not hauling 4000 lb loads, but for plywood, lumber, landscaping stuff for my backyard, etc, it's the perfect truck for me.

Good review Art, thank you.  I do love my little Honda and my first Honda lawnmower I just bought.  :D 

Posted

Ken, over the past 38 years, I have owned and driven:

 

2 Nissans

1 Toyota

2 Hondas

3 Chevys

1 Ford

5 Chrysler / Dodges

 

Only the first Nissan (Datsun, back then) was a new purchase.

 

The Chrysler / Dodge number is high, because they are less expensive on the used market. And because I didn't keep most of them more than a year or so. The Dodges I owned were from the 90s, and Chrysler Corp. seemed to still be making 'disposable' vehicles that went downhill quickly after 50k miles or so. But I can't recall parting with any of my vehicles before they had at least 100k miles. My current Avalanche had 100k when I bought it, now has 280k.

 

All that to say that I can't point out a huge difference in quality between any of them. Longevity, maybe. But just maybe.

 

As for my preference in style, features, etc..., I would have to say the Silverado, and now the Avalanche, have been my favorites. When this AV finally dies, I'm probably going to look for another, as it fits my needs better than any other vehicle I've owned.

  • Like 1
Posted

I worked for a dealership for 18 years that sold GMC, Chevy, Dodge, Ford, and Toyota. They all make good trucks. They can all have problems from time to time. That's what the warranty is for. Ken, you just need to get out there and test drive the ones that appeal to you the most. Some folks like pulling power while others prefer a smoother ride in their trucks.  Some like diesel engines and other prefer gas burners. I've never owned a Dodge truck or a Ford truck. I've certainly driven all of them. I've owned a GMC 4x4's for the last 20 years. I believe that the GM trucks have a smoother ride. I know my truck rides better than my wife's Toyota Camry. Most dealerships sell at invoice now days - for whatever that's worth. The sticker priced means very little since most offer huge rebates and low financing.

Buying a new truck is like buying a new piece of woodworking equipment. Everyone has their favorites.

Have a good time shopping for your new truck my friend.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Not much to say, other than I have bought one new truck in my life and it was a train wreck. Couldn't keep it out of the shop. As others have said the price is just stupid on a new one. I always try and find a low mileage used one. Usually takes me about 3 months to find it. Good luck and buy what you like, drive them all. 

  • Like 2
Posted

I think Ken should approach this as a project journal. Take pictures of the trucks he's considering. Pictures of him during the test drive. Maybe pictures of the salesperson and the dealership. Ending with a picture of the new truck with the happy owner standing beside it. Endless photo opportunities here! :D

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 54 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined