Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

The Wood Whisperer Guild

Building a Wood Whisperer Guild project? Ask questions about the plans, share your progress, and see how other members approached the same build.

  1. Started by AndremG,

    Is it just me, or do the v8 PDF plans not explicitly have a long stretcher dimension? You can infer it from the gap stop plan where it says that the dadoes are for clearance on the short stretchers, but you've got to do some math to get there. Will there be a v9 of the plans that will have this? No biggie. I was creating a story pole to see how the Roubo would fit into my cramped shop when I noticed the lack of an obvious leg-to-leg dimension. I imagine it's the 48-3/4" minus twice the remainder of leg width from the inside edge of the short stretcher to the inside edge of the leg. For the long stretcher length, just add the two tenons. Andy

      • Like
    • 16 replies
    • 5.2k views
  2. Started by Cynthia in BC,

    Hi all: I'm still on the fence about the bench. I'm probably most preoccupied with the level of difficulty and requirement for tools.....i.e. I don't have a band saw or a mortising machine........is this going to be possible with the basic power tools and hand tools? And intermediate.....not sure I've done anything this complex. Comments?

    • 11 replies
    • 4.2k views
  3. Started by Kevmc,

    I am getting ready for the build and from Marc's first post where he recommends the necessary tools he included a hand saw. I don't have a high qualit hand saw so I am using the build as a good excuse to get one. I was looking at the hand saws at lie Nielsen. Do you guys have any recommendations for whether a dovetail' carcass' crosscut or panel saw would make the most sense for the outbound build. Also any other brand recommendations. I was looking at bad axe saws and they look awesome but the lead time is too long for the build. Thanks

  4. Realized this is probably going to use up quite a bit a glue. Don't want to be caught in the middle of a glue up with not enough.

  5. Started by Eric.,

    Okay, so I'm a bit of a weirdo. Not exactly ambidextrous, just...weird. I throw left and bat right. Write left, swing a tennis racquet left, shoot a rifle or bow right. Cast a fly rod left. I saw left, but handplane right (right hand on the tote)...except with a block plane...left hand for that. When I chisel with a mallet, the chisel is in the right hand and the mallet is in the left. But for paring I use the left hand. My gut instinct tells me to go with the traditional bench configuration with leg vise on left and tail vise on right, but I couldn't give an explanation of why that seems right. I'd hate to build this thing and later realize I wish it were fli…

    • 8 replies
    • 4.6k views
  6. Started by Kevmc,

    A big thanks to Russ for making some pin handles for the latheless woodworkers doing the build. Russ was so awesome turning this handles with donated cocobolo and getting them shipped out. He graciously did this for a donation to the Salvation Army. His father even tool the brass nuts used for the ferrule and knocked off the edges to make them round. Now the pressure is on to make a bench worthy of the pin handle, a very tall task for someone with very little hand tool experience and certain not with a project this large. Thanks again Russ KC

    • 7 replies
    • 3.4k views
  7. Started by kaiser,

    Benchcrafted has a blog post on this subject and recommend brushing on the flaxseed oil. Well if you are as sloppy with a brush as I am, here is what I did. 1: Clean all the parts with warm soap and water. 2: Dry them in an oven on 200 degrees for 10-15 minutes. 3: This is the step I altered. And here is how it goes. Charge a paper towel with flaxseed oil and ring it out totally. Have 5 or 6clean towels on hand. Wipe down the parts with the charged paper towel. 4: proceed to wipe off any excess with the fresh towels and do not handle parts with bare hands. Your bare hands at this point will have oil on them and will leave excess oil on the parts if handled…

    • 2 replies
    • 3k views
  8. I sat down with some graph paper and worked on a cut list that makes sense to someone in a timber yard in the metric world. I grouped the timbers into one hardwood for the vises, dog holes etc and one for the rest (maple) so that the finished product well my one at least will have a nice contrast. Attached is the scanned pdf of the Roubo Metric cut list, what boards are cut from each piece and the standard timber types to buy. Hope this helps the others in the build playing in m rather than " Cheers Chas roubo-bench-metric.pdf

    • 5 replies
    • 4k views
  9. Hi, I'm thinking of doing a modification of adding a tool tray off the back of the bench. I'm thinking of making the bottom of the tool tray removable so that I can use it for clamping if needed. I was wondering if anyone had any thoughts on this idea. Andy

  10. OK, so I'm slowly watching the videos leading up to the Roubo bench and I'm trying to figure out where I'm going to get the wood. I heard in one of the videos "Why My Workbench Sucks" that it's going to be about 150-200 board feet of lumber. I thought of going out to Craigslist to see if anything popped up on there and I found this one: http://dallas.craigs...2753190119.html He just references $1.75 per foot for oak, not referencing board-feet. My question is whether this is a decent price for oak and if so, any ideas on whether it may work for most of what I need for the table? Sorry for the noob question but it's all I've got right now Mark

  11. Started by kaiser,

    Did anyone notice that there is 3" difference between the rabbet in the top for the wagon vise (14") and the dog hole strip length (17" less than the top)? Purpose for this? Does this allow for full travel on the vise screw?

    • 3 replies
    • 3.4k views
  12. Started by kaiser,

    Anyone needing some extra soft maple in the New York area. I have enough 12/4 for chop and end caps, I have enough 8/4 for almost another bench, and I have tons of 4/4. Let me know if anyone needs some. Not looking to make money on these, just figured if it can help anyone that has run short. I get this stuff for pretty good prices because I order 500 bf at a time. You can contact me anytime. Good luck with your build. Cheers, THE KAISER

    • 4 replies
    • 3.6k views
  13. Started by msmurray,

    Two summers ago I built a bench with the Benchcrafted tail vise and leg vise. I used a combination of the Benchcrafted plans, which are excellent, and the Christopher Schwartz’s Workbench book, which was indispensable. The bench was my first major project. If I could build one, anyone can. For me, the bench build was less technical and an easier build than the Shaker Table. It was absolutely easier than the Adirondack chair build. Mark's videos and advice will no doubt make this project doable for everyone. Random thoughts from the build: It took a few months. I bought 20 2x6x16 pine boards. The nice folks at the lumber yard were kind enough to cross-cut each of…

    • 3 replies
    • 4.4k views
  14. Started by dvoigt,

    Reviewing my on-going struggle on if I can build this bench (time and money being the consideration), I measured the area that I would need to put the bench. I can only fit a 6' bench max, and even that will take some rearranging. And I will need to make the bench moveable, not ideal for a bench of this weight, but I also consider a shorter 6' bench to be a plus for this. So I suppose my question is: at what point does a bench of this caliber suffer if it is too short? I don't do alot of really long things currently, but there is always the possibility that I will in the future and i don't want to out grow this bench. What is everyone's thought on this? How lon…

      • Like
    • 11 replies
    • 4.8k views
  15. Started by MTC,

    marc, I just signed up - my Christmas gift to myself - at the insistance of My wife - nice to know that we both have wives that support our addiction :-) Looking forward to working on my Roubo bench - have a VERY happy Christmas and a VERY prosperous 2012!! regards Michael

  16. Started by alaporte,

    Hi All Looking for some advice on how to pick up the lumber for this project. I was planning on using hard maple. The cost for 8/4 is $4.50 bf +$0.75 for boards over 8”. My first question is how is this compared to around your area? Now focusing mostly on the top I’m guessing that I would need boards over 8” if I expect to get 2 planks out of each board. So my second question is how do you deal with this as most boards seem to be 10-12” wide? Do you just consider the extra waste? My third question has to do on length of the boards. The lumber mill will cut boards shorter but in order to cut the boards you must leave at least 6’. I’m noticing most of the …

      • Like
    • 11 replies
    • 5.3k views
  17. Started by Stephens_Shop,

    So I am 100% all in but I would like to better understand how things will go when the build begins. Jan 2 is the "go date", so... Do we all bring our computers into the shop and build live with Marc? I know there are videos of all the steps are they posted on Jan 2? How exactly does a guild build go? The reason I am asking is that I am going to be off work the 1st week or so in January and want to know just what am I going to do to go along with the build during the first 1 or 2 weeks. Stephen.

  18. Started by AdamAronson,

    As far as I can tell the only dimensional difference between the two plans is the thickness and length of the gap stop. Has there been any discussion about why the guild build's gap stop is different? Longer makes sense (I guess)... what about thicker? Easier to dimension to the more rounded 8ths vs. 16ths perhaps? Are there any other differences I'm overlooking? Before committing to the guild build I purchased the BC plans and was planning on following them. Will I be confusing myself if I still plan on following the BC plans over the guild plans? Then again, I'm not entirely sure why I care. Thanks, Adam

    • 7 replies
    • 4.5k views
  19. Started by Joraft,

    Fortunately, I'm right in the process of putting my shop together, so I do have some latitude on the size of the work room where my Roubo will be located. I'm thinking about increasing the bench size from that in the plans, and adding a second tail vise. Benchcrafted offers both a right-hand and left-hand vise, so one of each will work out well. Any thoughts on that? I've been planning on building this bench since Jameel unveiled it at WIA back in 2009. It will almost certainly be the last bench I build, so I want to get it right. No doubt I'll wind up putting more time into designing it than actually building it. That's okay, both are fun.

      • Like
    • 54 replies
    • 17.5k views
  20. Started by Torch02,

    Andy over at the Oregon Woodworker has recently finished building his Nicholson bench. It's not a split top Roubo, but he does cover a lot of the interesting decision that are applicable to any workbench. It's worth checking out.

    • 1 reply
    • 3.5k views
  21. Started by woodcanuck,

    I was able to find a nice slab of soft maple 12"x16/4x7' (my bench will be on the shorter side). So I am thinking that I'll use the slab for the back half of the bench top and laminate up some 8/4 for the front half. Does anyone have any thoughts on using a slab top? I'm wondering if I have to make an accommodations for the single slab that I don't have to make for the laminated top. I would guess that wood movement won't be much different, although I imagine it could cup over time. Is anyone else using a single slab for one or both benchtop sections?

  22. Started by JeffB1,

    I saw this on the benchcrafted blog http://benchcrafted....de%20Leg%20Vise I'm going to give it a go I think it looks cool is anybody else trying it! It's more work but what the heck .

    • 3 replies
    • 4.3k views
  23. Started by konkers,

    I found a great deal on some reclaimed 4"x4" purpleheart railroad ties. I'm tempted to build my bench out of this but as Chris Wong pointed out on twitter, it's notoriously tough to work. Still I'm tempted. Am I crazy?

      • Like
    • 16 replies
    • 8.8k views
  24. Started by BrianPatton,

    had a question of the Roubo Build... 1. Total Cost of Build (Wood+Benchcraft accessories) 2. Tool list needed for build I am relatively new to woodworking and wonder how advanced you need to be to start this project with the guild? How much is the hardware as pictured/vise/etc (looks like around $700 from benchcraft page, but does that include the vise?) I am a bit limited in my tools at this point because of budget and wondered if you could list what we may need for a minimum set of tools to realistically do this project? Here is what I have now: Tablesaw 10", w/52" Table extension Festool 1400 Router, 150/3 EQ Sander, T55 saw, CT26 Dust Ext Basic chisel set, …

  25. Started by Cynthia in BC,

    I thought I'd start a new thread because I have several questions. I apologize in advance if any of them are stupid, but this is the only way I learn anything. 1. Does anyone know how many of us are doing this build? Also, if there is anyone else out there who is going to struggle through this project despite it being beyond their skill set (and who doesn't want to say so out loud) please feel free to send me a private message. I know of myself and one other person who are talking off-line to help each other. 2. Is there anyone out there who could label the drawing with the names of the pieces on the cut list? I'm happy to do it myself if anyone would want to tal…

    • 12 replies
    • 4.3k views

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.